Navy vs. William & Mary

Navy and William & Mary have 42 meetings on file, the first in 1923; Navy leads the series 35–⁠6–⁠1 in the games on file. Over the last 10 meetings it’s Navy 7–⁠3, and William & Mary has won the last 2.

Navy wins
35
William & Mary wins
6
Ties
1
Earliest on file
1923
Longest streak
12 Navy
Current streak
2 William & Mary
Last 10 meetings
Navy 7–⁠3
Most recent
1991

The series at a glance

Every meeting by decade, colored by the winner
’0’1’2’3’4’5’6’7’8’9W–L
1920s4–⁠0
1930s9–⁠1
1940s2–⁠1
1950s7–⁠0–⁠1
1960s6–⁠1
1970s4–⁠1
1980s3–⁠1
1990s0–⁠1
Average margin
19 points; 9 decided by one score (8 or fewer)
At Navy
34–⁠6–⁠1 Navy’s record at home
Neutral sites
1–⁠0 Navy first
Shutouts
17

Every meeting on file, as played. Ranks are the AP poll’s going in.

Games that tell the story

  1. Navy’s biggest win1937: Navy 45, William & Mary 0by 45 points
  2. William & Mary’s biggest win1987: William & Mary 27, Navy 12by 15 points
  3. Upset1987: William & Mary 27, Navy 12William & Mary had a 30% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  4. Upset1967: William & Mary 27, Navy 16William & Mary had a 32% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  5. Upset1991: William & Mary 26, Navy 21William & Mary had a 33% chance, by our ratings before kickoff

Coach against coach

YearsNavySeriesWilliam & Mary
1931–⁠1933Rip Miller2–⁠1John Kellison
1939–⁠1941Swede Larson3–⁠0Carl Voyles
1952–⁠1956Eddie Erdelatz4–⁠0–⁠1Jack Freeman
1959–⁠1963Wayne Hardin4–⁠0Milt Drewer
1965–⁠1967William Elias2–⁠1Marv Levy
1976–⁠1979George Welsh3–⁠1Jim Root

Head-coach pairings with three or more meetings on file, the series read from Navy’s side (Miller 2–⁠1 against Kellison). A season split between coaches goes to the one credited with the game.

Both programs through the years

End-of-season Elo ratings of Navy and William & Mary, 1923 on13001500170019401960198020002020

Our Elo rating at the end of each season, a measure of how strong a team was, not a forecast; 1500 is an average FBS team.

From the newspapers

  • The The Birmingham age-herald's story of the 1923 game: NAVY WINS FROM WILLIAM & MARY BY 39-TO-IO SCORE

    1923 · The Birmingham age-herald, Alabama, Sep 30, 1923

  • The Evening star's story of the 1953 game: Return of 4 Players BoIsfers Dartmouth For Game With Navy

    1953 · Evening star, Oct 2, 1953

  • The Evening star's story of the 1954 game: Irish Beut Texas, 27-0;;Novy,VIginio Win, but CIV Loses

    1954 · Evening star, Washington, D.C., Sep 26, 1954

  • The Evening star's story of the 1961 game: Middies Had Best Beware Of Miomi's Mira and Miller

    1961 · Evening star, Oct 5, 1961

  • The Evening star's story of the 1962 game: NAVY

    1962 · Evening star, Oct 1, 1962

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The earliest meetings with a story on file; each game’s page has the full text.

Photos

From the rivalry’s and its games’ categories on Wikimedia Commons (free licenses only, each credited), and the Library of Congress’s Prints & Photographs Division (no known restrictions on publication).

Every game

Sep 21, 1991William & Mary 26, Navy 21at Navy
Sep 12, 1987William & Mary 27, Navy 12at Navy
Oct 16, 1982Navy 39, William & Mary 3at Navy
Oct 24, 1981Navy 27, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 27, 1980Navy 45, William & Mary 6at Navy
Oct 13, 1979Navy 24, William & Mary 7Neutral site
Oct 21, 197817Navy 9, William & Mary 0at Navy
Oct 22, 1977Navy 42, William & Mary 17at Navy
Oct 16, 1976William & Mary 21, Navy 13at Navy
Sep 16, 1972Navy 13, William & Mary 9at Navy
Oct 21, 1967William & Mary 27, Navy 16at Navy
Oct 22, 1966Navy 21, William & Mary 0at Navy
Oct 9, 1965Navy 42, William & Mary 14at Navy
Sep 26, 196410Navy 35, William & Mary 6at Navy
Sep 28, 19635Navy 28, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 29, 1962Navy 20, William & Mary 16at Navy
Sep 30, 1961Navy 44, William & Mary 6at Navy
Sep 26, 195913Navy 29, William & Mary 2at Navy
Sep 27, 195812Navy 14, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 28, 19575Navy 33, William & Mary 6at Navy
Sep 29, 1956Navy 39, William & Mary 14at Navy
Sep 24, 1955Navy 7, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 25, 1954Navy 27, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 26, 195313Navy 6, William & Mary 6at Navy
Oct 11, 195217Navy 14, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 26, 1942William & Mary 3, Navy 0at Navy
Sep 27, 1941Navy 34, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 28, 1940Navy 19, William & Mary 7at Navy
Sep 30, 1939Navy 31, William & Mary 6at Navy
Sep 24, 1938Navy 26, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 25, 1937Navy 45, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 26, 1936Navy 18, William & Mary 6at Navy
Sep 28, 1935Navy 30, William & Mary 0at Navy
Sep 29, 1934Navy 20, William & Mary 7at Navy
Sep 30, 1933Navy 12, William & Mary 0at Navy
Oct 1, 1932William & Mary 6, Navy 0at Navy
Oct 3, 1931Navy 13, William & Mary 6at Navy
Oct 4, 1930Navy 19, William & Mary 6at Navy
Oct 5, 1929Navy 15, William & Mary 0at Navy
Oct 3, 1925Navy 25, William & Mary 0at Navy
Oct 4, 1924Navy 14, William & Mary 7at Navy
Sep 29, 1923Navy 39, William & Mary 10at Navy

Every game is listed as played on the field.