Princeton at Carlisle

Saturday, November 11, 1899

Princeton beat Carlisle 12–⁠0. It was their third meeting; after it, Princeton led the series 3–⁠0.

AwayPrinceton12–⁠1 in 1899
12
HomeCarlisle9–⁠2 in 1899
0

FinalAttendance 8,000

In the newspapers

  • The The Anaconda standard's story: RESULT WAS A cRUsHER Carlisle Indians Were Defeated by Princeton. 1T WAS A GREAT BATTLE They Put UP Formidable Game. but Were Outplayed by the Tigers-Pre- vious Victories Warranted Better Showing.

    The Anaconda standard, Anaconda, Mont., November 12, 1899, page 1

    Read the text

    RESULT WAS A cRUsHER Carlisle Indians Were Defeated by Princeton. 1T WAS A GREAT BATTLE They Put UP Formidable Game. but Were Outplayed by the Tigers-Previous Victories Warranted Better Showing. New York. Nov. 1.-THE Princeton football team took the Carlisle Indians into camp on Manhattan field this afternoon, but had a difficult time doing 1t. Princeton scored two touchdowns, one in each half. and the goals were successfully kicked, making the total at the finish II to in favor of the Tigers. The result, while not unlocked for, was a crusher just the same for the red men. Their victory over Penn sylvania and their double score against Harvard warranted a better showing for the Indians, but although beaten, they put up such a formidable game that they proved themselves worthy of football world. The attendance was between 5000 and 1000, the majority Of whom carried Princeton colors. Fully twice that number witnessed the game from the | outsides of vantage. At the call Of time the teams lined up, Princeton having the ball. Wheel er kicked off MetoXen and after four | minutes play Knight, right halfbaek | for Princeton, skirted Carlisle’s right end for a 45-yard run and planted the ball behind the line without assistance. the north side of the gridiron, making punt-in necessary. This was done successfully, and Wheeler kicked goal, making the score to 0 in favor of Princeton. Then Princeton enthusiasts let loose and bedlam reigned for a minute. Some 800 Princeton students in one of the field stands sang their university anthem, at the conclusion OF which the cheers broke out afresh. From this to the end Of the first half - .I.I. ,t-r NrxI and the Indians held the Tigers so close that Princeton was unable to pass Carlisle’s 25-yard line. All the | gains that Princeton made were accom- | plished around the ends, at which | points the Indians were weakest The second half was productive of numerous casualties, several men on | both sides being forced to retire Both | teams suffered, but during the inter- | mission none Of the Indians left the ! field. A few of them lay down on blankets, but the majority stood on their feet. while all of the Princeton | players had to resort to massage treat ment in the club house. When time was | called the Indians were just as frisky as ever, although one or two OF them limped slightly The Tigers lined up as in the first half looking none the worse | for wear. Substitute after substitute ! were called upon on both sides, owing | to the fierce playing in this half. After a series of end plays the ball was land | ed on the Indians five-yard line. Hodgman was pushed over for Princeton’s second touch down and Mills kicked a | goal, making the score Princeton IL, In | dams 0. From the time to the call Of | time no further score was made, and | when the whistle blew the ball was on | Carlisle’s 15-yard line after kick. The | lineup: | Princeton Position Carlisle / Pell ..........L. T....... Wheelock Mills Dana .......L. c.. ...... Redwater Booth ............. c.. ............ Smith | Edwards .........R. G........... Scott Hildebrand ......R. T. Scho1der- Warren Poe-Lathrop .....R. e.. sickles-Miller Hutchinson ......Q. B.......... Hudson | McCord .........L. +. B.. Metoxen- Johnson Knight-Kafer ...R. F. Be-. Seneca | Wheeler CO. and Pierce Co and | Hodgman ..F B......... Metoxen Score: Princeton IL, Carlisle 0. Touch downs: Knight and Hodgman

  • The The Indianapolis journal's story: Princeton Defeats Carlisle I'm a Stub horn and Bruising Contest.

    The Indianapolis journal, Indianapolis [Ind.], November 12, 1899, page 1

    Read the text

    Princeton Defeats Carlisle I’m a Stub horn and Bruising Contest. W. football team took the Carlisle Indians into camp on Manhattan Field this afternoon. but had difficult time doing it. Princeton scored two touchdowns. one in each half. and the goals were successfully kicked, making the total at the finish II to in IA vor of the Tigers. The result. while not unlocked for, was crusher just the same for the red men. Their victory over Penn sylvania and their double score against Harvard warranted a better showing from the Indians, but although beaten they put up such formidable game that they proved themselves worthy of the respect which Is paid them in the football world. In the first half of the game several men on both sides were hurt. but none faltered. In the second half many changes were forced Player after player was knocked out in short order and the enforced retirement OF Pierce weakened the Carlisle side more than little. The paid attendance was between 5000 and 7.009 the majority of whom carried Princeton colors. Fully twice that number witnessed the game from outside points OF Vantage. TIE Tigers. who donned their padded clothes in the clubhouse on the grounds. were the first to come on the field for preliminary work. and they were greeted with tumltuous cheers. In their brief practice the Tigers showed up to good advantage and their numerous tricks We’re watched with keen interest. Many snappy plays Were mace, and in each one the Princeton boys seemed TO be perfect With a yell. the Redskins, clothed in red sweaters and yellow helmets. jumped through the northern gate and burst upon the grounds about fiye minutes after their opponents had made their entrance. The crowd received the Indians most cordially lTrtf a nf Ia hQO nf Llttffaso B4iIs warriors The Red Mems prelinlinary work was necessarily OF shorter duration than that OF the Tigers. but their condition was all that could be desired. From Pierce. who lowered over the rest OF the group, 10 little Hudson the quarter back, each one of them had Drawn and AZ the call Of time the teams lined up. Princeton having the ball. Wheeler kicked play. Knignt, right half back for Princeton, skrted Carlisles right end for a forty-five yard run. and he planted the ball behind the reference The Tigers locomotive was turned loose, and IL echoed and re-echoed from the Hudson river TO the Long island snore. The ball, when downed, was away to the north side OF the gridiron, making a punt-in necessary. This was done success fully, and Wheeler kicked goal. making the score . 10 o in favor OF Princeton. Then the Princeton enthusiasts let loose. and bediam reigned for a minute. Some three hundred Princeton students I’m one OF the field stands sang their university anthem, at the conclusion OF which the cheers broke out afresh. From this TO the end OF the first half the game was stubbornly contest ed and the Indians held the Tigers very close--so close. in fact. that Princeton was unable 10 pass Carlisle’s twenty-fve-yard line. All the gains that Princeton made were accomplished around the ends, at which points the Indians were weakest. The second half WAS productive OF nusides being forced 10 retire. Both teams suffered. but during the intermission none Of the Indians left the field A few of them lay down on blankets, but the majority stood on their feet. while all Of the Prince

