Carlisle at Harvard

Saturday, October 29, 1898

Harvard beat Carlisle 11–⁠5. It was their second meeting; after it, Harvard led the series 2–⁠0.

AwayCarlisle6–⁠4 in 1898
5
HomeHarvard11–⁠0 in 1898
11

FinalHigh 45°F, low 33°F

In the newspapers

  • The The times's story: 'HARVARD'S CLOSE CALL Carlisle Indians Defeated in a Hafd-FOught Game. cRIMSON'S RAGGED WORK The Cambridge Boys BACKS Show Up Well in the Punting Lines, hut the Tackles Prove Exceptionally Weak-Hain Falls, Throughout the Contcst-Dctails of the Game.

    The times, October 30, 1898, page 9

    Read the text

    ‘HARVARD’S CLOSE CALL Carlisle Indians Defeated in a Hafd-FOught Game. cRIMSON’S RAGGED WORK The Cambridge Boys BACKS Show Up Well in the Punting Lines, hut the Tackles Prove Exceptionally Weak-Hain Falls, Throughout the Contcst-Dctails of the Game. Cambridge, Mass, Oct 29-For the first time this season the Harvard Varsity | eleven found themselves facing an oppo- | nent with the score to against them | in the early stages of the game, and for time 1t looked as though the Indians might give the men in crimson u tight ! pull for the victory. The Harvard men. | however, made brace and managed to make touchdown in the first half | through fluke play, and another in the second half giving them the victory. / The weather conditions were. about as bad as could be, and rain fell about 2 o’clock and continued throughout the / game. This, however, did not prevent the | crowd of 5000 people from coming out to see the game. The game was especially disheartening to the Harvard supporters. The home | teams play was from the first decidedly ragged, good plays at intervals being the | only point to bring encouragement to | Harvard. Much of the Indians failure to make the score against them less was the ability of the Harvard backs in the punt ing line. ! The Harvard tackles proved exception ally weak, the Pierce boys having Donald and Mills on the string throughout the ! game Most of the Carlisle plays were ! directed at this partaof the line, and 1t was here that most of their gains were | made. AT times II looked as If there were a driveway through the Harvard center, and through this hole the Indian backs came tearing for Irresistible gains. On the toss-off the ball fell to the In dians, Harvard taking the west and what little advantage there was to be | derived from the wind. Pierce sent the ball down the field. DAILY rooted II to midfield. where Miller received 1t, and ! was downed near the middle of the field. At once Hudson began sending his men here and there for feelers, but the downs did not yield the required five yards and he dropped back and sent punt down to DAILY. | Carlisle here sprung a surprise on Har- | ward by throwing Dibblee and Warren ! back for loss on their attempts at | end gaining and steadfastly refusing the | Crimson backs any approach to an ad- | mission to her center. Cochrane was sent back on kick formation and gave the Indians the ball by punting 1t directly into their line and Bemis Pierce | secured the ball The Indians gallopcd | the ends for small gains and then Me- | token went into the Crimson territory for | fifteen yards. The ball was now well within Harvard’s twenty-yard line. | The Harvard line was playing fast and | furious, and when the Indians could | make no gain either at end or center, 1 rns.s faf | the field and when just abreast of the goal-posts went straight for them until | tackled and thrown. On the next play | Hudson dropped back for a kick and | Just missed the goal-posts. on the kick out, Miller ran fifteen yards and then slipped through the tackles for | fifteen yards. Carlisle consistently rip ped up Harvard’s line and ends for gains until the ball was in the twenty-hve-yard line in front of goal. The Crimson here | held for three downs and Hudson again | s,enned back and deliberately sent the ball through the goal-posts | Cochrane kicked off for Harvard, but after the first rush Carlisle could make no ground, and Miller was called on to | kick. The ball was Harvard’s in mid | field. and Cochrane returned 1t to the three-yard line. Here Miller and Hudson, | instead of taking the leather, let 1t roll L touch, but they waited so long that Coch- rane had time TO get down the field and nut it on side, enabling Hollowell TO fall on 1t at the three-yard line and practically presenting Harvard with touch down. The Indians, however. disputed every inch of the three yards. and so fercely that II took Reid four rushes to get II over. Cochrane kicked the goal. During the remaining time both sides made desperate endeavors to score. In the second half the fight stood abou, even. Harvard, however, showed uI strong and fast at the finish. while the Indians. although fast and strong. showed the effect of their punishment. Dibble and Warren did some effective end running while Boal and Reid used the guards for steady gains. Dibblee finally carried the ball over after his side had worked II down to the three-yard-line. Once Har- ward lost the ball on the five yard line where long run had taken 1t. Carlisle however, came up strong and walked Harvard down the field after recovering the ball on downs, and it was only by the most heroic of efforts that the Indians were eventually stopped on the fifteen. yard line. A puAt by Haughton put the ball out of danger. At the end the bal was in possession of the red men and be- ing rushed by them for steady gains. The lineup: Harvard. Position Carlisle Cochrane-Farley left end - .Archiquette Boal.............left guard. Scot, | Jaffrey center Smith

