The 1910 All-America teams
22 selectors named All-America teams for 1910; the NCAA counts one of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1910 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- EStanfield Wells, Michigan
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Second team
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- EEdward J. Daly, Dartmouth
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OTBrenton G. Smith, Brown
- OGJoseph L. Wier, West Point
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- CEffingham Morris, Yale
- QBArt Howe, Yale
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- RBJohn Field, Yale
- RBJohn Dalton, Navy
Third team
- EHarold Eyrich, Cornell
- EJames Dean, Wisconsin
- OTHuber “Polly” Grimm, Washington
- OTSylvester V. Shonka, Nebraska
- OGGlenn D. Butzer, Illinois
- OGWill Metzger, Vanderbilt
- CCharles P. Sisson, Brown
- QBJohn McGovern, Minnesota
- RBFred “Tex” Ramsdell, Penn
- RBC.M. Taylor, Oregon
- FBHam Corbett, Harvard
Other selectors
The Cincinnati Post
- EStanfield Wells, Michigan
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CEffingham Morris, Yale
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
Outing magazine
- EStanfield Wells, Michigan
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- EEdward J. Daly, Dartmouth
- EArthur Berndt, Indiana
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OTAlfred L. Buser, Wisconsin
- OTHomer Dutter, Illinois
- OTRudolph “Rudy” Probst, Syracuse
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGGlenn D. Butzer, Illinois
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- CArchibald Vincent Arnold, Army
- CEffingham Morris, Yale
- CJohn Twist, Illinois
- CHarry Hartman, Syracuse
- CForsman, Lafayette
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- QBArt Howe, Yale
- QBJohn McGovern, Minnesota
- QBJohn E. Ingersoll, Dartmouth
- QBJames Scott, Penn
- QBSchef, Illinois
- QBV. Ballou, Princeton
- QBAshel Cunningham, Indiana
- QBJames Dean, Wisconsin
- QBG.H. Fletcher, Purdue
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- RBHamilton Corbett, Harvard
- RBFred “Tex” Ramsdell, Penn
- RBFred Daly, Yale
- RBJohn Field, Yale
- RBJohn Rosenwald, Minnesota
- RBThomas Andrew Gill, Indiana
- RBWilliam Crawley, Chicago
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
- FBJohn Dalton, Navy
- FBReuben Johnson, Minnesota
- FBPete Hauser, Carlisle
Leslie’s Weekly
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Second team
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGJoseph L. Wier, West Point
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- FBEd Hart, Princeton
Evening Standard
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
The New York Times
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTRalph W. “Bud” Sherwin, Dartmouth
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGWayland Minot, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBFred Daly, Yale
- FBJohn Dalton, Navy
Second team
- EEdward J. Daly, Dartmouth
- ESpringer H. Brooks, Yale
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGT.S. Wilson, Princeton
- CArchibald Vincent Arnold, Army
- QBArt Howe, Yale
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- RBHamilton Corbett, Harvard
Tommy Clark
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ERichard Plimpton Lewis, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBJohn McGovern, Minnesota
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Second team
W.S. Farnsworth
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ERichard Plimpton Lewis, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGJoseph L. Wier, West Point
- CArchibald Vincent Arnold, Army
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- RBHamilton Corbett, Harvard
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
The New York Sun
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
New York Herald
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
New York Telegraph
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
New York Evening World
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- EEdward J. Daly, Dartmouth
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGT.S. Wilson, Princeton
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- QBJohn E. Ingersoll, Dartmouth
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
The Philadelphia Press
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGT.S. Wilson, Princeton
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBArt Howe, Yale
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBFred “Tex” Ramsdell, Penn
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Second team
Former Yale star Ted Coy
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OGJoseph L. Wier, West Point
- CEffingham Morris, Yale
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJames Russell McKay, Brown
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Washington Times
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ESpringer H. Brooks, Yale
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
Pittsburgh Dispatch
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CRalph Galvin, Pittsburgh
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBTex Richards, Pittsburgh
New York Globe
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGT.S. Wilson, Princeton
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
New York Morning Telegraph
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Philadelphia Times
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap Smith, Harvard
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGJoseph L. Wier, West Point
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Andrew Latham Smith
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ETom Piollet, Penn State
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Pittsburgh Leader
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- EEdward J. Daly, Dartmouth
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OTLothrop “Ted” Withington, Harvard
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- CRalph Galvin, Pittsburgh
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBTalbot Pendleton, Princeton
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
The Pennsylvanian
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ETom Piollet, Penn State
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OTJames W. “Jim” Scully, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGBob Fisher, Harvard
- CErnest Cozens, Penn
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
From Wikipedia’s 1910 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.