Pennsylvania at Columbia

Saturday, October 14, 2023

Pennsylvania beat Columbia 20–⁠17. It was their 81st meeting; after it, Pennsylvania led the series 60–⁠20–⁠1.

AwayPennsylvania6–⁠4 in 2023
20
HomeColumbia3–⁠7 in 2023
17

Final at Lawrence A. Wien Stadium, ManhattanTV: ESPN+Attendance 8,032

At kickoff
51°F, rain, wind 7 mph from the northWeather: NOAA NCEI Integrated Surface Database; La Guardia Airport (KLGA), 11 km from the stadium, 21 minutes after kickoff
Official
Jeff PumphreyGame officials: stats.ncaa.org box scores, via SportsDataverse

Scoring by quarter

TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
Pennsylvania3701020
Columbia770317

Standouts

Player stats

Pennsylvania

PassingC/AttYdsTDInt
Aidan Sayin30/4428611
RushingCarYdsTDLong
Malachi Hosley1558013
Isaac Shabay316010
Jacob Cisneros2504
Aidan Sayin3403
ReceivingRecYdsTDLong
Jared Richardson791025
Bisi Owens663126
Alex Haight748013
Jonathan Mulatu335026
DefenseTklTFLSacksInt
Shiloh Means0001

Columbia

PassingC/AttYdsTDInt
Caden Bell11/299101
RushingCarYdsTDLong
Joey Giorgi1656116
Malcolm Terry II527010
Caden Bell10616
ReceivingRecYdsTDLong
J.J. Jenkins236022
James Miller217013
Wills Meyer116016
Joey Giorgi31108
DefenseTklTFLSacksInt
Rocco Milia0001

From CollegeFootballData’s box score. Names lead to each player’s page. ★ a career high on file.

Team stats

PennsylvaniaColumbia
358Total yards180
286Passing yards91
72Rushing yards89
6.5Yards per pass3.1
2.3Yards per rush2.9
20First downs12
5–⁠16Third downs5–⁠16
1–⁠2Fourth downs0–⁠0
2Turnovers1
7–⁠46Penalties5–⁠35
36:52Possession23:08

Efficiency

PennsylvaniaColumbia
43%Success rate29%
0.08EPA per play−0.10
0.99Explosiveness1.13
−0.13Rushing EPA−0.00
0.31Passing EPA−0.19
39%Passing-down success23%
5%Havoc by its defense4%

From CollegeFootballData.com: each offense’s efficiency, and the havoc each defense caused. The better side of each line is bold.

Before kickoff

Our ratings and the line, going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Columbia 51% to win. Pennsylvania won as Elo’s underdog.

The line

Pennsylvania −3, over/under 34.5.

The last line on file before kickoff: the consensus line when the books publish one, otherwise a single major sportsbook’s.