  • The The morning news's story: HARVARD DEFEATS INDIANS. CARLISLE TEAM USED THE SAME TACTICS AS IN PREVIOUS GAME.

    The morning news, Savannah, Ga., October 30, 1898, page 1

    Read the text

    HARVARD DEFEATS INDIANS. CARLISLE TEAM USED THE SAME TACTICS AS IN PREVIOUS GAME. Harvard Team Had Hard Work, but TO @University of Pennsylvania Beat the Chicago TRANSFORMED Has “a Hard Struggle With the OberIin Team-Other Games Play ed Yesterday. Cambridge, Mass, Oct. 29.-The Carlisle Indians scored their usual goal from the field in the foot ball game on Soldiers Fled this afternoon, but Harvard won through hard, clean, and, at times, brill liant work, by a score of II to 5, making the first touchdown through poor head work on the part of the Indians, and an other in the second half by beautiful runs by Dibblee. The Indians repeated their tactics at Yale last Saturday by at once rushing the ball down the field to the tweuty-five-yard lire, and then making their try for a goal from the field. In the first attempt Hudson failed but the second time the ball sailed across the crossbar, with five yards to spare. Then the Indians showed their lack of knowledge of the game and allowed Coon rane, after kick, to put the Harvard team on side and Hallowell fell on the ball within five yards of the goal post. Three rushes were necessary, however, before Reid went over for the first touch down. In the second half long runs by Dibblee scored another, and what proved to be the last touchdown for Harvard. The game was of the hest In Cambridge this year, for the Indians gave the Harward team the hard work that they need ed, and showed up the weak points in the crimson line in a manner that was any thing but assuring to the outcome of the game next Saturday.

  • The The Saint Paul globe's story: HARVARD HARD PRESSED. Crimson Crowd Kept Busy I'm Beat ing the Carlisle Indians.

    The Saint Paul globe, October 30, 1898, page 10

    Read the text

    HARVARD HARD PRESSED. Crimson Crowd Kept Busy I’m Beat ing the Carlisle Indians. ing the Carlisle Indians. CAMBRIDGE, Mass, Oct. 29-The Carlisle Indians scored their usual goal from the ne.d In the football game Soldiers field, but Harvard through hard clean and at times brilliant work, by a score of IL to 5, making the first touchdown through poor headwork the part of the Indians, and another in the second half by beautiful runs by Dibbee. The Indians repeated their tao ties against Yale. last Saturday by at once rushing down the field to the 25-yard line and then making their try fer goal from the fed In the first attempt Hudson failed, but the second time the ball sailed over the crossbar with yards to spare. Then the Indians showed their lack of knowledge of the game and allowed Cochrane after kick to put the Harvard team on side, and Hallowel fell on Baldwin FIVE yards from the goal post. Three Tushes were necessary, however, before Reid went over Tor the first touchdown. In the second half long runs by Dibblee scored another, and what proved to be the last touchdown for Harvard. The game was one OF the best seen in Cambridge this year Tor the Indians gave the Harvard team the hard work that they needed, and showed up the weak points in the Crimson line In manner that was anything but assuring as to the outcome Of the Pennsylvania game next Saturday.

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Harvard 81% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Harvard leads 12–⁠2 in 14 meetings, counting the 12 since this game.

Recent meetings
1915Harvard 29, Carlisle 7
1911Carlisle 18, Harvard 15
1908Harvard 17, Carlisle 0
1907Carlisle 23, Harvard 15
1906Harvard 5, Carlisle 0
1905Harvard 23, Carlisle 11

Around this game

Carlisle

Harvard