The 1914 All-America teams
28 selectors named All-America teams for 1914; the NCAA counts 2 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1914 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTWalter Trumbull, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
Second team
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- EMaurice R. “Red” Brann, Yale
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OTBob Nash, Rutgers
- OGWilbur Shenk, Princeton
- OGLouis Jordan, Texas
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Spiegel, Washington & Jefferson
- RBWilliam “Billy” Cahall, Lehigh
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Third team
- EHarvey E. Overesch, Navy
- OTVic Halligan, Nebraska
- OTAlex Weyand, Army
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGLaurence B. Meacham, Army
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBAlexander D. Wilson, Yale
- RBHarold Pogue, Illinois
- RBHoward Parker Talman, Rutgers
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
- FBLorin Solon, Minnesota
Frank G. Menke
First team
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EPerry Graves, Illinois
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTVic Halligan, Nebraska
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- OGArlie Mucks, Wisconsin
- OGMichalis Dorizas, Penn
- CBob Peck, Pittsburgh
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBJohnny Spiegel, Washington & Jefferson
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Second team
- EBoyd Cherry, Ohio State
- EThomas Jefferson Coolidge, Harvard
- OTAlex Weyand, Army
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
- FBLorin Solon, Minnesota
Third team
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- EReginald Bovill, Washington & Jefferson
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OTLennox F. Armstrong, Illinois
- OGHarry Routh, Purdue
- OGDale Munsick, Cornell
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBPotsy Clark, Illinois
- RBHarold Pogue, Illinois
- RBWilliam H. Miller, Pittsburgh
- FBCharles Shuler Jr., Cornell
Other selectors
Vanity Fair
Parke H. Davis
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTWalter Trumbull, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- QBDavid Paddock, Georgia
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBJohnny Spiegel, Washington & Jefferson
Walter Eckersall
First team
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
Second team
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTVic Halligan, Nebraska
- OTCub Buck, Wisconsin
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- OGJoseph J. “Red” O’Hare, Army
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
- RBHarold Pogue, Illinois
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
- FBLorin Solon, Minnesota
Monty
First team
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Second team
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- EReginald Bovill, Washington & Jefferson
- OTPete Maxfield, Lafayette
- OTGeorge D. Howell, Trinity College
- OGEddie Trenkmann, Princeton
- OGEarl W. Mills, Navy
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBHuntley, New York
- RBWilliam “Billy” Cahall, Lehigh
- RBAndrew Toolan, Williams
- FBRay Eichenlaub, Notre Dame
New York Herald
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBJohnny Spiegel, Washington & Jefferson
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
James P. Sinnot
First team
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTJohn Toohey, Rutgers
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBJohnny Spiegel, Washington & Jefferson
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Second team
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OTEdward J. Gallogly, Cornell
- OGWilbur Shenk, Princeton
- OGHarold White, Syracuse
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
- FBHugo Franck, Harvard
New York Globe
First team
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTJohn Toohey, Rutgers
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- QBVernon Prichard, Army
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
Newark Sunday Call
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTJohn Toohey, Rutgers
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBVernon Prichard, Army
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
- FBRay Eichenlaub, Notre Dame
Pittsburgh Gazette-Times
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTVic Halligan, Nebraska
- OTCub Buck, Wisconsin
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBVernon Prichard, Army
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBHarold Pogue, Illinois
Baltimore News