Every drive

Columbia end zonePennsylvania end zoneQ1 PennsylvaniaField goal, 10 playsQ1 ColumbiaPunt, 4 playsQ1 PennsylvaniaInterception, 6 playsQ1 ColumbiaTouchdown, 7 playsQ1 PennsylvaniaPunt, 3 playsQ1 ColumbiaPunt, 3 playsQ1 PennsylvaniaTouchdown, 13 playsQ2 ColumbiaPunt, 6 playsQ2 PennsylvaniaPunt, 5 playsQ2 ColumbiaPunt, 4 playsQ2 PennsylvaniaPunt, 3 playsQ2 ColumbiaTouchdown, 10 playsQ2 PennsylvaniaEnd of half, 1 playQ3 ColumbiaInterception, 3 playsQ3 PennsylvaniaFumble, 4 playsQ3 ColumbiaPunt, 6 playsQ3 PennsylvaniaPunt, 4 playsQ3 ColumbiaPunt, 3 playsQ3 PennsylvaniaPunt, 6 playsQ3 ColumbiaField goal, 11 playsQ4 PennsylvaniaTouchdown, 7 playsQ4 ColumbiaPunt, 3 playsQ4 PennsylvaniaField goal, 11 playsQ4 ColumbiaPunt, 3 playsQ4 PennsylvaniaResult not recorded, 6 plays
Solid bars scored; an outline in the other team’s color marks points the defense scored. Columbia drives left to right, Pennsylvania right to left.
  1. Q1 PennsylvaniaField goal, 10 plays, 68 yards
  2. Q1 ColumbiaPunt, 4 plays, 18 yards
  3. Q1 PennsylvaniaInterception, 6 plays, 19 yards
  4. Q1 ColumbiaTouchdown, 7 plays, 32 yards
  5. Q1 PennsylvaniaPunt, 3 plays, 8 yards
  6. Q1 ColumbiaPunt, 3 plays, 5 yards
  7. Q1 PennsylvaniaTouchdown, 13 plays, 72 yards
  8. Q2 ColumbiaPunt, 6 plays, 14 yards
  9. Q2 PennsylvaniaPunt, 5 plays, 17 yards
  10. Q2 ColumbiaPunt, 4 plays, −6 yards
  11. Q2 PennsylvaniaPunt, 3 plays, 1 yard
  12. Q2 ColumbiaTouchdown, 10 plays, 55 yards
  13. Q2 PennsylvaniaEnd of half, 1 play, 0 yards
  14. Q3 ColumbiaInterception, 3 plays, 4 yards
  15. Q3 PennsylvaniaFumble, 4 plays, 9 yards
  16. Q3 ColumbiaPunt, 6 plays, 19 yards
  17. Q3 PennsylvaniaPunt, 4 plays, −7 yards
  18. Q3 ColumbiaPunt, 3 plays, −5 yards
  19. Q3 PennsylvaniaPunt, 6 plays, 40 yards
  20. Q3 ColumbiaField goal, 11 plays, 50 yards
  21. Q4 PennsylvaniaTouchdown, 7 plays, 72 yards
  22. Q4 ColumbiaPunt, 3 plays, 3 yards
  23. Q4 PennsylvaniaField goal, 11 plays, 50 yards
  24. Q4 ColumbiaPunt, 3 plays, −7 yards
  25. Q4 PennsylvaniaResult not recorded, 6 plays, −7 yards

