The 1919 All-America teams
4 selectors named All-America teams for 1919; the NCAA counts 2 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1919 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
First team
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EHeinie Miller, Penn
- OTPete Henry, Washington & Jefferson
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OGDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- OGSwede Youngstrom, Dartmouth
- CRed Weaver, Centre
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBEddie Casey, Harvard
- FBIra Rodgers, West Virginia
Second team
- EFrank Weston, Wisconsin
- EJoseph DuMoe, Lafayette
- OTWilliam Grimm, Washington
- OTBurt Ingwersen, Illinois
- OGFred Denfeld, Navy
- OGJack Depler, Illinois
- CRuss Bailey, West Virginia
- QBJohn Strubing, Princeton
- RBMurray Trimble, Princeton
- RBArnold Oss, Minnesota
- FBJim Braden, Yale
Third team
- EEarl Blaik, Army
- ERed Roberts, Centre
- OTDuke Slater, Iowa
- OTJosh Cody, Vanderbilt
- OGCharles Arthur Clark, Harvard
- OGLloyd Pixley, Ohio State
- CTim Callahan, Yale
- QBBenny Boynton, Williams
- RBBill Steers, Oregon
- RBHank Gillo, Colgate
- FBJim Robertson, Dartmouth
Frank Menke Syndicate
Other selectors
Reno Evening Gazette
First team
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EDick Reichle, Illinois
- OTPete Henry, Washington & Jefferson
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTHoffman, Ohio
- OGRobert Sedgwick, Harvard
- CHarry J. Robertson, Syracuse
- QBJames Bradshaw, Nevada
- RBEddie Casey, Harvard
- RBMurray Trimble, Princeton
- FBIra Rodgers, West Virginia
Dick Jemison
First team
- EBob Higgins, Penn State
- EHeinie Miller, Penn
- OTPete Henry, Washington & Jefferson
- OTJosh Cody, Vanderbilt
- OGLloyd Pixley, Ohio State
- OGPup Phillips, Georgia Tech
- CRed Weaver, Centre
- QBBenny Boynton, Williams
- RBChic Harley, Ohio State
- RBEddie Casey, Harvard
- FBIra Rodgers, West Virginia
Second team
- EBernard Kirk, Notre Dame
- EPaul Meyers, Wisconsin
- OTBelford West, Colgate
- OTJoseph Murphy, Dartmouth
- OGDoc Alexander, Syracuse
- OGSwede Youngstrom, Dartmouth
- CBum Day, Georgia
- QBBo McMillin, Centre
- RBHank Gillo, Colgate
- RBBodie Weldon, Lafayette
- FBJim Robertson, Dartmouth
From Wikipedia’s 1919 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.