Toledo at Western Michigan

Saturday, September 9, 2006

Western Michigan beat Toledo 31–⁠10. It was their 45th meeting; after it, Toledo led the series 29–⁠16.

AwayToledo5–⁠7 in 2006
10
HomeWestern Michigan8–⁠5 in 2006
31

Final at Waldo Stadium, KalamazooAttendance 24,806

At kickoff
61°F, overcast, haze, wind 9 mph from the northWeather: NOAA NCEI Integrated Surface Database; Klmazo/Btl Creek International Airport (KAZO), 8 km from the stadium, seven minutes before kickoff

Scoring by quarter

TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
Toledo0100010
Western Michigan70141031

Standouts

Player stats

Toledo

PassingC/AttYdsTDInt
Clint Cochran18/3021802
Brandon Summers0/1001
RushingCarYdsTDLong
Jalen Parmele17111020
Richard Davis81715
ReceivingRecYdsTDLong
Chris Hopkins4100041
Steve Odom552021
Jalen Parmele228025
Richard Davis2906

Western Michigan

PassingC/AttYdsTDInt
Thomas Peregrin11/159820
RushingCarYdsTDLong
Mark Bonds22134157
Chris Maragos21209
Thomas Peregrin41105
Kirk Elsworth1404
ReceivingRecYdsTDLong
Mark Bonds332016
Branden Ledbetter128128
Herb Martin318018
Chris Maragos111011
InterceptionsIntYdsTD
Londen Fryar21061
C.J. Wilson100

From CollegeFootballData’s box score. Names lead to each player’s page. ★ a career high on file.

Team stats

ToledoWestern Michigan
306Total yards261
261Passing yards98
88Rushing yards163
7.0Yards per pass6.5
2.8Yards per rush5.1
17First downs11
7–⁠15Third downs4–⁠12
1–⁠2Fourth downs3–⁠3
5Turnovers0
8–⁠50Penalties6–⁠40
20:03Possession16:37

Efficiency

ToledoWestern Michigan
37%Success rate33%
0.13EPA per play0.03
1.25Explosiveness1.07
0.05Rushing EPA−0.04
0.18Passing EPA0.27
33%Passing-down success9%
−0.11First-down EPA0.06
−0.32Second-down EPA−0.33
1.01Third-down EPA0.15

From CollegeFootballData.com: each offense’s efficiency, and the havoc each defense caused. The better side of each line is bold.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Toledo 57% to win. Western Michigan won as Elo’s underdog.

Every drive

Western Michigan end zoneToledo end zoneQ1 ToledoPunt, 4 playsQ1 Western MichiganTouchdown run, 12 playsQ1 ToledoInterception, 3 playsQ1 Western MichiganMissed FG, 8 playsQ1 ToledoField goal, 14 playsQ2 Western MichiganPunt, 3 playsQ2 ToledoTouchdown run, 10 playsQ2 Western MichiganPunt, 3 playsQ2 ToledoEnd of halfQ3 Western MichiganTouchdown pass, 6 playsQ3 ToledoPunt, 6 playsQ3 Western MichiganPunt, 3 playsQ3 ToledoDefensive TD, 7 plays (Western Michigan scores)Q3 Western MichiganResult not recorded, 1 playQ3 ToledoTurnover on downs, 11 playsQ4 Western MichiganField goal, 6 playsQ4 ToledoFumble, 6 playsQ4 Western MichiganTouchdown pass, 7 playsQ4 ToledoInterception, 3 playsQ4 Western MichiganEnd of game, 1 play
Solid bars scored; an outline in the other team’s color marks points the defense scored. Western Michigan drives left to right, Toledo right to left.
  1. Q1 ToledoPunt, 4 plays, 25 yards
  2. Q1 Western MichiganTouchdown run, 12 plays, 66 yards
  3. Q1 ToledoInterception, 3 plays, 5 yards
  4. Q1 Western MichiganMissed FG, 8 plays, 6 yards
  5. Q1 ToledoField goal, 14 plays, 51 yards
  6. Q2 Western MichiganPunt, 3 plays, 6 yards
  7. Q2 ToledoTouchdown run, 10 plays, 74 yards
  8. Q2 Western MichiganPunt, 3 plays, 8 yards
  9. Q2 ToledoEnd of half, 16 yards
  10. Q3 Western MichiganTouchdown pass, 6 plays, 36 yards
  11. Q3 ToledoPunt, 6 plays, 25 yards
  12. Q3 Western MichiganPunt, 3 plays, 3 yards
  13. Q3 ToledoDefensive TD, 7 plays (Western Michigan scores), 47 yards
  14. Q3 Western MichiganResult not recorded, 1 play, 3 yards
  15. Q3 ToledoTurnover on downs, 11 plays, 49 yards
  16. Q4 Western MichiganField goal, 6 plays, 66 yards
  17. Q4 ToledoFumble, 6 plays, 14 yards
  18. Q4 Western MichiganTouchdown pass, 7 plays, 49 yards
  19. Q4 ToledoInterception, 3 plays, −5 yards
  20. Q4 Western MichiganEnd of game, 1 play, 1 yard

