The 1916 All-America teams
11 selectors named All-America teams for 1916; the NCAA counts 3 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1916 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- EGeorge Clark Moseley, Yale
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTSteamer Horning, Colgate
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGHarrie Dadmun, Harvard
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBOscar Anderson, Colgate
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
Second team
- EJames P. Herron, Pittsburgh
- EHeinie Miller, Penn
- OTArtemus Gates, Yale
- OTClarence Ward, Navy
- OGFrank T. Hogg, Princeton
- OGCharlie Bachman, Notre Dame
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBClair Purdy, Brown
- RBEddie Casey, Harvard
- RBHarry LeGore, Yale
- FBJoe Berry, Penn
Third team
- ECharles Atherton Coolidge, Harvard
- EGraham Vowell, Tennessee
- OTLouis Seagrave, Washington
- OTJohn Beckett, Oregon
- OTBob Ignico, Washington & Lee
- OGBudge Garrett, Rutgers
- CPup Phillips, Georgia Tech
- QBIrby Curry, Vanderbilt
- RBPaddy Driscoll, Northwestern
- RBJohnny Gilroy, Georgetown
- FBMcReaghy, Washington & Jefferson
INS
International News Service
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- ECharles Comerford, Yale
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTGeorge Hauser, Minnesota
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGClaude E. Thornhill, Pitt
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBOscar Anderson, Colgate
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBAndy Hastings, Pittsburgh
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
Second team
- EJames P. Herron, Pittsburgh
- ERichard Harte, Harvard
- OTArtemus Gates, Yale
- OTMark Farnum, Brown
- OGHarrie Dadmun, Harvard
- OGMason Barton, Colgate
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBFritz Shiverick, Cornell
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- RBHarry LeGore, Yale
- FBJoe Berry, Penn
Frank Menke Syndicate
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- EJames P. Herron, Pittsburgh
- EStan Cofall, Notre Dame
- OTSteamer Horning, Colgate
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGFrank T. Hogg, Princeton
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
Other selectors
UP
United Press
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTDeVitalis, Brown
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGLawrence Fox, Yale
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBFritz Shiverick, Cornell
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBAndy Hastings, Pittsburgh
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
- FBJoe Berry, Penn
Second team
- ECharles Highley, Princeton
- EStan Cofall, Notre Dame
- OTArtemus Gates, Yale
- OTWalter Herber Wheeler, Harvard
- OGHarrie Dadmun, Harvard
- OGMonroe Good, Colgate
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBOscar Anderson, Colgate
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- RBPaddy Driscoll, Northwestern
- FBPudge Wyman, Minnesota
Walter Eckersall
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- EJames P. Herron, Pittsburgh
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTFred Becker, Iowa
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGHarrie Dadmun, Harvard
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBJames DeHart, Pitt
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- FBJoe Berry, Penn
- FBPudge Wyman, Minnesota
Second team
- EGeorge Clark Moseley, Yale
- EPaul Eckley, Cornell
- OTSteamer Horning, Colgate
- OTFrank A.R. Mayer, Minnesota
- OGRobert Lee Nourse, Princeton
- OGArnold McInerney, Notre Dame
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBBart Macomber, Illinois
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- RBEddie Casey, Harvard
- RBHarry LeGore, Yale
Paul Purman
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- OTDeVitalis, Brown
- OTLouis Seagrave, Washington
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGFrank T. Hogg, Princeton
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBFritz Shiverick, Cornell
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBEddie Casey, Harvard
- RBEverett Strupper, Georgia Tech
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
Second team
- EClifford Carlson, Pitt
- ETommy Whelan, Georgetown
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTEarl Beacham, Tufts
- OGRobert Lee Nourse, Princeton
- OGSinclair, Minnesota
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBBart Macomber, Illinois
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- RBHarry LeGore, Yale
- FBArnold Horween, Harvard
Fielding H. Yost
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- EHeinie Miller, Penn
- OTWilliam Lippard McLean, Princeton
- OTFred Gillies, Cornell
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGHarrie Dadmun, Harvard
- CAlfred Gennert, Princeton
- QBBart Macomber, Illinois
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- FBJoe Berry, Penn
Second team
The Boston Post
First team
- EBert Baston, Minnesota
- ECharles Comerford, Yale
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTWilliam Lippard McLean, Princeton
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGCharles Henning, Penn
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBOscar Anderson, Colgate
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
Lawrence Perry
First team
- EHeinie Miller, Penn
- ECharles Highley, Princeton
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTWalter Herber Wheeler, Harvard
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGCharlie Bachman, Notre Dame
- CAlfred Gennert, Princeton
- QBOscar Anderson, Colgate
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- RBHarry LeGore, Yale
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
Monty
First team
- ERichard Harte, Harvard
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- OTWilliam Lippard McLean, Princeton
- OTMark Farnum, Brown
- OGClinton Black, Yale
- OGChristopher Schlachter, Syracuse
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCliff Sparks, Michigan
- RBFritz Pollard, Brown
- FBElmer Oliphant, Army
- FBJoe Berry, Penn
Frank G. Menke
- OTBob Karch, Ohio State
- RBClaire Long, Minnesota
From Wikipedia’s 1916 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.