Carlisle at Columbia
Thursday, November 30, 1899 Share
Carlisle beat Columbia 45–0. It was their first meeting; after it, Carlisle led the series 1–0.
FinalAttendance 10,000
In the newspapers

New-York tribune, New York [N.Y.], December 1, 1899, page 1
Read the text
INDIANS BIG TRIUMPH. THE CARLISLE ELEVEN OyERWHELMS COLUMBIA ~ TO D. NEw-YORK PLAY -;Rs ~ POOR CONDITION A MEAGRE SHOWING AGAINST THE MAGNIFr -ENT WORK OF THE VISITORS THE VISITORS. Columbla’s hopes for a brilliant close ~ her football season were completely crushed by the Carlisle Indians Yesterday who overwhelmed the Blue and White by the remarkable score or – TO o. The work of the Indians was superb throughout, but so far as football playing IL concerned they met a foe hardly worthy OF their steel 1t is clear that Columbia arrived az the zenith Of her strength for the football season of lN7o just in time TO defeat the Yale eleven. for IN that contest nearly five weeks ago Columpia showed power and dash and Development that have been conspcuously absent almost ever since The players have been plainly over trained at times. and though the coaches believed that the college youths had rounded into good physical condition again. II was evident before the first fifteen minutes of play were over yesterday that the New-Yorkers were far from fit They were easily wnded and weIngh wholly exhausted before the first half was over PERFECT WORK BY INDIANS. Columbias poor condition should not detract in any way from tho brilliance OF the Carlisle Indian victory, for the native North Americans played a game yesterday that would have been a doubtful proposition for the very strongest varsity eleven on the gridiron TO tackle The Indian Interference by far the best thinS seen in New-YOrk this year. being superior IN both compactness and speed to the first class formations that Cornell displayed here against Columbia. In fact, it would be extremely dlffcult 10 pick flaws in the work Of the redmen- Thev tackled with a ferceness and an audacity that were never falling. They outSicked Columbia on every exchange and when it came TO rushing the ball whether through the line or around the ends Carlisle was simply invincible. PERHAPS the most noticeable feature OF their play. however was their speed az all times They played the fastest game seen on the grid iron this season Yale’s play at Cambridge against Harvard was characterized as extremely fast. but it was not so rapid as Carisles work yesterday. ONE SIDED ALL THE WAY THROUGH. It goes without saying that the score Of 10 T. was wholly unexpected in its hugeness by the most ardent partisan Of the Indians anf marks the game conspcuously. for the two elevens had been considered on about an even footing. and the odds were only slightly. II at all. in favor Of the Indians. But almost from the start It was apparent that Columbia was outclassed After the first three minutes OF play the red men began a series Of spectacular end rushes that carried the ball close 10 CO. umbia’s goal and. while the Indians did not AT once score they soon had the play close TN der the Columbia goal again and Hudson started the figur with ., for a field goal After that the Indians made, one after another series Of brilliant, hair-raisng dashes around the end that brought the ball repeatedly 80 close n their enemy’s goal that IL was simple matter 10 push It across The first haf closed with a score OF % to 0, and the second half was simply a repetition Of the first. the mighty Indians scoring almost AZ will. and az clocklks intervals. SOME SHGNT LIGHTS The Indian victory was an exceedingly po7ular one though the specta tors had not looked for such a one sided contest The record that the Carlisle men have made this season IN defeating the University Of Pennsylvania. scoring twice on Harvard and putting up such nerce struggle against Princeton. was on the lips or every ono Yesterday and the achevements or the Indian chiefs were promptly and warmly applauded Metoxen’s terrific line punses were a feature of the play that was greatly appreciated though naturally Senecas metNoriks runs up and down the field for tventy.nne thirty and hfty wards az a me W-re more oliilant and conspicuous Miller and johnson also made some beautiful runs. whle ‘P,a.’ Wheelock did any amount NJ gaHanl N’Ih. - tie Hudson ran the eleven in excellent Shape. dropped one pretty field goal, and kicked othfrs from touchdowns. on the Columbia side The work ~ Nceks IN the hack field was brilliant while in ITO hhH Wright and TongaCrc did excellent Norhs Weeks saved his country again ana “-”.u’ standing solitary 20 meet mo ln1lAh ioun,,’ whoever he might no. and almost never fauing 90 down him The score would nave o’-t considerably larger had 10 not been flr Wefks tackling Captain Wilson played nara. nui vas away below the form thar De showed ln tne Yale game The line mel. with the Two eAceptions that have been ment NED. Nri” NtaN . as water and allowed the indian backs 10 eaHop through them Al every point. while ON tne o. ferce the Columbia forwards were useless J” breaking holes or fleming interference BEFORE THE STRUGGLE There was a good crowd opt FOR The san’N ~ Manhattan Field but. as usual. The spectators thar occupied orchestra places on tho viaduct and Deadhead Hu We’re far more numerous than the ticket holders that were IN the grand stands Altogether there must hay” been ahout twelve thousand people VINO “iih’‘H’u ~ , game but aside from the size Or me ‘.0”d -, ~, character differed greatly from lha’ ,r r, 49, -, thousands that used to gather for mo l”ain, giving Day games between vale ana FIin.’,I,,. ~ Those struggles were inafh’1 9lN ,yy,trc- / most tremendous cheering ana pN ih’ TllsliLs – c,Iiage refrains Yesterday, however ‘lets was little cheering-what there was ot ‘oli.iss from a crowd Of Columbia men ‘n W. -, a. stand who pucki’y supported tn’F ‘r’t ~ The face OF certain defeat. and up 10 the nitIer e”1I, o.0o n m. the sturdy Columbia men ,rotted on the field and were greeted with te- .o,ious cheers from the Columbia students, rrho nor content with roaring royal welcome Sr The team cheerod each and every member ~ ~ oie,on individually. moment later tho T-diars ran out and began 10 practise their formations on the grdron which lay dry and tit,ht In the warm sunlight which shone with ~ a. 20 IGOR ~ September day. Columbia won .no ,,ss and tool, the west goal with a gentle Hreeze AZ her back. and then tho eievcns lined up as follows. ..,..-,,, Position Carlisle Indians Neldun-er lMCt taskeyl lfit ono - .Ts-N tackle Pores ,t0ie- Left guard teiWtffr 5--I,r, nNft r,s,--e ....... Ight gIanl Narren t|<i.t’ V.grr tackle N’Iee.1ce .t,r’,I,ct .Rg ght end .... Schcitrr tsicAeO Wilson captaInl Put- ,,,. ZIAfi.i.i ‘‘‘a.l ‘f’s-‘‘,, 49,. irurnsrt – RIGHT lalfbark.. Miller Gnhns’nD

The Seattle post-intelligencer, Seattle, Wash. Terr. [Wash.], December 1, 1899, page 1
Read the text
~ NEW YORK. Nov. ao.-The footbasf eleven OF Columhia. was beaten NJ &hAl Carlisle Indians at Manhattan feld today 45 to 0. There were probably 10000 people within the inclosure and fully as many more on the viaduct. This was by long odds the severest beating Columbia. has received this season.. Their team lined up exactly az on the day they defeated Yale. The Indians were in prime physicst eOs-‘ dition and tore through the Columbia Mne and skirted the ends at will. Long Runs by the Carlisle Baels. AT least eight times the Carlisle backs got around the end for runs OF from thirty to sixty yards. Most Of these runs wefe made by Seneca and Miller. Weeks stop ped most of them by beautiful tackles. but on two occasions ne was dragged over the line by main strength. On almost every kick the Carlisle backs ran the BAN back about twenty yards and twice the catcher got back sixty yards. Metoxen plunged through the line frequently for ten-yard gains. Columbia held the Indians for downs but three or four times during the entire game Hudson sc0ies q Goal From Field. Wheeler kicked off for the Indians at $50 o’clock. On the flrsl line-up Columbia tried long pass to sloeovitch to trick Rogers. This failed dismally. Then they tried double pass and just made their distance Carlisle forced Columbia to punt and the ball was the Indians in the center OF the field. In the second lineup Seneca got through the line for twenty yards. Hudson failed in trial for goal from the field. Morely kicked out from the 1-yard line. The Indians made short gains through the line on the next four downs, and then Seneca got through for = beau tiful run OF thirty yards and was dropped by Weeks on Columbia’s l0-yard Inc Carr isle failed on two attempts at Smythe. but Hudson dropped goal from the field. Score: Indians. s: Columbia. 0. Seneca Makes Touchdown. On an exchange OF kicks after the kick off, Columbia got around Echolder for q :hirty-yard line. This brought the ball to Carlisle’s 15-yard line. the only time dur ing the game In which their goal was In danger. Morley fumbled. however, the ball going to the Indians. Immediately Seneca got In another run Of 40 yards, and was stopped by Weeks. Smith got the ball on tumble. Columbia could not gain and had to kick. Seneca again got around the end for run of IS yards, and made I touchdown. wheelock kicked the goal. Score: Carlisle. IL; Columbia, O. Two More Goals. After this the ball zigzaged up and down the field, affording Wilson a chance for . field goal. which he missed Metoxen carr ried the ball down the field for the next touchdown. Within minute OF the end OF the half Miller scored another touch down. Both goals were kicked. making the score for the half: Carlisle, e; Columbia. o. Second Half. Both teams lined up for the second half unchanged. y Columbia did not seem to improve. And this half was merely q silcfession of long runs by Miller. Seneca. Metoxen and johnson. In ali four touchowns were made in this half. from which two goals we’re kicked Columbia was Al tho run hom the bssinniug d ths hall dtripg NhIah ~

