Pennsylvania at Columbia

Saturday, November 25, 1905

Pennsylvania beat Columbia 23–⁠0. It was their 12th meeting; after it, Pennsylvania led the series 8–⁠3–⁠1.

AwayPennsylvania12–⁠0–⁠1 in 1905
23
HomeColumbia4–⁠3–⁠2 in 1905
0

FinalAttendance 10,000

In the newspapers

  • The New-York tribune's story: WATERLOO FOR COLUMBIA NO MATCH FOR QUAKERS Pennsylvania Earns DecisiUe Gid. iron Victorq.

    New-York tribune, November 26, 1905, page 8

    Read the text

    WATERLOO FOR COLUMBIA NO MATCH FOR QUAKERS Pennsylvania Earns DecisiUe Gid. iron Victorq. afternoon by the score Of % tc o. From tba e.. blow OF the whistle the superiority OF the Philad phia team was clearly demonstrated Cutnrr1, and outplayed in every department Of the garDS Columbia could do little except fight honaI.Ss against the irresistible rushes OF the Penusvlvar backs. 1t was a game in which punting figured Ia-v.,from beginning to end. In the first half sbAhlS his long punts, which Collins could not eousi worked the ball down toward the Columbia -, when it was easy for Lamson and Robinso3 take 1t the rest of the way. Twice this hapra,.S and when the half ended the score board sborvas Il points for Pennsylvania In the second hal, Pennsyfvania scored two more touchdowns. h., sheble missed one Of the goals The Pennsylvanians started the gams ussh . rush Columbia kicked or to Greene, who cay-.s the ball to the D-yard line. On the hrS. 81 Stevenson tried quarterback run around Ieft a. and placed the ball on Pennsylvania’s EO-yars Ibefore he tackled To the disappointment the crowd in the Pennsylvania bleachers and a. delight Of the cheering Columbians, the RED ana Blue had been holding In the line and ns&sa, yard penalty placed the ball on Pennsylyanta,s 5-yard line. This was the nearest the bah ever “a, to the Pennsylvania goal. Shebie punted the bali out to Collins. WIN r.n the ball back to PENIS 50-yard line Here Colun bia could find no opening IN the opposing lins and punted A series OF punts followed, by each az which Pennsylvania made substantial EaIns Finally when the Quakers had reached Colurbds,s 45-yard line, they started 10 carry the ball Robin son crashed into the line again and again Sor he gains. He was ably assisted by Lamson and before ten minutes Of play had elapsed the big aeka went for a touchdown. Stevenson Kicked The ball out to Bemiss who heeed the catch and Sheble kicked the goal A score so early in the game discouraged ths two thousand Columbia IN the Blue and Whss cheering section who had come TO the park WITH the full expectation of seeing the home team win They came headed by the big 22d Regiment Band and all through the game made things Lively In the cheering line. Before the game they formed IN cial subway train and marched on the fei Il : body, singing “RayI Ray! Rayi for Old Columbia After marching once around the field they fled into the stand The Pennsylvania contingent came In by twOs and threes. but before the game began the Penn sylvania stand was well filed. and the Columbia oat tSe Ray Ray W Ray Pennsyvan ya a. 0En o gether about fifteen thousand people the game. and BY the time the rst half was haif hi-s over hs west stand was completely filed. and only few vacant seats were left on the east side Of the grid The feminine contingent was on hand in force never seen a football game before. kept plying TO play football. Almost every one OF them carried a red and blue white and blue flag, or else Of one college or the other figured prominently. The Columbia men were the hrst 10 arrive on was almost equaIled when the opposing squad trotted out few minutes later At the head Of the mascot, gorgeously arrayed in blue and white blanket bearing the word Columbia on each side While the team ran through signals he frsked