Play by play

1st quarter7 drives, then Columbia 7, Pennsylvania 3
Pennsylvania Field goal, 10 plays
15:001st & 10 at own 13Malachi Hosley run for 9 yds to the PENN 22
15:002nd & 1 at own 22Aidan Sayin pass complete to Malone Howley for 12 yds to the PENN 34 for a 1ST down
15:001st & 10 at own 34Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson for 11 yds to the PENN 45 for a 1ST down
15:001st & 10 at own 45Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson for 25 yds to the COLU 30 for a 1ST down
15:001st & 10 at opp 30Aidan Sayin pass incomplete to Alex Haight, broken up by Aaron Brebnor
15:002nd & 10 at opp 30Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jonathan Mulatu for 11 yds to the COLU 19 for a 1ST down
15:001st & 10 at opp 19pass incomplete to Malone Howley
15:002nd & 10 at opp 19pass incomplete to Malachi Hosley
15:003rd & 10 at opp 19Aidan Sayin pass incomplete to Joshua Casilli, broken up by Hayden McDonald
14:551st & 10 at own 40Hugo Merry kickoff for 59 yds , Isaac Shabay return for 12 yds to the PENN 13
11:344th & 10 at opp 19Graham Gotlieb 36 yd FG GOODPennsylvania 3, Columbia 0
Columbia Punt, 4 plays
11:281st & 10 at own 40Santiago Sturla kickoff for 49 yds , Ty’son Edwards return for 12 yds to the COLU 23
11:281st & 10 at own 23Caden Bell pass complete to JJ Jenkins for 14 yds to the COLU 37 for a 1ST down
11:281st & 10 at own 37Joey Giorgi run for 3 yds to the COLU 40
11:282nd & 7 at own 40Caden Bell run for 1 yd to the COLU 41
11:283rd & 6 at own 41pass incomplete to Joey Giorgi
9:444th & 6 at own 41William Hughes punt for 49 yds
Pennsylvania Interception, 6 plays
9:441st & 10 at own 10Aidan Sayin run for 3 yds to the PENN 13
9:442nd & 7 at own 13Malachi Hosley run for 4 yds to the PENN 17
9:443rd & 3 at own 17Malachi Hosley run for 8 yds to the PENN 25 for a 1ST down
9:441st & 10 at own 25pass incomplete to Joshua Casilli
9:442nd & 10 at own 25Jacob Cisneros run for 4 yds to the PENN 29
7:023rd & 6 at own 29Aidan Sayin pass intercepted
Columbia Touchdown, 7 plays
7:021st & 10 at opp 35Joey Giorgi run for a loss of 1 yard to the PENN 36
7:022nd & 11 at opp 36Caden Bell run for 6 yds to the PENN 30
7:023rd & 5 at opp 30Joey Giorgi run for 16 yds to the PENN 14 for a 1ST down
7:021st & 10 at opp 14Caden Bell run for 2 yds to the PENN 12
7:022nd & 8 at opp 12Malcolm Terry II run for 4 yds to the PENN 8
7:023rd & 4 at opp 8pass incomplete to Joey Giorgi
4:114th & 4 at opp 8Pennsylvania Penalty, off-side (Jaden Key) to the PENN 4 for a 1ST down
4:091st & goal at opp 4Caden Bell run for 4 yds for a TD (Hugo Merry KICK)Columbia 7, Pennsylvania 3
Pennsylvania Punt, 3 plays
4:091st & 10 at own 40Hugo Merry kickoff for 57 yds
4:091st & 10 at own 25Aidan Sayin pass complete to Malachi Hosley for 5 yds to the PENN 30
4:092nd & 5 at own 30Malachi Hosley run for 4 yds to the PENN 34
4:093rd & 1 at own 34Liam O’Brien run for a loss of 1 yard to the PENN 33
2:094th & 2 at own 33Albert Jang punt for 39 yds , Carter McFadden returns for no gain to the COLU 28
Columbia Punt, 3 plays
2:091st & 10 at own 28Joey Giorgi run for 5 yds to the COLU 33
2:092nd & 5 at own 33pass incomplete to JJ Jenkins
2:093rd & 5 at own 33pass incomplete to James Miller
1:244th & 5 at own 33William Hughes punt for 42 yds
Pennsylvania Touchdown, 13 plays
1:241st & 10 at own 25Aidan Sayin pass complete to Joshua Casilli for 8 yds to the PENN 33
1:242nd & 2 at own 33Aidan Sayin pass complete to Alex Haight for 8 yds to the PENN 41 for a 1ST down
1:241st & 10 at own 41Isaac Shabay run for 2 yds to the PENN 43
1:242nd & 8 at own 43Isaac Shabay run for 10 yds to the COLU 47 for a 1ST down
