SMU at Notre Dame

Saturday, October 13, 1951

SMU beat No. 5 Notre Dame 27–⁠20. It was their fourth meeting; after it, Notre Dame led the series 3–⁠1.

AwaySMU3–⁠6–⁠1 in 1951
27
Home5Notre Dame7–⁠2–⁠1 in 1951
20

FinalHigh 70°F, low 41°FAttendance 58,240

In the newspapers

  • The Evening star's story: Pouring Rain Is Best Defense Against Mustangs, Leohy Says

    Evening star, October 14, 1951, page 48

    Read the text

    Pouring Rain Is Best Defense Against Mustangs, Leohy Says SOUTH BEND, Ind, Oct. 13.- Fred Benners threw that football about as straight as it’s humanity possible. and that’s the whole story” That was Coach Frank Leahy’s explanation Of his Notre Dame teams 27–⁠20 upset by Southern Methodist today. H. N. Russell, coach Of the triumphant Mustangs. tempered his glee over SINUS first win over Notre Dame with the observation that “Benners threw ‘em and everybody caught ‘em. We figured we’d have to throw a lot to win. And that’s the way we went. Its just like a baseball game. II you hit ‘em where they amt. you’re a hero. If you don’t you’re not. sas mo, we didn’t have any preconceived plan of attack. When Fred started to hit on his passes, we just kept throwing them. We used the same pass patterns we’ve always used” Rain Best Defense. Leahy was slumped on a bench slipping a cup Of coffee. when reporters burst into the Notre Dame dressing room. Naturally. we tried to set up a pass defense when Southern Meth odist kept hitting those passes. Starting the second half, we switched from five to a four man line. Il guess Georgia Tech used the best possible defense against Southern Methodists passing-aI pouring rain” Georgia Tech beat SMU, 21–⁠7, in the seasons openerD Benners, perching a gallon hat jauntily on his head, refused to take any undue credit for his great aerial show. “Shucks, I was back there way back-tossing-with plenty of help from my teammates” said

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

On the newsreel

  • S.M.U.-NOTRE DAMEBig upset of the week at South Bend. Behind the amazing aerial artistry of Fred Benners, the Southern Methodist Mustangs score thrilling 27-20 upset over the Fighting IrishUniversal Newsreel, October 15, 1951. Catalog record at the National Archives

Universal Newsreel, National Archives (catalog record). Story titles and words as Universal’s release sheet gives them; the films themselves may still be under copyright, so we link to the record rather than show them.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Notre Dame 66% to win. SMU pulled the upset.

Notre Dame leads 10–⁠3 in 13 meetings, counting the nine since this game.

Recent meetings
1989Notre Dame 59, SMU 6
1986Notre Dame 61, SMU 29
1984SMU 27, Notre Dame 20Aloha Bowl
1958Notre Dame 14, SMU 6
1957Notre Dame 54, SMU 21
1956SMU 19, Notre Dame 13

Around this game