Carlisle at Harvard
Saturday, October 28, 1899 Share
Harvard beat Carlisle 22–10. It was their third meeting; after it, Harvard led the series 3–0.
FinalHigh 69°F, low 49°F, 0.04 in. of rainAttendance 13,000
In the newspapers

New-York tribune, New York [N.Y.], October 29, 1899, page 1
Read the text
THE WINNING RUN. HARVARD Downs THE INDIANS. CAMBRIDGE ELEVEN MAKES A FINE SHOW Nc ID TO 10 TNE SCORE. ING-22 TO 10 TIE SlONf. Cambridge. Mass. oct % (speciaD.-In the most spectacular game Of the season Harvard exceeded all expectations this afternoon by rolling up tventv-tvvo points against the Carlisle Indians. The latter scored ten points by touchdown ana drop goal from the field by Hudson, but were COM pletoly outcassed in all departments OF the game The Harvard team. with the exception or fumbling played a superb game IialloweFs pununs WAS the best seen this year. for the kicks not only evceeded Mnler’s in distance. but were all beautfully placed and time and again the Indians were forced to bring the ball from the side line few yards IN front Of their goal line The Harvard men were moro aggressive IMAM their oponents and I’m far better condition. in spite Of the two twenty minute halves played in close ond damn atmosphere. Not Harvard man was hurt although several were taken out 20 give inc substitutes trials: but the Indians were continually laid out and Wheelock had 10 be carried from the fold In fact the game was considerably deiayeo by the Indians. Before tho substitutes went Into the game In the second half Harvard’s defence perfect. the red rner failing % make gains and not even getting near enough to the goal line TO allow Hudson 10 try for a drop kick The Indian ends were passed and their centre was repeatedly attacked for gains FEATURES OF THE GAME. The frequent kicking. the fumbing. Hudsons three tries for goals from the field and his single success Burnetts TWO tries for place kicks from the field and his single success. Elliss smashing plunges through the line. Redwater’s long run for a touchdown in the first minute OF play, and, finally, the Indians superby strong finish all contributed TO a game which repeatedly brought the loVD spec tators to their feet with tremendous demonstratons. Burnett kicked or. and the Indians sub sequontly held for downs and were compelled 20 punt Gierasch mufed the kick. which was poor. and Redwater fell on the bail on the Indians forty 1--WE yard line but recovered his feet Immediately i rsft .rfffn handicap ~ five yards and gained and tackled him Just the goal line was crossed. Wheeler failed TO Kick the goal. Burnett again kicked off and himself oC%ned Hudson VINO was Ietii l VIII. the ball. The Indians made their first down. but hudson TOOK IL To- me inldde OF ‘He nero on mar wards tumble. The Indians were forced 10 kick, from the middle Of the field the fifteen yard limo on fake kick Ellis made short gains through Diy then scorer “a t0rciu9@n lar ou a’ou5G LEY Kicked the goal Score: to D. GOOD WORK OF HARVARDs FULLBACK. After seesawing about the middle Of the field Ellis broke through and blocked one Of Hudson’s kicks. and fell on the bail on the Indians twenty five yard line. lie then went at the Indians centre and right tackle and scored IN four plays. Law During me remainder Of re half the ball was In time when Hudson failed in a drop kick from the in the second half Days return Of the Kick OFF bit Hudson head. and the ball was Haryard’s. soon hail9wel l4nlieH out on the INDIANS twenty hoeled the BAN on The forty-iVe yard line Burnett Miller punted again and This time Burnett kicked I}y short rushes through Eaton and Swain who bad been substituted for Donald and Lawrence. Hudson had second chance for drop kick. which siderable kicking followed until the Indians FUN he bah To- the ,hfec yard inc kendall. on the second try around lcft end. scored and DAILY kicked BY this time Harvarl’s tackles were weakening

The Anaconda standard, Anaconda, Mont., October 29, 1899, page 1
Read the text
KNIGHTS OF THE CR|D|RON Desperate Battle Between Penn sylvania and Chicago Resulted in a Tie. HARVARD AND CARLISLE in Disposing OF the Indians at Cam bridge-Columoia Won From Yale in a Great Contese-Cornell Took Vic tory From Princeton by a Score OF s to O. chicago, oct So.--l ne loolodi eieNoAi of the University Of Pennsylvania barely escaped defeat at the hands q the University Of Chicago in game in which the desperate playing has seldom been equaled. The final score was tie, both sides scoring touch down in the second half and neither kicking against It. Total to S. The game was free from rough playing. Through poor generalship on the part of Captain Kennedy of Chicago in at tempting to send Stacker through PENN sylvania’s left guard, he lost the ball within two yards of the goal line in the second half, and when, finally, few moments later, Wellington was pushed over for the tieing touchdown, the Chicago captain missed an easy goal. 1t was his attempt at fake kick, too, that ultimately resulted in Pennsylvania score, Kennedy drop ping the ball when tackled and Penn sylvania securing it on Chicago’s A. yard line. With Chicago’s goal in sight Pennsylvania’s big guards tore the maroon line to pieces and David son was