The 1915 All-America teams
10 selectors named All-America teams for 1915; the NCAA counts 2 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1915 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- EMurray Shelton, Cornell
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OTEarl Abell, Colgate
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGChris Schlachter, Syracuse
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBRichard King, Harvard
- RBBart Macomber, Illinois
- RBElmer Oliphant, Army
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
Second team
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EJames P. Herron, Pittsburgh
- OTHoward “Cub” Buck, Wisconsin
- OTWilliam T. Van de Graaff, Alabama
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGFrank T. Hogg, Princeton
- CGib Cool, Cornell
- QBDonald Clarke Watson, Harvard
- RBDave Tibbott, Princeton
- FBHoward Parker Talman, Rutgers
Third team
- EFred Heyman, Washington & Jefferson
- EGeorge Squier, Illinois
- OTAlex Weyand, Army
- OTJosh Cody, Vanderbilt
- OGHarrie Holland Dadmun, Harvard
- OGBaby Taylor, Auburn
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBPete Russell, Chicago
- RBHerman Abraham, Oregon State
- FBPunk Berryman, Penn State
Frank G. Menke
First team
- EGuy Chamberlin, Nebraska
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- OTHoward “Cub” Buck, Wisconsin
- OTMaurice M. Witherspoon, W&J
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGHarold White, Syracuse
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEugene Mayer, Virginia
- RBNeno DaPrato, Michigan State
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
Second team
- EMurray Shelton, Cornell
- EGeorge Squier, Illinois
- OTEarl Abell, Colgate
- OTLaurens Shull, Chicago
- OGFreeman Fitzgerald, Notre Dame
- OGPat Dunnigan, Minnesota
- CGib Cool, Cornell
- QBPete Russell, Chicago
- RBBernie Bierman, Minnesota
- RBR.B. “Dick” Rutherford, Nebraska
- RBAndy Hastings, Pittsburgh
Other selectors
Monty
First team
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EFred Heyman, Washington & Jefferson
- OTEarl Abell, Colgate
- OTMark Farnum, Brown
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBElmer Oliphant, Army
- RBRed Wilkinson, Syracuse
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
Second team
- EMurray Shelton, Cornell
- EErnest William Soucy, Harvard
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OTAlex Weyand, Army
- OGHarold White, Syracuse
- OGBudge Garrett, Rutgers
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBMiller, Columbia
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBJohnny Gilroy, Georgetown
- FBHoward Parker Talman, Rutgers
Parke H. Davis
First team
- EMurray Shelton, Cornell
- EGuy Chamberlin, Nebraska
- OTHoward “Cub” Buck, Wisconsin
- OTWilliam T. Van de Graaff, Alabama
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGFreeman Fitzgerald, Notre Dame
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEugene Mayer, Virginia
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBEdward H. Driggs, Princeton
Tommy Clark
First team
Damon Runyon
- EMurray Shelton, Cornell
- EErnest William Soucy, Harvard
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OTNelson “Pie” Way, Yale
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBElmer Oliphant, Army
- RBFritz Shiverick, Cornell
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
Eddie N. Robinson
- EMurray Shelton, Cornell
- EErnest William Soucy, Harvard
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OTMark Farnum, Brown
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGChris Schlachter, Syracuse
- CGib Cool, Cornell
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBRed Wilkinson, Syracuse
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBPunk Berryman, Penn State
Walter Eckersall
First team
- EGuy Chamberlin, Nebraska
- EJack “Red” Lamberton, Princeton
- OTHoward “Cub” Buck, Wisconsin
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGPat Dunnigan, Minnesota
- CGib Cool, Cornell
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBBernie Bierman, Minnesota
- RBDave Tibbott, Princeton
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
Second team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- OTEarl Abell, Colgate
- OTJohn B. McAuliffe, Dartmouth
- OGHarold White, Syracuse
- OGChris Schlachter, Syracuse
- CJohn Wesley “Jack” Watson, Illinois
- QBPete Russell, Chicago
- RBRichard King, Harvard
- RBRed Wilkinson, Syracuse
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
Fielding Yost
First team
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EJack “Red” Lamberton, Princeton
- OTHoward “Cub” Buck, Wisconsin
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGChris Schlachter, Syracuse
- CGib Cool, Cornell
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBRichard King, Harvard
- RBDave Tibbott, Princeton
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
Jonas H. Ingram
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EErnest William Soucy, Harvard
- OTJoseph Gilman, Harvard
- OTNelson “Pie” Way, Yale
- OGHarold White, Syracuse
- OGFrank T. Hogg, Princeton
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- QBGuy Williamson, Pittsburgh
- FBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBPunk Berryman, Penn State
From Wikipedia’s 1915 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.