Ball State vs. Northern Illinois

Ball State and Northern Illinois have 49 meetings on file, the first in 1968; the series is tied 24–⁠24–⁠1 in the games on file. Over the last 10 meetings it’s even at 5–⁠5. The winner takes home the Bronze Stalk Trophy, played for since 2008. Northern Illinois has held it since the 2025 game.

Ball State wins
24
Northern Illinois wins
24
Ties
1
Earliest on file
1968
Longest streak
10 Northern Illinois
Current streak
1 Northern Illinois
Last 10 meetings
even at 5–⁠5
Most recent
2025

The series at a glance

Every meeting by decade, colored by the winner
’0’1’2’3’4’5’6’7’8’9W–L
1960s0–⁠2
1970s6–⁠2–⁠1
1980s8–⁠1
1990s2–⁠1
2000s3–⁠7
2010s1–⁠9
2020s4–⁠2
Average margin
14 points; 21 decided by one score (8 or fewer)
At Ball State
11–⁠12 Ball State’s record at home
At Northern Illinois
12–⁠13–⁠1 Northern Illinois’s record at home
Shutouts
4

Every meeting on file, as played. Ranks are the AP poll’s going in.

Bronze Stalk Trophy

Played for since
2008
Held by
Northern Illinois since the 2025 game
Games for it on file
18 Ball State 6, Northern Illinois 12

Who holds it comes from the games on file: the winner of the latest regular-season meeting since 2008 (bowl rematches aren’t played for it); a tie leaves it with the holder (the usual rule; the article doesn’t say). The rivalry’s article counts the games for it: Northern Illinois leads, 12–⁠6. From Wikipedia’s list of rivalry games and the rivalry’s article (CC BY-SA). More on the Bronze Stalk Trophy.

Games that tell the story

  1. Ball State’s biggest win1979: Ball State 42, Northern Illinois 0by 42 points
  2. Northern Illinois’s biggest win2017: Northern Illinois 63, Ball State 17by 46 points
  3. Upset2005: Ball State 31, Northern Illinois 17Ball State had a 13% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  4. Upset1984: Ball State 15, Northern Illinois 14Ball State had a 18% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  5. Upset2019: Ball State 27, Northern Illinois 20Ball State had a 28% chance, by our ratings before kickoff

Coach against coach

YearsBall StateSeriesNorthern Illinois
1973–⁠1975Dave McClain2–⁠1Jerry Ippoliti
1980–⁠1983Dwight Wallace3–⁠1Bill Mallory
1985–⁠1988Paul Schudel4–⁠0Jerry Pettibone
1997–⁠2002Bill Lynch2–⁠4Joe Novak
2003–⁠2007Brady Hoke2–⁠3Joe Novak
2013–⁠2015Pete Lembo0–⁠3Rod Carey
2016–⁠2018Mike Neu0–⁠3Rod Carey
2019–⁠2024Mike Neu5–⁠1Thomas Hammock

Head-coach pairings with three or more meetings on file, the series read from Ball State’s side (McClain 2–⁠1 against Ippoliti). A season split between coaches goes to the one credited with the game.

Both programs through the years

End-of-season Elo ratings of Ball State and Northern Illinois, 1968 on130015001700197019801990200020102020

Our Elo rating at the end of each season, a measure of how strong a team was, not a forecast; 1500 is an average FBS team.

Stars of the series

Biggest days

Garrett Wolfe Northern Illinois31 carries, 353 yards, 3 TD2006 Rushing
Garrett Wolfe Northern Illinois36 carries, 280 yards, 3 TD2004 Rushing
Harrison Waylee Northern Illinois30 carries, 230 yards, 3 TD2022 Rushing
Jordan Lynch Northern Illinois29 carries, 207 yards, 3 TD2012 Rushing
Da’Ron Brown Northern Illinois8 catches, 209 yards, 2 TD2013 Receiving

Biggest days: the week’s best individual games by our big-days rule, from box scores (2004 on).

Photos

From the rivalry’s and its games’ categories on Wikimedia Commons (free licenses only, each credited).