Q2 15:001st & 10 at opp 47Isaac Shabay run for 4 yds to the COLU 43
Q2 15:002nd & 6 at opp 43Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson for 10 yds to the COLU 33 for a 1ST down
Q2 15:001st & 10 at opp 33Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson for 17 yds to the COLU 16 for a 1ST down
Q2 15:001st & 10 at opp 16fumbled, recovered by PENN Aidan Sayin
Q2 15:002nd & 13 at opp 19Aidan Sayin pass complete to Alex Haight for 10 yds to the COLU 9
Q2 15:003rd & 3 at opp 9Columbia Penalty, off-side (Patrick Passalacqua) to the COLU 4 for a 1ST down
Q2 15:001st & goal at opp 4Malachi Hosley run for 3 yds to the COLU 1
Q2 15:002nd & goal at opp 1
Q2 15:003rd & goal at opp 1
Q2 15:004th & goal at opp 1Columbia Penalty, off-side (Justin Townsend) to the COLU 1
Q2 10:124th & goal at opp 1Liam O’Brien run for 1 yd for a TD (Graham Gotlieb KICK)Pennsylvania 10, Columbia 7
2nd quarter5 drives, then Columbia 14, Pennsylvania 10
Columbia Punt, 6 plays
10:061st & 10 at own 40Santiago Sturla kickoff for 57 yds , Carter McFadden return for 31 yds to the COLU 34
10:061st & 10 at own 34Caden Bell pass complete to Edan Stagg for 7 yds to the COLU 41
10:062nd & 3 at own 41Caden Bell pass complete to Edan Stagg for 2 yds to the COLU 43
10:063rd & 1 at own 43Caden Bell run for 1 yd to the COLU 44 for a 1ST down
10:061st & 10 at own 44Caden Bell pass complete to Joey Giorgi for a loss of 1 yard to the COLU 43
10:062nd & 11 at own 43pass incomplete to Joey Giorgi
10:063rd & 11 at own 43Pennsylvania Penalty, off-side (Micah Morris) to the COLU 48
10:063rd & 6 at own 48pass incomplete to Wills Meyer
8:044th & 6 at own 48William Hughes punt for 49 yds
Pennsylvania Punt, 5 plays
8:041st & 10 at own 3Malachi Hosley run for 2 yds to the PENN 5
8:042nd & 8 at own 5Liam O’Brien pass complete to Alex Haight for 13 yds to the PENN 18 for a 1ST down
8:041st & 10 at own 18Liam O’Brien pass complete to Alex Haight for 4 yds to the PENN 22
8:042nd & 6 at own 22pass incomplete to Malachi Hosley
8:043rd & 6 at own 22Liam O’Brien pass complete to Jonathan Mulatu for a loss of 2 yards to the PENN 20
5:294th & 8 at own 20Albert Jang punt for 46 yds , Carter McFadden returns for no gain to the COLU 33
Columbia Punt, 4 plays
5:291st & 10 at own 33
5:292nd & 10 at own 33Caden Bell pass complete to James Miller Columbia Penalty, Offensive holding (Jack Larsen) to the COLU 23
5:292nd & 20 at own 23pass incomplete to JJ Jenkins
5:293rd & 20 at own 23Caden Bell pass complete to James Miller for 4 yds to the COLU 27
3:494th & 16 at own 27William Hughes punt for 51 yds
Pennsylvania Punt, 3 plays
3:491st & 10 at own 22pass incomplete to Alex Haight
3:492nd & 10 at own 22Jacob Cisneros run for 1 yd to the PENN 23
3:493rd & 9 at own 23pass incomplete to Jacob Cisneros
2:594th & 9 at own 23Albert Jang punt for 35 yds
Columbia Touchdown, 10 plays
2:591st & 10 at own 42Joey Giorgi run for 1 yd to the COLU 43
2:592nd & 9 at own 43pass incomplete to Marcus Libman
2:323rd & 9 at own 43Caden Bell pass complete to JJ Jenkins for 22 yds to the PENN 35 for a 1ST down
2:321st & 10 at opp 35Joey Giorgi run for 3 yds to the PENN 32
2:322nd & 7 at opp 32pass incomplete to Wills Meyer
2:323rd & 7 at opp 32Joey Giorgi run for 4 yds to the PENN 28 for a 1ST down Pennsylvania Penalty, personal foul (Micah Morris) to the PENN 14 for a 1ST down
2:321st & 10 at opp 14Malcolm Terry II run for 5 yds to the PENN 9
2:322nd & 5 at opp 9pass incomplete to Titus Evans
2:323rd & 5 at opp 9Caden Bell pass complete to Joey Giorgi for 8 yds to the PENN 1 for a 1ST down
0:231st & goal at opp 1Joey Giorgi run for 1 yd for a TD (Hugo Merry KICK)Columbia 14, Pennsylvania 10