  • The The Salt Lake herald's story: Pennsylvania Football Team Defeats the Michigan Eleven. THE SCORE WAS II TO 10 BRILLIANT AND POOR PLAYING BY BOTH TEAMS. Princeton Takes In Carlisle Indians By Score of IL to o After Hard Fight-Many Players On Both Sides Injured and Forced to Re- tire From Game.

    The Salt Lake herald, Salt Lake City [Utah], November 12, 1899, page 4

    Read the text

    Pennsylvania Football Team Defeats the Michigan Eleven. THE SCORE WAS II TO 10 BRILLIANT AND POOR PLAYING BY BOTH TEAMS. Princeton Takes In Carlisle Indians By Score of IL to o After Hard Fight-Many Players On Both Sides Injured and Forced to Retire From Game. Philadelphia, Nov. Hin the fiercest game played on Franklin field this year the University of Pennsylvania fooes ball team this afternoon defeated the University of Michigan eleven IL to 10. The game was royal battle from start to finish, and was marked by brilliant and poor playing by both teams. Penn sylvania earned her victory because she had TO play harder for her two touchdowns than did Michigan The Michigan team made most of its gains on runs around Pennsylvania s left end, which was lamentably weak, while Pennsylvania had to gain her ground by fierce plunging through the line The game was a beautiful one for the spectators. Both teams were about as evenly matched as they could be. The Quakers excelled as they could be. The kicking. while Michigan far outplayed Pennsylvania when it came to skirting the ends. Mclean. Michigan’s left halfback. was almost invariably used for end running. The interferences accorded him were almost perfect, and this, in a great measure, helped him in gaining ground. Pennsylvania showed her old time form in line bucking, and Michigan was seldom able to hold the Qua, kers in their terrible plunges with the aid of the guards back. In the Kicking Line. In the kicking line, Coombs. although suffering with a lame shoulder, had no trouble in outpunting Street, who did the kicking for Michigan. The duel between Cunningham and Overfield, the center rushes, was interesting. Both are high class players, and they played with dash that was inspiring. Cum ningham had much the better during the first half but in the second period Overfield, through better staying quail ties. made big holes through Michigan’s center. Both teams fumbled badly and at critical moments. Pennsylvania was the worst offender. and probably would have made another touchdown in the first half had not one of the men let the ball slip through his fingers The Michigan team was frequently penal ICED for off-side playing more than any two teams that have played here this summer. The game, however, was fair and clean one. The game ended with the ball in Pennsylvania possession on Michigan’s orty-five-yard line.

  • The San Francisco call, San Francisco [Calif.], November 12, 1899

    Read the text

    CARLISLE’S ELEVEN IS SHUT OUT Indians Fail to Score in a Hard-Fought Game With Princeton. NEW YORK, Nov. 1.-THE Princeton football team took the Carlisle Indians into camp on Manhattan field this after noon, but had difficult time doing it. Princeton scored two touchdowns, one in each half, and the goals were successfully kicked. making the total at the finish IL to in favor of the Tigers The result, while not unlocked for. was a crusher just the same for the red men. Their vic tory over Pennsylvania and their double score against Harvard warranted a BET ter showing for the Indians. but although beaten, they put up such formidable game that they proved themselves worthy of the respect which is paid them in the football world. The paid attendance was between 500 and 1000, the majority of whom carried Princeton colors. Fully twice that num- Der witnessed the game from outside points of vantage. AT the call of time the teams lined up. Princeton having the ball. Wheeler kicked off to Metoxen and after four minutes play Knight, right halfback for Prince tom skirted Carisles right end for forty-hVe-yard run and planted the ball behind the line with the assistance of magnificent interference. The bali when returned was away TO the north side of the gridiron making punt-in necessary. This was done successfully, and Wheeler kicked a goal, making the score to in favor of Princeton. Then Princeton enthusiasm let loose and bedam reigned for minute. Some geo Princeton students in one of the field stands sang their university anthem, at the conclusion of which the cheers broke out afresh. From this TO the end Of the first half the. game. was stubbornly contested and the Indians held the Tigers so closely that Princeton was unabIe to pass Carlisle’s fifteen-yard line. All the gains that Princeton made were accom-

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Princeton 62% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Princeton leads 6–⁠0 in six meetings, counting the three since this game.

Recent meetings
1910Princeton 6, Carlisle 0
1907Princeton 16, Carlisle 0
1903Princeton 11, Carlisle 0
1899Princeton 12, Carlisle 0
1897Princeton 18, Carlisle 0
1896Princeton 22, Carlisle 6

Around this game

Carlisle