Play by play

1st quarter5 drives, then Western Michigan 7, Toledo 0
Toledo Punt, 4 plays
14:301st & 10 at own 20Clint Cochran pass complete to Jalen Parmele for 24 yards to the Toled 44 for a 1ST down.
14:001st & 10 at own 44Jalen Parmele rush for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 43.
13:272nd & 11 at own 43Clint Cochran pass complete to Steve Odom for 2 yards to the Toled 45.
12:503rd & 9 at own 45Clint Cochran pass incomplete.
12:424th & 9 at own 45Matt Shumaker punt for 21 yards punt out-of-bounds at the WMich 34.
Western Michigan Touchdown run, 12 plays
11:551st & 10 at own 34Chris Maragos rush for 9 yards to the WMich 43.
11:372nd & 1 at own 43Brandon West rush for a loss of 1 yard to the WMich 42.
11:373rd & 2 at own 42Thomas Peregrin rush for 5 yards to the WMich 47 for a 1ST down.
10:501st & 10 at own 47Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Mark Bonds for 12 yards to the Toled 41 for a 1ST down.
10:291st & 10 at opp 41Mark Bonds rush for 5 yards to the Toled 36.
10:292nd & 5 at opp 36Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Herb Martin for 1 yard to the Toled 35.
9:473rd & 4 at opp 35Timeout TOLEDO, clock 09:47.
9:183rd & 4 at opp 35Thomas Peregrin rush for no gain to the Toled 35.
8:384th & 4 at opp 35Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Dennis Reedy for 5 yards to the Toled 30 for a 1ST down.
8:201st & 10 at opp 30Mark Bonds rush for 3 yards to the Toled 27.
7:432nd & 7 at opp 27Mark Bonds rush for 4 yards to the Toled 23.
7:193rd & 3 at opp 23Kirk Elsworth rush for 4 yards to the Toled 19 for a 1ST down.
6:551st & 10 at opp 19Mark Bonds rush for 19 yards for a TOUCHDOWN.Western Michigan 6, Toledo 0
6:55Nate Meyer extra point GOOD.Western Michigan 7, Toledo 0
6:50Nate Meyer kickoff for 65 yards for a touchback.
Toledo Interception, 3 plays
6:221st & 10 at own 20Jalen Parmele rush for no gain to the Toled 20.
5:552nd & 10 at own 20Clint Cochran pass complete to Steve Odom for 5 yards to the Toled 25.
5:003rd & 5 at own 25Clint Cochran pass intercepted by CJ Wilson at the Toled 37, returned for no gain to the Toled 37.
Western Michigan Missed FG, 8 plays
4:271st & 10 at opp 37Mark Bonds rush for 5 yards to the Toled 32.
3:542nd & 5 at opp 32Mark Bonds rush for a loss of 2 yards to the Toled 34.
3:223rd & 7 at opp 34Mark Bonds rush for 4 yards to the Toled 30.
2:464th & 3 at opp 30Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Chris Maragos for 11 yards to the Toled 19 for a 1ST down.
2:251st & 10 at opp 19Westrn Michigan penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
2:251st & 15 at opp 24Westrn Michigan penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
1:531st & 20 at opp 29Thomas Peregrin pass incomplete to Dennis Reedy.
1:492nd & 20 at opp 29Thomas Peregrin pass incomplete to Chris Maragos.
1:493rd & 20 at opp 29Westrn Michigan penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
1:233rd & 25 at opp 34Thomas Peregrin rush for 3 yards to the Toled 31.
1:104th & 22 at opp 31Nate Meyer 49 yard field goal MISSED.
Toledo Field goal, 14 plays
0:431st & 10 at own 31Jalen Parmele rush for 20 yards to the WMich 49 for a 1ST down.
0:151st & 10 at opp 49Jeff Green rush for 1 yard to the WMich 48.
Q2 14:392nd & 9 at opp 48Clint Cochran pass complete to John Allen for 3 yards to the WMich 45.
Q2 14:183rd & 6 at opp 45Toledo penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
