The 1920 All-America teams
9 selectors named All-America teams for 1920; the NCAA counts 4 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1920 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
INS
International News Service
First team
- EArmant Legendre, Princeton
- ERoger Kiley, Notre Dame
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTBertrand Gulick, Syracuse
- OGTim Callahan, Yale
- OGPercy W. Griffiths, Penn State
- CDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- QBDonold Lourie, Princeton
- RBCharley Way, Penn State
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
- FBArnold Horween, Harvard
Second team
- EChuck Carney, Illinois
- ELester Belding, Iowa
- OTRobert Minturn Sedgwick, Harvard
- OTFrank Coughlin, Notre Dame
- OGTom Woods, Harvard
- OGTarzan Taylor, Ohio State
- CBill Cunningham, Dartmouth
- QBBenny Boynton, Williams
- RBGaylord Stinchcomb, Ohio State
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- FBJack Crangle, Illinois
Third team
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- EClarence Swanson, Nebraska
- OTThomas V. Dickens, Yale
- OTClyde W. King, Navy
- OGCharles McGuire, Chicago
- OGAlbert W.T. Mohr, Illinois
- CWilliam Day, Nebraska
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBGeorge Owen, Harvard
- FBWalter French, Army
- FBBuck Flowers, Georgia Tech
Walter Camp
First team
- EChuck Carney, Illinois
- EBill Fincher, Georgia Tech
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTRalph Scott, Wisconsin
- OGTim Callahan, Yale
- OGTom Woods, Harvard
- CHerb Stein, Pittsburgh
- QBDonold Lourie, Princeton
- RBGaylord Stinchcomb, Ohio State
- RBCharley Way, Penn State
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
Second team
- ELuke Urban, Boston College
- EArmant Legendre, Princeton
- OTAngus Goetz, Michigan
- OTDan McMillan, Cal
- OGEdward E. Wilkie, Navy
- CDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- CBill Cunningham, Dartmouth
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- FBWalter French, Army
- FBHank Garrity, Princeton
Third team
- EHarold Muller, California
- EEddie Ewen, Navy
- OTTillie Voss, Detroit
- OTThomas V. Dickens, Yale
- OGFritz Breidster, Army
- OGDean Trott, Ohio State
- CCharles Frederick Havemeyer, Harvard
- QBBenny Boynton, Williams
- RBHinkey Haines, Penn State
- RBJimmy Leech, Virginia Military Institute
- FBArnold Horween, Harvard
Frank Menke Syndicate
- ELuke Urban, Boston College
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OGIolas Huffman, Ohio State
- OGJames Randolph Tolbert, Harvard
- OGCharles McGuire, Chicago
- CHerb Stein, Pittsburgh
- QBBenny Boynton, Williams
- RBGaylord Stinchcomb, Ohio State
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
Football World magazine
- ELuke Urban, Boston College
- EArmant Legendre, Princeton
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTRobert Minturn Sedgwick, Harvard
- OGTom Woods, Harvard
- OGPercy W. Griffiths, Penn State
- CDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
- FBWalter French, Army
Other selectors
Henry L. Farrell
First team
- EChuck Carney, Illinois
- EEddie Anderson, Notre Dame
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTBertrand Gulick, Syracuse
- OGTim Callahan, Yale
- OGPercy W. Griffiths, Penn State
- CDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- QBDonold Lourie, Princeton
- RBCharley Way, Penn State
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
Second team
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- OTThomas V. Dickens, Yale
- OTRuss Stein, Washington & Jefferson
- OGTom Woods, Harvard
- OGJohn Acosta, Yale
- CBill Cunningham, Dartmouth
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- FBWalter French, Army
- FBHank Garrity, Princeton
- FBJim Robertson, Dartmouth
- FBJack Crangle, Illinois
Third team
- EArmant Legendre, Princeton
- ECyril E. Myers, Ohio State
- OTGus Sonnenberg, Dartmouth
- OTClyde W. King, Navy
- OGEdward E. Wilkie, Navy
- CGeorge Bunge, Wisconsin
- CJack Heaphy, Boston College
- QBAubrey Devine, Iowa
- RBJimmy Leech, Virginia Military Institute
- FBBuck Flowers, Georgia Tech
- FBFred Strauss, Penn
Walter Eckersall
First team
- EChuck Carney, Illinois
- EArmant Legendre, Princeton
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTTillie Voss, Detroit
- OGJames Randolph Tolbert, Harvard
- OGJohn Acosta, Yale
- CPolly Wallace, Ames
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBGaylord Stinchcomb, Ohio State
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
- FBArnold Horween, Harvard
Second team
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- ELester Belding, Iowa
- OTGus Sonnenberg, Dartmouth
- OTFrank Coughlin, Notre Dame
- OGPercy W. Griffiths, Penn State
- OGFritz Breidster, Army
- CHerb Stein, Pittsburgh
- QBBenny Boynton, Williams
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- RBHinkey Haines, Penn State
- FBJack Crangle, Illinois
Newspaper Association of America
First team
- EChuck Carney, Illinois
- EHarold Muller, California
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTGus Sonnenberg, Dartmouth
- OGPercy W. Griffiths, Penn State
- OGJames Randolph Tolbert, Harvard
- CJack Depler, Illinois
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBPhil White, Oklahoma
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
- FBArnold Horween, Harvard
Second team
- EEddie Anderson, Notre Dame
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- OTRalph Scott, Wisconsin
- OTRoy Smoot, Oklahoma
- OGTom Woods, Harvard
- OGJohn Acosta, Yale
- CDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- QBDonold Lourie, Princeton
- RBGaylord Stinchcomb, Ohio State
- RBHinkey Haines, Penn State
- FBJack Crangle, Illinois
Lawrence Perry
First team
- EChuck Carney, Illinois
- EBill Fincher, Georgia Tech
- ELuke Urban, Boston College
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OGIolas Huffman, Ohio State
- CGeorge Bunge, Wisconsin
- QBDonold Lourie, Princeton
- RBGaylord Stinchcomb, Ohio State
- FBGeorge Gipp, Notre Dame
- FBHank Garrity, Princeton
Second team
- EArmant Legendre, Princeton
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- OTGus Sonnenberg, Dartmouth
- OTTad Wieman, Michigan
- OGDummy Lebey, Georgia Tech
- OGGeorge Hartong, Chicago
- CAndy Nemecek, Ohio State
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- QBHoge Workman, Ohio State
- FBArnold Horween, Harvard
- FBWalter French, Army
The New York Times
- ELuke Urban, Boston College
- EBird Carroll, Washington & Jefferson
- OTStan Keck, Princeton
- OTBertrand Gulick, Syracuse
- OGTom Woods, Harvard
- OGHarold Hess, Penn State
- CDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- QBDonold Lourie, Princeton
- RBTom Davies, Pittsburgh
- FBHank Garrity, Princeton
- FBJim Robertson, Dartmouth
From Wikipedia’s 1920 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.