Every game

Oct 25, 2025Northern Illinois 21, Ball State 7at Northern Illinois
Oct 26, 2024Ball State 25, Northern Illinois 23at Ball State
Nov 7, 2023Ball State 20, Northern Illinois 17at Northern Illinois
Oct 1, 2022Ball State 44, Northern Illinois 38at Ball State
Nov 10, 2021Northern Illinois 30, Ball State 29at Northern Illinois
Nov 18, 2020Ball State 31, Northern Illinois 25at Ball State
Oct 5, 2019Ball State 27, Northern Illinois 20at Northern Illinois
Oct 6, 2018Northern Illinois 24, Ball State 16at Ball State
Nov 9, 2017Northern Illinois 63, Ball State 17at Northern Illinois
Oct 1, 2016Northern Illinois 31, Ball State 24at Ball State
Oct 10, 2015Northern Illinois 59, Ball State 41at Northern Illinois
Nov 5, 2014Northern Illinois 35, Ball State 21at Ball State
Nov 13, 201320Northern Illinois 48, Ball State 27at Northern Illinois
Oct 6, 2012Northern Illinois 35, Ball State 23at Ball State
Nov 15, 2011Northern Illinois 41, Ball State 38at Northern Illinois
Nov 20, 2010Northern Illinois 59, Ball State 21at Ball State
Nov 12, 2009Northern Illinois 26, Ball State 20at Northern Illinois
Nov 5, 200816Ball State 45, Northern Illinois 14at Ball State
Nov 24, 2007Ball State 27, Northern Illinois 21at Northern Illinois
Sep 30, 2006Northern Illinois 40, Ball State 28at Ball State
Oct 29, 2005Ball State 31, Northern Illinois 17at Northern Illinois
Oct 30, 2004Northern Illinois 38, Ball State 31at Ball State
Nov 1, 200321Northern Illinois 48, Ball State 23at Northern Illinois
Oct 5, 2002Northern Illinois 41, Ball State 29at Ball State
Nov 17, 2001Northern Illinois 33, Ball State 29at Northern Illinois
Sep 30, 2000Northern Illinois 43, Ball State 14at Ball State
Oct 9, 1999Northern Illinois 37, Ball State 17at Northern Illinois
Oct 3, 1998Ball State 18, Northern Illinois 13at Ball State
Oct 25, 1997Ball State 21, Northern Illinois 14at Northern Illinois
Oct 29, 1988Ball State 18, Northern Illinois 17at Northern Illinois
Oct 31, 1987Ball State 42, Northern Illinois 17at Ball State
Aug 30, 1986Ball State 20, Northern Illinois 10at Northern Illinois
Oct 5, 1985Ball State 29, Northern Illinois 0at Ball State
Sep 29, 1984Ball State 15, Northern Illinois 14at Northern Illinois
Oct 1, 1983Northern Illinois 27, Ball State 14at Ball State
Oct 2, 1982Ball State 14, Northern Illinois 7at Northern Illinois
Oct 3, 1981Ball State 23, Northern Illinois 0at Ball State
Sep 13, 1980Ball State 18, Northern Illinois 17at Northern Illinois
Nov 17, 1979Ball State 42, Northern Illinois 0at Ball State
Nov 18, 1978Ball State 31, Northern Illinois 13at Northern Illinois
Oct 15, 1977Ball State 31, Northern Illinois 6at Ball State
Oct 30, 1976Ball State 33, Northern Illinois 7at Northern Illinois
Oct 25, 1975Ball State 3, Northern Illinois 0at Northern Illinois
Nov 9, 1974Ball State 31, Northern Illinois 21at Ball State
Oct 20, 1973Northern Illinois 45, Ball State 17at Northern Illinois
Oct 23, 1971Northern Illinois 10, Ball State 10at Northern Illinois
Oct 24, 1970Northern Illinois 31, Ball State 14at Ball State
Oct 25, 1969Northern Illinois 17, Ball State 13at Northern Illinois
Sep 14, 1968Northern Illinois 40, Ball State 20at Ball State

Every game is listed as played on the field.