finally pushed over But Chi cago’s goal line was not again in dan ger. I9dIiS i’ll uHe ITSl liGll SsAASdAA discovered that PennsJlvania’s left end was weak. and time and again Hammil and Wellington got around for suostantial gains. But with the ball with in a yard of the goal line, Pennsylvania made the most desperate stand of the game. Three times the line held and when the mass of players untangled after the last down, the ball was still a foot from the line. Coombs an in slant later punted out of danger, and when time was called the ball was en- Chicago’s 45-yard line. Chicago’s all around playing was superior to that of the Quakers. The lat ter were utterly unable to get around the maroons’ end and in the first half were frequently held for downs. even when using the dreaded guards back play, which has brought victory to the red and blue In many games. IN the second half. however, the awful ham, mering told severely in the Chicago forwards and during the second series Of plays which resulted in Pennsyl, Vania’ S touchdown they were played off their feet. Most Of the time dur ing the second half the ball was well within Pennsylvania’s territory, and only the f1ercest kind Of playing by the well nigh exhausted Quakers saved them from defeat. Notwithstanding the fact that rain lao btSil SlSdu!lS since ing. the gridiron at Marshall field was in fair condition. Frequent applications of saWdust kept the field from becoming soft. A crowd Of fully 6O0C enthusiasts witnessed the struggle, in. cluding several hundred rooters for the red and blue of Pennsylvania, and the latter team did not lack encoura cement so far as cheering was concerned. Totai score: Pennsylvania, s; Chicago, 5. The teams lined up as follows: Pennsylvania. Position. Chicago Coombs fright End. go. Cassells Wallace fright Tackle. .... Webb Teas .......Right Guard. Ahlswede Overfleld ......Center.. r............ Speed Hare ........ Left Guard. Flanagan Shower ......Left Tackle. Felt Potter .......Left End ., Henry Outland 49,. Quarterback. ...... Kenny McCrackers Right Half..... Hammil Kennedy ......Left Half. Wellington Davidson Full Back. ..... . Stacker Umpire-H. f. Williams, Yale Referee-R. .. Wrenn, Harvard.
The San Francisco call, California, October 29, 1899
Read the text
HARVARD DEFEATS CARLISLE Indians Succeed in Scoring en- Points Against the Crimson. Harvard 22, Carlisle 10. CAMBRIDGE, Mass, Oct. 2S.-While Harvard had no difficulty in disposing of the famous Carlisle Indian eleven this afternoon on Soldiers field, the crimson players were unable to keep little Hudson from kicking his customary goal from the field and a wretched muff by Girasch early in the game, followed by quick pickup by Red Water, who ran fifty yards for a touchdown, gave the visitors five more points, making the final score % to 10. There was bad fumbling by the Harvard backs at times and during the latter part of the game the Indians, discovering a weak spot in the crimson line, hammered there for steady gains until the thirty yard line was reached After two downs without result Hudson drove the ball between the goal posts. The little Indian quarterback, however, did not have all the kicking honors to himself, for Burnett made fine goal from a place kick on the Indians fifty-yard line and Hallowell’s punting was almost as good as HaughtonS last year. The entire Harvard eleven played with a snap and dash that carried the IL 900 people almost off their feet with enthusiasm. during the entire game. On the other hand a number of the Indians were sadly bat tered. Wheelock was carried from the field and tonight is still in serious con diton. His injuries apparently resulted from a blow about the head. Until the last part of the second half Harvard’s new defense worked well and had no trouble in keeping the ball in the Indians territory. AS the Harvard score mounted, however. Captain Burden deter mined to give the substitutes a chance. Accordingly he called in Eaton and Swain as tackles, and also a new trio of backs Parker Warren and Reid Then the In dams began to play. They attacked Harwards line with fury that the substitutes could not meet and slowly pushed the ball down the field. A mass play just outside of tackle was the effective for, nation and Swain especially seemed pow erless to stop 1t. On every exchange of punts Harvard gained partly due to the great SUPERIOR ity of Hallowel over Miller and to the brilliant work of Daily, who invariably ran Millers punts back ten yards before being downed. The lineup:
Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.
Before kickoff
Our ratings going in
Our ratings (scores only)
Harvard 74% to win. Elo’s favorite won.
The series
Every Carlisle–Harvard gameHarvard leads 12–2 in 14 meetings, counting the 11 since this game.
| 1915 | Harvard 29, Carlisle 7 | |
| 1911 | Carlisle 18, Harvard 15 | |
| 1908 | Harvard 17, Carlisle 0 | |
| 1907 | Carlisle 23, Harvard 15 | |
| 1906 | Harvard 5, Carlisle 0 | |
| 1905 | Harvard 23, Carlisle 11 |
Around this game
Carlisle
- Next gamevs. HamiltonNov. 4, 1899
- SeasonCarlisle in 1899
- ProgramCarlisle history and records
Harvard
- Next gameat PennsylvaniaNov. 4, 1899
- SeasonHarvard in 1899
- ProgramHarvard history and records