about in front of the men. and had to be dragged from the field by trainer before the game began work with speed. Then the whistle blew and ths Iamson. Robinson Dennis and sheble were the men whom Pennsylvania depended upon 70 make gains Robinson was especially efIeetye S On 2..s through s the ght side Of the Columbia line ioT son found opening in the same place. while Dennis proved an able substitute b f9r FGEs eleven played together R9e1fs pert t ba Mhea Sa va! E11 s of splendid Interference, and while he stayed On his feet had ten men with him. pulling ana Coufnbia could do nothing against this attack The only part of the line that held conSistsntE and threw both Greene and Stevenson for losses on attempted end runs Fisher at the other Co- o. him. Both Stevenson and Collins showed spleh1a ability n running back P9a9ts h but IT. see4S4 gsct pSs Post who several times got down the held ahsaa Of Fisher the 0theT o ge back Yards I.avinne the star Pennsylvania end, did not show up as brilliantly he has in some Of the eral times down. the field ahead Of him: ~. game. lived up to his reputation of always having his eyes open for foul play Both teams spIIe[eee ea line cost Columbia forty-ve yards while Pennsy- d vana lost thirty ysafs endenex enc to- osd play al though both teams lost a few yards for clalsihs After Pennsylvania had scored the first touch, 1ho down Collins again ssed on TO 70 GfeeH ts yarG line shebe again punted but as the Two te1 bIm had changed goals he had the WING d agalSSs a Ran On its 50-yard line but after making eight yaT1s .ba ~ iInses ost * fteen Yards and Collins was forced punt With the wind he did 6ette5 . 1e tactes tio IN forcing the ball on exchanges OF punts toward ‘H’ Hsd sieVsns6n vs1 was thrown for loss by Post but made it up by a 13-yard run on the next s 2I@g, when shebie had apparently dropped 6af5 sn6sv IoT Vana got the ball Coiumba’s 4-ysEd lne ,s aeq, unable 70 siIn s was not successfl however the ball dropped into the waiting arms 9l b Stevenson ran Il back in splendid form, neatly lodging Pos From Colunbia’s 50yard line Pennsyyanl4 a p,S he Columbia goal AS usual, the Pennsylya1Eia s5d a1i ipeyi04qsd to to steyenson the who got back far as Colamba’s 4S-yard line. ~. otsgP Fg9m nafa6 hsES for as the coambia goal went around Posts end for eight yards Down, @ NS Pour Ave six eleven yards at time, and cneer tn aS the tbs would the Columbia followers c9Hld s6I5 n1I az the onslaught Not even the Irig%nqF % bgors sI.u Iamson referees whistle stopped the sbee n9 R6Sed the bali “fE1 vent over s4 vsae tine g6e g6e posfs lgs anu S’ Collins again Kicked or Greene who ran 16t ls ban bscL five Yards Sheble followed witn pun pun after several useless attempts to gain on TooTed bias part another exchange OF AtEs2 t5S Kicking match in which sheble steadily outdid Goi9sS b9s not Even at this b point Imf the game week ago agsipst Cornell which the Blue and Wh’s @ ,d of after having the against them a. dI 5I me work 6caTTefv 6aT however it was clear that Only har5 gf nonenaf streak of playing on the 1d oI5 save the New York team IRON +he announcement that ths ] v,es TO al the end Of the nTst a’1 gIoT M the Hsrvard-Yale game brought wiiq l. eRsI RyssIss possible Ia la ,S,,a Mo rooters who saw IN dte SJo-sbip defeaf a good reason for claiming the cnAA’f’ for themselves ,...,. r-ore than a repetinon of the first In the rst few minutes 1i,n o. by Collins A u @ ~ hail to the Red and Blue on o4,.,Se5Iyania -, ne The crushing f taetfs fdowed ya’ and after I’VE rae uss Rnbinson crossed the goal line Ior oint score goal by sheble added one th9t Columbia

  • The The Minneapolis journal's story: .QUAKERS TROUNCE COLUMBIA ELEVEN Four Touchdowns Scored BY Pennsylvania Opponents Completely Outclasesd.

