1957 William & Mary

4–⁠6 (2–⁠4 Southern Conference), coached by Milt Drewer.

Schedule and results

William & Mary in 1957, game by game: lost vs. George Washington 0–7; lost at No. 5 Navy 6–33; won vs. Virginia Tech 13–7; lost at Penn State 13–21; lost vs. VMI 13–14; lost at West Virginia 0–19; won at The Citadel 14–12; won at No. 10 NC State 7–6; won vs. Rutgers 38–7; lost at Richmond 7–12+31−27Lost 0–7 vs. George Washington-7George Washingt…Lost 6–33 at No. 5 Navy-27No. 5 NavyWon 13–7 vs. Virginia Tech+6Virginia TechLost 13–21 at Penn State-8Penn StateLost 13–14 vs. VMI-1VMILost 0–19 at West Virginia-19West VirginiaWon 14–12 at The Citadel+2The CitadelWon 7–6 at No. 10 NC State+1No. 10 NC StateWon 38–7 vs. Rutgers+31RutgersLost 7–12 at Richmond-5Richmond
Each game’s margin, wins above the line and losses below; orange marks an upset win.

Elo: a pregame chance from scores alone.

How it ended: Lost to Richmond 12–⁠7; unranked in the final AP poll; tied for 5th in the Southern Conference.

In program history: The 68th-best season in program history by end-of-season Elo (of 119 on file).

Record
4–⁠6
Conference
2–⁠4 tied for 5th in Southern Conference
AP final
Unranked
Points
111–⁠138
Coach
Milt Drewer
Elo
1378 +28 this season
SP+ rating
—
SRS
−2.4 No. 62 of 112 major-college teams
Recruiting class
—
Captains
Bill Rush and Larry Peccatiello

All-Southern Conference

3 first team

First team

  • Larry PeccatielloEAP-1
  • Elliott SchaubachOTAP-1
  • Bill RushCAP-1

From Wikipedia’s 1957 all-conference team article, with the selectors that named each player (AP-1: the Associated Press’s first team).

1957 Southern Conference standings

TeamConf.OverallAP final
VMI6–⁠09–⁠0–⁠120
West Virginia3–⁠07–⁠2–⁠1
The Citadel4–⁠25–⁠4–⁠1
Furman2–⁠13–⁠7
Richmond2–⁠44–⁠6
William & Mary2–⁠44–⁠6
Davidson1–⁠35–⁠3
Virginia Tech1–⁠34–⁠6
George Washington1–⁠52–⁠7

Ordered by conference winning percentage, then conference wins. Division splits and tiebreakers aren’t applied.