Brown vs. Colgate

Brown and Colgate have 52 meetings on file, the first in 1908; Colgate leads the series 25–⁠20–⁠7 in the games on file. Over the last 10 meetings it’s even at 5–⁠5.

Brown wins
20
Colgate wins
25
Ties
7
Earliest on file
1908
Longest streak
12 Colgate
Current streak
1 Brown
Last 10 meetings
even at 5–⁠5
Most recent
2021

The series at a glance

Every meeting by decade, colored by the winner
’0’1’2’3’4’5’6’7’8’9W–L
1900s2–⁠0
1910s1–⁠2–⁠1
1920s4–⁠1–⁠3
1930s0–⁠8
1940s3–⁠4–⁠2
1950s4–⁠5–⁠1
1960s5–⁠3
1970s0–⁠2
2020s1–⁠0
Average margin
13.1 points; 17 decided by one score (8 or fewer)
At Brown
19–⁠22–⁠6 Brown’s record at home
At Colgate
3–⁠1–⁠1 Colgate’s record at home
Shutouts
18

Every meeting on file, as played. Ranks are the AP poll’s going in.

Games that tell the story

  1. Brown’s biggest win1948: Brown 35, Colgate 7by 28 points
  2. Colgate’s biggest win1966: Colgate 48, Brown 7by 41 points
  3. Upset1962: Brown 6, Colgate 2Brown had a 24% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  4. Upset1959: Colgate 33, Brown 14Colgate had a 29% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  5. Upset1965: Brown 6, Colgate 0Brown had a 34% chance, by our ratings before kickoff

Coach against coach

YearsBrownSeriesColgate
1919–⁠1921Edward Robinson2–⁠1Ellery Huntington Jr.
1929–⁠1940DeOrmond McLaughry0–⁠10Andrew Kerr
1944–⁠1946Rip Engle1–⁠1–⁠1Andrew Kerr
1947–⁠1949Rip Engle2–⁠0–⁠1Paul Bixler
1952–⁠1956Alva Kelley2–⁠2–⁠1Hal Lahar
1959–⁠1961John McLaughry1–⁠2Alva Kelley
1962–⁠1966John McLaughry2–⁠1Hal Lahar
1968–⁠1971Len Jardine1–⁠3Neil Wheelwright

Head-coach pairings with three or more meetings on file, the series read from Brown’s side (Robinson 2–⁠1 against Huntington). A season split between coaches goes to the one credited with the game.

Both programs through the years

End-of-season Elo ratings of Brown and Colgate, 1908 on130015001700192019401960198020002020

Our Elo rating at the end of each season, a measure of how strong a team was, not a forecast; 1500 is an average FBS team.

From the newspapers

  • The Evening star's story of the 1908 game: Brown Beats Colgate.

    1908 · Evening star, Washington, D.C., Oct 4, 1908

  • The New-York tribune's story of the 1909 game: BROWN BEATS COLG4TE. Mckay Makes T5cO TOuchdO5cns and Kicks Tzco Goals.

    1909 · New-York tribune, Oct 3, 1909

  • The Rock Island Argus's story of the 1910 game: Saturdays Football Scores SATURDAYS FOOTBALL SCORES.

    1910 · Rock Island Argus, Rock Island, Ill., Oct 10, 1910

  • The New Britain herald's story of the 1916 game: Jack R0urke Colgate Team Trim Brown, Pollard et. ~. Conquerors of Yale and Harvard Short End of 28-0 Score-Noted Negro Held in Check-Local r #s Boys Share in Glory

    1916 · New Britain herald, Connecticut, Dec 1, 1916

  • The Evening star's story of the 1917 game: BROWN DEFEATS COLGATE Brunonians Get Jump on Hamilton Boys and Win by Mar. row Margin.

    1917 · Evening star, District of Columbia, Oct 28, 1917

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The earliest meetings with a story on file; each game’s page has the full text.

Every game

Oct 9, 2021Brown 31, Colgate 10at Brown
Oct 23, 1971Colgate 42, Brown 32at Colgate
Oct 24, 1970Colgate 10, Brown 6at Brown
Oct 25, 1969Colgate 20, Brown 6at Brown
Oct 26, 1968Brown 27, Colgate 19at Brown
Oct 28, 1967Brown 7, Colgate 0at Brown
Oct 22, 1966Colgate 48, Brown 7at Brown
Oct 23, 1965Brown 6, Colgate 0at Brown
Sep 22, 1962Brown 6, Colgate 2at Colgate
Nov 23, 1961Colgate 30, Brown 6at Brown
Nov 19, 1960Brown 21, Colgate 14at Brown
Nov 26, 1959Colgate 33, Brown 14at Brown
Nov 27, 1958Brown 28, Colgate 6at Brown
Nov 28, 1957Brown 33, Colgate 7at Brown
Nov 22, 1956Brown 20, Colgate 0at Brown
Nov 24, 1955Colgate 25, Brown 0at Brown
Nov 25, 1954Brown 18, Colgate 14at Brown
Nov 21, 1953Brown 7, Colgate 7at Brown
Nov 29, 1952Colgate 33, Brown 27at Brown
Oct 20, 1951Colgate 32, Brown 14at Brown
Oct 28, 1950Colgate 35, Brown 34at Brown
Nov 26, 1949Brown 41, Colgate 26at Brown
Nov 20, 1948Brown 35, Colgate 7at Brown
Oct 25, 1947Colgate 13, Brown 13at Colgate
Nov 23, 1946Colgate 20, Brown 14at Brown
Nov 24, 1945Brown 6, Colgate 6at Brown
Nov 25, 1944Brown 32, Colgate 20at Brown
Nov 27, 1943Colgate 21, Brown 14at Brown
Nov 21, 1942Colgate 13, Brown 0at Brown
Oct 12, 1940Colgate 20, Brown 3at Brown
Oct 14, 1939Colgate 10, Brown 0at Colgate
Nov 28, 1936Colgate 32, Brown 0at Brown
Nov 30, 1935Colgate 33, Brown 0at Brown
Dec 1, 1934Colgate 20, Brown 13at Brown
Nov 25, 1933Colgate 25, Brown 0at Brown
Nov 19, 1932Colgate 21, Brown 0at Brown
Nov 28, 1931Colgate 13, Brown 7at Brown
Nov 29, 1930Colgate 27, Brown 0at Brown
Nov 30, 1929Colgate 32, Brown 0at Brown
Nov 29, 1928Brown 16, Colgate 13at Brown
Nov 26, 1927Brown 0, Colgate 0at Brown
Nov 27, 1926Brown 10, Colgate 10at Brown
Nov 28, 1925Brown 14, Colgate 14at Brown
Nov 29, 1924Brown 20, Colgate 6at Brown
Nov 19, 1921Brown 7, Colgate 0at Brown
Oct 16, 1920Brown 14, Colgate 0at Brown
Oct 11, 1919Colgate 14, Brown 0at Colgate
Oct 27, 1917Brown 7, Colgate 6at Brown
Nov 25, 1916Colgate 28, Brown 0at Brown
Oct 8, 1910Brown 0, Colgate 0at Brown
Oct 2, 1909Brown 14, Colgate 0at Brown
Oct 3, 1908Brown 6, Colgate 0at Brown

Every game is listed as played on the field.