0:231st & 10 at own 40Hugo Merry kickoff for 59 yds
3rd quarter7 drives, then Columbia 14, Pennsylvania 10
Columbia Interception, 3 plays
15:001st & 10 at own 24Joey Giorgi run for 2 yds to the COLU 26
15:002nd & 8 at own 26Caden Bell run for 2 yds to the COLU 28
14:571st & 10 at own 35Santiago Sturla kickoff for 45 yds , Ty’son Edwards return for 4 yds to the COLU 24
13:463rd & 6 at own 28Caden Bell pass incomplete to Marcus Libman, broken up by Logan Nash
Pennsylvania Fumble, 4 plays
13:461st & 10 at opp 42Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson
13:462nd & 10 at opp 42Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson for 8 yds to the COLU 34
13:463rd & 2 at opp 34Malachi Hosley run for 1 yd to the COLU 33
11:304th & 1 at opp 33Malachi Hosley run for a loss of 5 yards to the COLU 38 Malachi Hosley fumbled, recovered by COLU Patrick Passalacqua
Columbia Punt, 6 plays
11:301st & 10 at own 38Joey Giorgi run for 4 yds to the COLU 42
11:302nd & 6 at own 42Joey Giorgi run for 1 yd to the COLU 43
11:303rd & 5 at own 43Caden Bell pass complete to James Miller for 13 yds to the PENN 44 for a 1ST down
11:301st & 10 at opp 44Joey Giorgi run for 4 yds to the PENN 40
11:302nd & 6 at opp 40Caden Bell run for a loss of 3 yards to the PENN 43
11:303rd & 9 at opp 43Caden Bell pass incomplete to Edan Stagg, broken up by Shiloh Means
8:434th & 9 at opp 43William Hughes punt for 31 yds
Pennsylvania Punt, 4 plays
8:431st & 10 at own 12Aidan Sayin pass complete to Joshua Casilli for 6 yds to the PENN 18
8:432nd & 4 at own 18Pennsylvania Penalty, Offensive holding (Will Bergin) to the PENN 9
8:432nd & 13 at own 9Pennsylvania Penalty, false start (Malachi Hosley) to the PENN 5
8:432nd & 17 at own 5pass incomplete to Bisi Owens
8:433rd & 17 at own 5pass incomplete to Jared Richardson
7:424th & 17 at own 5Albert Jang punt for 36 yds
Columbia Punt, 3 plays
7:421st & 10 at opp 41pass incomplete to Joey Giorgi
7:422nd & 10 at opp 41Caden Bell run for 1 yd to the PENN 40
7:423rd & 9 at opp 40Caden Bell sacked for a loss of 6 yards to the PENN 46
6:054th & 15 at opp 46William Hughes punt for 38 yds , Isaac Shabay returns for 7 yds to the PENN 15
Pennsylvania Punt, 6 plays
6:051st & 10 at own 15Malachi Hosley run for 1 yd to the PENN 16
6:052nd & 9 at own 16Malachi Hosley run for 4 yds to the PENN 20 for a 1ST down Columbia Penalty, personal foul (Justin Townsend) to the PENN 35 for a 1ST down
6:051st & 10 at own 35Malachi Hosley run for 13 yds to the PENN 48 for a 1ST down
6:051st & 10 at own 48Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bisi Owens for 4 yds to the COLU 48
6:052nd & 6 at opp 48Aidan Sayin run for 3 yds to the COLU 45
6:053rd & 3 at opp 45Aidan Sayin pass complete to Alex Haight
2:314th & 3 at opp 45Albert Jang punt for 17 yds
Columbia Field goal, 11 plays
2:311st & 10 at own 28Caden Bell pass complete to Wills Meyer for 16 yds to the COLU 44 for a 1ST down
2:311st & 10 at own 44pass incomplete to James Miller
2:312nd & 10 at own 44Malcolm Terry II run for 10 yds to the PENN 46 for a 1ST down
2:311st & 10 at opp 46Malcolm Terry II run for 6 yds to the PENN 40
2:312nd & 4 at opp 40Caden Bell pass complete to Joey Giorgi for 4 yds to the PENN 36 for a 1ST down
2:311st & 10 at opp 36Joey Giorgi run for 9 yds to the PENN 27
2:312nd & 1 at opp 27Joey Giorgi run for 1 yd to the PENN 26 for a 1ST down
Q4 15:001st & 10 at opp 26Malcolm Terry II run for 2 yds to the PENN 24
Q4 15:002nd & 8 at opp 24Caden Bell pass complete to Malcolm Terry II for 2 yds to the PENN 22
Q4 15:003rd & 6 at opp 22Caden Bell pass incomplete to Wills Meyer, broken up by Grant Parker
