Columbia vs. Rutgers

Columbia and Rutgers first met in 1870 and have played 49 times; Rutgers leads the series 23–⁠21–⁠5. Over the last 10 meetings it’s Rutgers 7–⁠3, and Rutgers has won the last 5.

Columbia wins
21
Rutgers wins
23
Ties
5
First meeting
1870
Longest streak
9 Columbia
Current streak
5 Rutgers
Last 10 meetings
Rutgers 7–⁠3
Most recent
1978

The series at a glance

Every meeting by decade, colored by the winner
’0’1’2’3’4’5’6’7’8’9W–L
1870s3–⁠4–⁠3
1880s2–⁠2–⁠1
1890s1–⁠1–⁠1
1900s3–⁠0
1930s1–⁠0
1940s3–⁠0
1950s3–⁠4
1960s3–⁠7
1970s2–⁠5
Average margin
14.8 points; 20 decided by one score (8 or fewer)
At Columbia
13–⁠8–⁠2 Columbia’s record at home
At Rutgers
15–⁠8–⁠3 Rutgers’s record at home
Shutouts
13

Every meeting on file, as played. Ranks are the AP poll’s going in.

Games that tell the story

  1. Columbia’s biggest win1902: Columbia 43, Rutgers 0by 43 points
  2. Rutgers’s biggest win1978: Rutgers 69, Columbia 0by 69 points
  3. Upset1972: Rutgers 6, Columbia 3Rutgers had a 27% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  4. Upset1899: Columbia 26, Rutgers 0Columbia had a 29% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  5. Upset1959: Columbia 26, Rutgers 16Columbia had a 32% chance, by our ratings before kickoff

Coach against coach

YearsColumbiaSeriesRutgers
1946–⁠1955Lou Little4–⁠2Harvey Harman
1957–⁠1959Aldo Donelli1–⁠2John Stiegman
1960–⁠1967Aldo Donelli3–⁠5John Bateman
1968–⁠1972Frank Navarro2–⁠3John Bateman
1975–⁠1978Bill Campbell0–⁠3Frank Burns

Head-coach pairings with three or more meetings on file, the series read from Columbia’s side (Little 4–⁠2 against Harman). A season split between coaches goes to the one credited with the game.

Both programs through the years

End-of-season Elo ratings of Columbia and Rutgers, 1870 on13001500170018801900192019401960198020002020

Our Elo rating at the end of each season, a measure of how strong a team was, not a forecast; 1500 is an average FBS team.

From the newspapers

  • The New-York tribune's story of the 1891 game: RUTGERS DEFEATS COLUMBIA.

    1891 · New-York tribune, New York [N.Y.], Oct 29, 1891

  • The New-York tribune's story of the 1899 game: FOOTBALL. COLUMBIA WINS a GAME FROM RUTGERS BY AN AMPLE MARGIN

    1899 · New-York tribune, New York [N.Y.], Oct 4, 1899

  • The New-York tribune's story of the 1900 game: FOOTBALL. COLUMBIA DEFEATS RUTGERS URE TO FOLLOW SIGNALS MAKES A TOJTCunOWN

    1900 · New-York tribune, New York [N.Y.], Oct 4, 1900

  • The New-York tribune's story of the 1901 game: RUTGERS EASY FOR COLUMBIA. THE NEW-YORKERS. WITHOUT THEIR DE BARRED MEN. WIN BY q TO o.

    1901 · New-York tribune, Oct 3, 1901

  • The Evening star's story of the 1935 game: COLUMBIA STAGES BIG RALLY TO WIN Gets All It's Points in Second Period in 20-6 Victory Over Rutgers.

    1935 · Evening star, District of Columbia, Oct 13, 1935

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The earliest meetings with a story on file; each game’s page has the full text.

Every game

Oct 28, 1978Rutgers 69, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Oct 23, 1976Rutgers 47, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Oct 25, 1975Rutgers 41, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Oct 27, 1973Rutgers 28, Columbia 2at Rutgers
Oct 28, 1972Rutgers 6, Columbia 3at Columbia
Oct 23, 1971Columbia 17, Rutgers 16at Rutgers
Oct 24, 1970Columbia 30, Rutgers 14at Columbia
Oct 25, 1969Rutgers 21, Columbia 14at Rutgers
Oct 26, 1968Rutgers 28, Columbia 17at Columbia
Oct 28, 1967Columbia 24, Rutgers 13at Columbia
Oct 22, 1966Rutgers 37, Columbia 34at Rutgers
Oct 23, 1965Columbia 12, Rutgers 7at Rutgers
Oct 24, 1964Rutgers 38, Columbia 35at Columbia
Nov 23, 1963Columbia 35, Rutgers 28at Rutgers
Nov 24, 1962Rutgers 22, Columbia 6at Columbia
Nov 25, 1961Rutgers 32, Columbia 19at Rutgers
Nov 19, 1960Rutgers 43, Columbia 2at Columbia
Nov 21, 1959Columbia 26, Rutgers 16at Columbia
Nov 22, 1958Rutgers 61, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Nov 23, 1957Rutgers 26, Columbia 7at Columbia
Nov 24, 1956Columbia 18, Rutgers 12at Rutgers
Nov 19, 1955Rutgers 12, Columbia 6at Columbia
Nov 20, 1954Rutgers 45, Columbia 12at Columbia
Nov 21, 1953Columbia 27, Rutgers 13at Columbia
Sep 25, 1948Columbia 27, Rutgers 6at Columbia
Sep 27, 1947Columbia 40, Rutgers 28at Columbia
Sep 28, 1946Columbia 13, Rutgers 7at Columbia
Oct 12, 1935Columbia 20, Rutgers 6at Columbia
Oct 4, 1902Columbia 43, Rutgers 0at Rutgers
Oct 2, 1901Columbia 27, Rutgers 0at Rutgers
Oct 3, 1900Columbia 11, Rutgers 0at Rutgers
Sep 30, 1899Columbia 26, Rutgers 0at Rutgers
Oct 28, 1891Rutgers 44, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Nov 15, 1890Rutgers 6, Columbia 6at Rutgers
Oct 15, 1884Rutgers 35, Columbia 5at Rutgers
Nov 9, 1882Rutgers 2, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Nov 23, 1881Columbia 1, Rutgers 0at Columbia
Nov 8, 1881Rutgers 0, Columbia 0at Rutgers
Nov 13, 1880Columbia 3, Rutgers 0at Columbia
Nov 20, 1879Columbia 0, Rutgers 0at Columbia
Nov 6, 1877Columbia 1, Rutgers 0at Columbia
Nov 2, 1875Rutgers 1, Columbia 1at Rutgers
Nov 14, 1874Columbia 4, Rutgers 1at Columbia
Oct 24, 1874Rutgers 6, Columbia 1at Rutgers
Nov 8, 1873Columbia 4, Rutgers 3at Columbia
Nov 1, 1873Rutgers 5, Columbia 4at Rutgers
Nov 9, 1872Rutgers 7, Columbia 5at Rutgers
Nov 2, 1872Columbia 0, Rutgers 0at Columbia
Nov 5, 1870Rutgers 6, Columbia 3at Rutgers

Every game is listed as played on the field.