Q2 13:523rd & 11 at the 50Clint Cochran pass complete to Steve Odom for 21 yards to the WMich 29 for a 1ST down.
Q2 13:151st & 10 at opp 29Jeff Green rush for 3 yards to the WMich 26.
Q2 12:462nd & 7 at opp 26Jeff Green rush for 2 yards to the WMich 24.
Q2 12:153rd & 5 at opp 24Clint Cochran pass incomplete to John Allen.
Q2 12:144th & 5 at opp 24Clint Cochran pass complete to Jeff Green for 6 yards to the WMich 18 for a 1ST down.
Q2 12:041st & 10 at opp 18Toledo penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
Q2 11:331st & 15 at opp 23Jalen Parmele rush for 4 yards to the WMich 19.
Q2 11:032nd & 11 at opp 19Clint Cochran pass complete to Steve Odom for 14 yards to the WMich 5 for a 1ST down.
Q2 10:331st & goal at opp 5Jalen Parmele rush for a loss of 1 yard to the WMich 6.
Q2 9:452nd & goal at opp 6Clint Cochran sacked by Ameer Ismail at the WMich 13 for a loss of 7 yards.
Q2 9:213rd & 0 at opp 13Toledo penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
Q2 8:553rd & 0 at opp 18Clint Cochran pass incomplete to John Allen.
Q2 8:504th & 0 at opp 18Alex Steigerwald 36 yard field goal GOOD.Western Michigan 7, Toledo 3
Q2 8:45Michael Krispinsky kickoff for 65 yards for a touchback.
2nd quarter3 drives, then Toledo 10, Western Michigan 7
Western Michigan Punt, 3 plays
7:521st & 10 at own 20Chris Maragos rush for 2 yards to the WMich 22.
7:302nd & 8 at own 22Mark Bonds rush for 4 yards to the WMich 26.
7:023rd & 4 at own 26Thomas Peregrin pass incomplete to Chris Maragos.
6:504th & 4 at own 26Jim Laney punt for 33 yards, returned by Steve Odom for a loss of 5 yards to the Toled 36, Toledo penalty 10 yard holding accepted.
Toledo Touchdown run, 10 plays
6:001st & 10 at own 26Jalen Parmele rush for 2 yards to the Toled 28.
5:332nd & 8 at own 28Clint Cochran pass complete to Stephen Williams for 6 yards to the Toled 34.
4:563rd & 2 at own 34Jalen Parmele rush for 3 yards to the Toled 37 for a 1ST down.
5:331st & 10 at own 37Jalen Parmele rush for 4 yards to the Toled 41.
5:002nd & 6 at own 41Clint Cochran pass complete to Stephen Williams for 4 yards to the Toled 45.
4:273rd & 2 at own 45Clint Cochran pass complete to Andrew Hawkins for 4 yards to the Toled 49 for a 1ST down.
4:111st & 10 at own 49Jalen Parmele rush for 12 yards to the WMich 39 for a 1ST down.
3:401st & 10 at opp 39Clint Cochran pass complete to Jalen Parmele for 10 yards to the WMich 29 for a 1ST down.
3:001st & 10 at opp 29Clint Cochran pass complete to Stephen Williams for 24 yards to the WMich 5 for a 1ST down.
2:141st & goal at opp 5Jeff Green rush for 5 yards for a TOUCHDOWN.Toledo 10, Western Michigan 7
2:14Alex Steigerwald extra point GOOD.
2:04Michael Krispinsky kickoff for 64 yards returned by Brandon West for 26 yards to the WMich 27.
Western Michigan Punt, 3 plays
1:451st & 10 at own 27Thomas Peregrin pass incomplete to Dennis Reedy.
1:092nd & 10 at own 27Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Mark Bonds for 5 yards to the WMich 32.
0:403rd & 5 at own 32Mark Bonds rush for 3 yards to the WMich 35.
0:074th & 2 at own 35Jim Laney punt for 45 yards, returned by Steve Odom for a loss of 6 yards to the Toled 14.
Q3 14:551st & 10 at own 35Toledo penalty 5 yard OF accepted.
Q3 14:38Michael Krispinsky kickoff for 53 yards returned by Brandon West for 47 yards to the Toled 36.
3rd quarter5 drives, then Western Michigan 21, Toledo 10
Western Michigan Touchdown pass, 6 plays