Q4 13:284th & 6 at opp 22Hugo Merry 40 yd FG GOODColumbia 17, Pennsylvania 10
4th quarter5 drives, then Pennsylvania 20, Columbia 17
Pennsylvania Touchdown, 7 plays
13:281st & 10 at own 40Hugo Merry kickoff for 54 yds
13:281st & 10 at own 25Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jonathan Mulatu for 26 yds to the COLU 49 for a 1ST down
13:281st & 10 at opp 49Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bisi Owens for 12 yds to the COLU 37 for a 1ST down
13:281st & 10 at opp 37Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bisi Owens for 7 yds to the COLU 30
13:282nd & 3 at opp 30Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bisi Owens for 26 yds to the COLU 4 for a 1ST down
13:281st & goal at opp 4Malachi Hosley run for 2 yds to the COLU 2
13:282nd & goal at opp 2Pennsylvania Penalty, false start (Alex Haight) to the COLU 7
13:282nd & goal at opp 7Aidan Sayin pass incomplete to Malachi Hosley, broken up by Rocco Milia
9:443rd & goal at opp 7Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bisi Owens for 7 yds for a TD (Graham Gotlieb KICK)Tied at 17
Columbia Punt, 3 plays
9:441st & 10 at own 40Santiago Sturla kickoff for 45 yds
9:441st & 10 at own 25Caden Bell pass incomplete to JJ Jenkins, broken up by Logan Nash
9:442nd & 10 at own 25Joey Giorgi run for 3 yds to the COLU 28
9:443rd & 7 at own 28pass incomplete to Wills Meyer
8:524th & 7 at own 28William Hughes punt for 28 yds
Pennsylvania Field goal, 11 plays
8:521st & 10 at own 44pass incomplete to Bisi Owens
8:522nd & 10 at own 44Aidan Sayin pass complete to Alex Haight for 5 yds to the PENN 49
8:523rd & 5 at own 49Aidan Sayin pass complete to Alex Haight for 8 yds to the COLU 43 for a 1ST down
8:521st & 10 at opp 43Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bryce Myers for 15 yds to the COLU 28 for a 1ST down
8:521st & 10 at opp 28Pennsylvania Penalty, false start (Bryce Myers) to the COLU 33
8:521st & 15 at opp 33Aidan Sayin run for a loss of 2 yards to the COLU 35
8:522nd & 17 at opp 35Aidan Sayin pass complete to Joshua Casilli for 4 yds to the COLU 31
8:523rd & 13 at opp 31Aidan Sayin pass complete to Jared Richardson for 20 yds to the COLU 11 for a 1ST down
8:521st & 10 at opp 11pass incomplete to Alex Haight
4:382nd & 10 at opp 11Aidan Sayin pass complete to Joshua Casilli for a loss of 1 yard to the COLU 12
4:383rd & 11 at opp 12Malachi Hosley run for 6 yds to the COLU 6
3:044th & 5 at opp 6Graham Gotlieb 23 yd FG GOODPennsylvania 20, Columbia 17
Columbia Punt, 3 plays
3:041st & 10 at own 40Santiago Sturla kickoff for 45 yds
3:041st & 10 at own 25Caden Bell pass incomplete to JJ Jenkins Columbia Penalty, false start (Jordan Kelley) to the COLU 20
3:041st & 15 at own 20Caden Bell sacked for a loss of 2 yards to the COLU 18
3:042nd & 17 at own 18pass incomplete to Malcolm Terry II
2:213rd & 17 at own 18William Hughes punt for 33 yds
Pennsylvania Result not recorded, 6 plays
2:211st & 10 at own 49Malachi Hosley run for a loss of 1 yard to the PENN 48
2:162nd & 11 at own 48Malachi Hosley run for 7 yds to the COLU 45
2:103rd & 4 at opp 45Aidan Sayin pass complete to Bisi Owens for 7 yds to the COLU 38 for a 1ST down

Play-by-play from CollegeFootballData.com, as its scorers wrote it. The clock is the time left in the quarter; the spot is from the side of the team with the ball.

Pennsylvania leads 61–⁠22–⁠1 in 84 meetings, counting the three since this game.

Recent meetings
2026Columbia 28, Pennsylvania 27
2025Pennsylvania 35, Columbia 21
2024Columbia 23, Pennsylvania 17
2023Pennsylvania 20, Columbia 17
2022Pennsylvania 34, Columbia 14
2021Columbia 23, Pennsylvania 14

Around this game