    The Minneapolis journal, Minnesota, November 26, 1905, page 40

    Read the text

    .QUAKERS TROUNCE COLUMBIA ELEVEN Four Touchdowns Scored BY Pennsylvania Opponents Completely Outclasesd. by publishers Press New York, Nov. 25.-By the decisive score of 23 to 0, the University of Pennsylvania defeated the Columbia team at the American League park. Two touchdowns were netted in each half. In only one instance did Penn sylvania fail to make a goal. Pennsylvania outplayed Columbia at every period Of tho game. The Colum bia men would take occasional braces which enabled them to hold down the score, but at decisive moments, weak ened, and the blue and red was able to make good gains. Only toward the very close of the game did Columbia show to better advantage than her rivals With scarce | ten minutes to play, Columbia made a game stand and not only prevented Pennsylvania from making much head way against her, but really had the bet ter Of the argument. Columbia did not use the headwork that Pennsylvania did, and her men at critical times showed lack of Judgment. Columbia kicked off, the ball being downed on Pennsylvania g 2o-yard line. Pennsylvania lost on being penalized for off-side play, and after two at tempts to kick, punted to midfeld. Getting the ball again in midfield, Pennsylvania slowly worked it down toward Columbia goal. Line bucks carried the ball to the 20-yard line. For an instant the line held, but Pennsy resumed her fierce rushes and Lamson went over for the first touchdown. Sheble kicked goal. Score: Pennsylvania 6, Columbia 0. Resorts to Kicking. Pennsylvania resorted to kicking tactics on the second kickoff and Columbia was forced to play the same kind of a game because she could not gain against the red and blue line. Penn sylvania finally captured the ball on . her 5O-yard line. Green made ten yards on an end-run, and tandem plays ad, vanced the ball to Columbia’s 7-yard line. Green and Lamson carried the ball over. Sheble kicked goal. Score: Pennsylvania IL, Columbia O. ! The half end went without further scoring. The third touchdown came easily. Sheble kicked off in the second ha1f to Columbia g 80-yard line. Car ter punted out Of bounds and Pennsyl vania got the ball on Columbia 3 30. yard line. The tandem play was called into good service and soon landed the ball on Columbia g l5-yard line. Green made twelve yards around W. Fisher and Robinson was pushed over. sheble kicked the goal. Score: Pennsylvania 1s, Columbia 0 Pennsylvania fourth touchdown was scored in much the same way Van Salza was hurt and Armstrong took his place. Carter also was replaced il the Columbia line by Lindo. Ryan re lieved Davis for Pennsylvania. PennsJ got the ball on Columbia g 35-yard line and Rookie made a 2O-yard gain. Col umbia braced and Pennsylvania had tt fight for every other inch of ground but Lamson finally went over. Sheble failed at an easy goal. :. Score: Pennsylvania %, Columbia o

  • The Daily Kennebec journal's story: BY A SCORE OF % TOO Pennsylvania Shows Its Relative Su- periority Over Columbia Eleven.

    Daily Kennebec journal, Augusta, Me., November 27, 1905, page 4

    Read the text

    BY A SCORE OF % TOO Pennsylvania Shows Its Relative Su- periority Over Columbia Eleven. New York Nov. 26.-Columbia was no match for Pennsylvania in the an nual football game played at American League park, Saturday afternoon. At all stages and in all departments of the game the Pennsylvania were superior and the final score of % to indicates the relative strength of the teams. Carter. Columbias star back, was badly injured in a scrimmage late in the second half and had to be carried from the field. 1t was found that he had wrenched his spine and he was taken in an ambulance to a private hospital. Throughout the game Pennsylvania played good hard football. Columbia did not once rush the ball for first downs. The work of Collins at quarter-back was the feature of the blue and whites play. He did not quite match Stevenson in the distances of his punts but he was a sure man in the back field and time after time his sure tackles saved the Columbia goal.

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Pennsylvania 68% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Pennsylvania leads 61–⁠22–⁠1 in 84 meetings, counting the 72 since this game.

Recent meetings
2026Columbia 28, Pennsylvania 27
2025Pennsylvania 35, Columbia 21
2024Columbia 23, Pennsylvania 17
2023Pennsylvania 20, Columbia 17
2022Pennsylvania 34, Columbia 14
2021Columbia 23, Pennsylvania 14

Around this game