Philadelphia Evening Bulletin
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OTPete Maxfield, Lafayette
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
- FBHaps Benfer, Albright
Atlanta Constitution
Pittsburgh Sun
Washington Herald
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EMaurice R. “Red” Brann, Yale
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Davis J. Davies
Davis J. Davies in the Pittsburgh Dispatch
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EReginald Bovill, Washington & Jefferson
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OTWalter Trumbull, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLorin Solon, Minnesota
Philadelphia Evening Telegraph
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGEddie Trenkmann, Princeton
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
St. Louis Times
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTCub Buck, Wisconsin
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBVernon Prichard, Army
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
Michigan Daily
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTVic Halligan, Nebraska
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBHarold Pogue, Illinois
Newark Evening Star
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTJohn Toohey, Rutgers
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
Detroit Evening News
Philadelphia Public Ledger
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OTTed Shultz, Washington & Lee
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CBurleigh Cruikshank, Washington & Jefferson
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
Boston Post
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EMaurice R. “Red” Brann, Yale
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
Tom Thorp
Tom Thorp in the New York Evening Journal
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBritain Patterson, Washington & Jefferson
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGEddie Trenkmann, Princeton
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Alexander Wilson
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- EMaurice R. “Red” Brann, Yale
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTWalter Trumbull, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CJohn McEwan, Army
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBJohnny Spiegel, Washington & Jefferson
Philadelphia Inquirer
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTWalter Trumbull, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGClarence Spears, Dartmouth
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- QBMilt Ghee, Dartmouth
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
Outing magazine
Outing magazine’s “FOOTBALL ROLL OF HONOR
- EHuntington “Tack” Hardwick, Harvard
- ELouis A. Merrilat, Army
- EJohn E. O’Hearn, Cornell
- EBoyd Cherry, Ohio State
- EEdwin Stavrum, Wisconsin
- ERobbie Robinson, Auburn
- OTHarold Ballin, Princeton
- OTBud Talbott, Yale
- OTWalter Trumbull, Harvard
- OTVic Halligan, Nebraska
- OTCub Buck, Wisconsin
- OTWill Burton, Kansas
- OTLaurens Shull, Chicago
- OTJosh Cody, Vanderbilt
- OTFarmer Kelly, Tennessee
- OTBob Taylor Dobbins, Sewanee
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRalph Chapman, Illinois
- OGWilbur Shenk, Princeton
- OGHarold White, Syracuse
- CPaul Des Jardien, Chicago
- CAlbert Journeay, Penn
- CBoles Rosenthal, Minnesota
- CWillard Cool, Cornell
- CJames Raynsford, Michigan
- CBoozer Pitts, Auburn
- QBCharley Barrett, Cornell
- QBVernon Prichard, Army
- QBAlexander D. Wilson, Yale
- QBPotsy Clark, Illinois
- QBDavid Paddock, Georgia
- QBMalcolm Justin Logan, Harvard
- QBFrank Glick, Princeton
- QBWilliam H. Tow, Amherst
- QBIrby Curry, Vanderbilt
- QBRobert Kent Gooch, Virginia
- QBPaul Russell, Chicago
- QBTommy Hughitt, Michigan
- QBSammy Gross, Iowa
- QBWilbur Hightower, Northwestern
- QBLouis E. Pickerel, Ohio State
- RBJohnny Maulbetsch, Michigan
- RBEddie Mahan, Harvard
- RBFrederick Bradlee, Harvard
- RBHarold Pogue, Illinois
- RBAndrew Toolan, Williams
- RBDick Rutherford, Nebraska
- RBGuy Chamberlin, Nebraska
- RBTam Rose, Syracuse
- RBMarcus Wilkinson, Syracuse
- RBCarroll Knowles, Yale
- RBMoore, Princeton
- RBEugene Mayer, Virginia
- RBGray, Chicago
- RBBart Macomber, Illinois
- RBAmmie Sikes, Vanderbilt
- RBLee Tolley, Sewanee
- RBDave Tayloe, North Carolina
- FBHarry LeGore, Yale
- FBLawrence Whitney, Dartmouth
- FBLorin Solon, Minnesota
- FBHaps Benfer, Albright
- FBPete Calac, Carlisle
- FBDan Kenan, Wesleyan
- FBCarl Philippi, Cornell
- FBCampbell “Honus” Graf, Ohio State
- FBCharles Brickley, Harvard
From Wikipedia’s 1914 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.