14:031st & 10 at opp 36Mark Bonds rush for 1 yard to the Toled 35.
13:062nd & 9 at opp 35Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Herb Martin for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 36.
12:553rd & 10 at opp 36Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Mark Bonds for 16 yards to the Toled 20 for a 1ST down.
12:471st & 10 at opp 20Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Herb Martin for 18 yards to the Toled 2 for a 1ST down.
12:321st & goal at opp 2Mark Bonds rush for no gain to the Toled 2.
12:102nd & goal at opp 2Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Keith Schultz for 2 yards for a TOUCHDOWN.Western Michigan 13, Toledo 10
12:10Nate Meyer extra point GOOD.Western Michigan 14, Toledo 10
12:06Nate Meyer kickoff for 65 yards for a touchback.
Toledo Punt, 6 plays
11:361st & 10 at own 20Clint Cochran pass incomplete to Steve Odom.
11:142nd & 10 at own 20Jalen Parmele rush for 8 yards to the Toled 28.
10:543rd & 2 at own 28Jalen Parmele rush for 12 yards to the Toled 40 for a 1ST down.
10:251st & 10 at own 40Jalen Parmele rush for 5 yards to the Toled 45.
10:022nd & 5 at own 45Clint Cochran pass incomplete to John Allen.
9:573rd & 5 at own 45Clint Cochran pass incomplete to Justin Guy.
9:494th & 5 at own 45Matt Shumaker punt for 43 yards, fair catch by Dennis Reedy at the WMich 12.
Western Michigan Punt, 3 plays
9:141st & 10 at own 12Mark Bonds rush for 3 yards to the WMich 15.
8:542nd & 7 at own 15Westrn Michigan penalty 5 yard false start accepted.
8:202nd & 12 at own 10Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Mark Bonds for 4 yards to the WMich 14.
7:463rd & 8 at own 14Thomas Peregrin rush for 1 yard to the WMich 15.
7:234th & 7 at own 15Jim Laney punt for 47 yards, returned by Steve Odom for a loss of 2 yards to the Toled 36.
Toledo Defensive TD, 7 plays (Western Michigan scores)
7:231st & 10 at own 36Toledo penalty 10 yard holding accepted.
6:481st & 10 at own 26Clint Cochran pass complete to Jalen Parmele for 3 yards to the Toled 29.
6:262nd & 7 at own 29Jalen Parmele rush for 20 yards to the Toled 49 for a 1ST down.
5:561st & 10 at own 49Jeff Green rush for 3 yards to the WMich 48.
5:232nd & 7 at opp 48Clint Cochran pass complete to Jeff Green for 3 yards to the WMich 45.
4:483rd & 4 at opp 45Clint Cochran pass complete to Chris Hopkins for 22 yards to the WMich 23 for a 1ST down.
4:301st & 10 at opp 23Jalen Parmele rush for 6 yards to the WMich 17.
3:472nd & 4 at opp 17Clint Cochran pass intercepted by Londen Fryar at the WMich 8, returned for 92 yards for a TOUCHDOWN.Western Michigan 20, Toledo 10
3:471st & 0 at opp 3Westrn Michigan penalty 5 yard illegal motion accepted, no play.
3:47Nate Meyer extra point GOOD.Western Michigan 21, Toledo 10
3:42Nate Meyer kickoff for 65 yards for a touchback.
Toledo Turnover on downs, 11 plays
3:101st & 10 at own 20Jalen Parmele rush for 3 yards to the Toled 23.
2:452nd & 7 at own 23Jalen Parmele rush for 3 yards to the Toled 26.
2:123rd & 4 at own 26Clint Cochran pass complete to Chris Hopkins for 17 yards to the Toled 43 for a 1ST down.
1:501st & 10 at own 43Jalen Parmele rush for 11 yards to the WMich 46 for a 1ST down.
1:301st & 10 at opp 46Jeff Green rush for 1 yard to the WMich 45.
0:562nd & 9 at opp 45Clint Cochran pass incomplete to Chris Hopkins.
0:463rd & 9 at opp 45Clint Cochran pass complete to Chris Hopkins for 41 yards to the WMich 4 for a 1ST down.