The Worcester spy, Worcester, Mass., December 1, 1899, page 2
Read the text
Continued from Page One) closure, and fully as many more on the viaduct, This was by long odds the severest beating Columbia has received this season. Columbia’s team lined up exactly as on the day it defeated Yale, The Indians were in prime physical condition, and tore through the Column bia line and skirted the ends at will. At least eight times the Carlisle backs got around the ends for runs of from 80 to 60 yards. Most of these runs We’re made by Seneca and Miller. Weeks stopped most Of them by beautiful tackles. but on two occasions he was dragged over the line by main strength. On almost every kick the Carlisle’s backs ran the ball back about 20 yards, and twice the catcher got back go yards. Metoxen plunged through the line fire. quently for 10-yard gains. Columbia held the Indians for downs but three or four times during the game. Wheeler kicked off for the Indians On the first lineup Columbia tried a long pass to Slocovitch to trick Rogers. This failed dismally. Then Columbia tried a double pass, and just made the distance Carlisle forced Columbia to punt, and the ball was the Indians in the centre of the field. On the second lineup, Seneca got through Smythe for 80 yards Hudson then failed in a try for goal from the field. Morley kicked out from the 25-yard line The Indians made short gains through the line on the next four downs and Seneca got through for a beautifull run of 80 yards, and was dropped by Weeks on Columbia’s 10-yard line. Car isle failed on two attempts at Smythe, but Hudson dropped a goal from the field. Score-Indians 5: Columbia o. On an exchange Of kicks, after the kickoff, Columbia got the ball on Car isles 45-yard line. On double pass Morley got around Scholder for 30 yard run. This brought the ball to Carlisles 15-yard line, and was the only time during the game in which Carl isles goal was in danger. Morley FUN bled, however. the ball going to the In dams. Immediately Seneca got in another run of 40 yards, and was stopped by Weeks. Smythe got the bali on tumble Columbia could not gain and had to kick. Again Seneca got around the end for a run Of So yards and a touchdown. Wheelock kicked the goal Score-Indians IL; Columbia 0. After this the ball zig-zagged up and down the field affording Wilson a chance for a field goal which he missed. Metoxen carried the ball down the field for the next touchdown. Within a minute of the end of the half, Miller scored another touchdown. Both goals were kicked, making the score for the half, Carlisle %; Columbia 0. Both teams lined up for the second half unchanged Columbia did not seem to improve, and this half was merely a succession Of long runs by Miller, Seneca, MetoXen and Johnson. In all, four touchdowns were made in this half, from which two goals were kicked Columbia was on the run from the beginning of the half, during which five substitutes were called into | the game. The final scocre was: Carlisle 45; Co lumbia 0. The lineup:

Akron daily Democrat, Akron, Ohio, December 1, 1899, page 1
Read the text
FOOTBALL GAMES. At Pittsburg-Duauesne.. Country and Athletic club, Is; Washington and JET ferson, O. At AtPhiladelphia-University of Penn sylvania. 30; Cornell, o. At Chicago-Wisconsin, II; Michi gan, 5. At New Yorsh-Carlisle Indians, 45 Columbia, 0. At Easton-Lafayette. SO; Dickin son, O. At Chicago-University of Chicago II; Brown university, 6. AT Cleveland-Western Reser7e uni. versity. 16; Case School of Applied Science, 8.
Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.
Before kickoff
Our ratings going in
Our ratings (scores only)
Carlisle 55% to win. Elo’s favorite won.
The series
Every Carlisle–Columbia gameColumbia leads 2–1 in three meetings, counting the two since this game.
| 1901 | Columbia 40, Carlisle 12 | |
| 1900 | Columbia 17, Carlisle 6 | |
| 1899 | Carlisle 45, Columbia 0 |
Around this game
Carlisle
- Next gameat CaliforniaDec. 25, 1899
- SeasonCarlisle in 1899
- ProgramCarlisle history and records
Columbia
- Next gameat RutgersOct. 3, 1900
- SeasonColumbia in 1899
- ProgramColumbia history and records