0:151st & goal at opp 4Jeff Green rush for a loss of 1 yard to the WMich 5.
Q4 14:372nd & goal at opp 5Clint Cochran sacked by Ameer Ismail at the WMich 14 for a loss of 9 yards.
Q4 13:363rd & goal at opp 14Clint Cochran sacked by Cory Flom at the WMich 24 for a loss of 10 yards.
Q4 13:084th & 0 at opp 24Clint Cochran rush for a loss of 7 yards to the WMich 31, Toledo penalty illegal motion declined.
4th quarter5 drives, then Western Michigan 31, Toledo 10
Western Michigan Field goal, 6 plays
12:301st & 10 at own 31Thomas Peregrin rush for 4 yards to the WMich 35.
12:102nd & 6 at own 35Mark Bonds rush for 57 yards to the Toled 8 for a 1ST down.
11:401st & goal at opp 8Mark Bonds rush for 3 yards to the Toled 5.
10:552nd & goal at opp 5Mark Bonds rush for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 6.
10:093rd & goal at opp 6Brandon West rush for 3 yards to the Toled 3.
9:254th & goal at opp 3Nate Meyer 22 yard field goal GOOD.Western Michigan 24, Toledo 10
9:19Nate Meyer kickoff for 40 yards out-of-bounds.
Toledo Fumble, 6 plays
8:591st & 10 at own 35Clint Cochran pass incomplete to Chris Hopkins.
8:592nd & 10 at own 35Toledo penalty 5 yard illegal participation accepted.
8:382nd & 15 at own 30Clint Cochran pass complete to Justin Guy for 5 yards to the Toled 35.
8:053rd & 10 at own 35Clint Cochran pass complete to Chris Hopkins for 20 yards to the WMich 45 for a 1ST down.
7:581st & 10 at opp 45Clint Cochran pass incomplete.
7:532nd & 10 at opp 45Clint Cochran pass incomplete to John Allen.
7:453rd & 10 at opp 45Clint Cochran rush for a loss of 6 yards, fumbled at the Toled 49, recovered by Ameer Ismail at the Toled 49.
Western Michigan Touchdown pass, 7 plays
7:121st & 10 at opp 49Mark Bonds rush for 8 yards to the Toled 41.
6:182nd & 2 at opp 41Mark Bonds rush for 1 yard to the Toled 40.
5:453rd & 1 at opp 40Mark Bonds rush for 3 yards to the Toled 37 for a 1ST down.
5:001st & 10 at opp 37Mark Bonds rush for 8 yards to the Toled 29.
4:202nd & 2 at opp 29Mark Bonds rush for no gain to the Toled 29.
3:273rd & 2 at opp 29Mark Bonds rush for no gain to the Toled 29.
3:084th & 2 at opp 29Thomas Peregrin pass complete to Brandon Ledbetter for 29 yards for a TOUCHDOWN.Western Michigan 31, Toledo 10
3:08Nate Meyer extra point GOOD.
2:50Nate Meyer kickoff for 63 yards returned by Jeff Green for 21 yards to the Toled 23.
Toledo Interception, 3 plays
2:101st & 10 at own 23Brandon Summers sacked by Matt Ludeman at the Toled 13 for a loss of 10 yards.
2:002nd & 20 at own 13Toledo penalty 5 yard delay of game accepted.
1:112nd & 25 at own 8Brandon Summers rush for 10 yards to the Toled 18.
0:433rd & 15 at own 18Timeout TOLEDO, clock 00:43.
0:303rd & 15 at own 18Brandon Summers pass intercepted by Londen Fryar at the Toled 44, returned for 14 yards to the Toled 30.
Western Michigan End of game, 1 play
0:001st & 10 at opp 30Caleb Clark rush for 1 yard to the Toled 29.

Play-by-play from CollegeFootballData.com, as its scorers wrote it. The clock is the time left in the quarter; the spot is from the side of the team with the ball.

Toledo leads 39–⁠24 in 63 meetings, counting the 18 since this game.

Recent meetings
2025Western Michigan 14, Toledo 13
2023Toledo 49, Western Michigan 31
2022Western Michigan 20, Toledo 14
2021Toledo 34, Western Michigan 15
2020Western Michigan 41, Toledo 38
2019Toledo 31, Western Michigan 24

Around this game