The 1909 All-America teams
5 selectors named All-America teams for 1909; the NCAA counts one of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1909 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- EAdrian Regnier, Brown
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- OTHamilton Fish III, Harvard
- OTHenry Hobbs, Yale
- OGAlbert Benbrook, Michigan
- OGHamlin Andrus, Yale
- CCarroll Cooney, Yale
- QBJohn McGovern, Minnesota
- RBStephen Philbin, Yale
- RBWayland Manning Minot, Harvard
- FBTed Coy, Yale
Second team
- ELawrence Dunlap “Bud” Smith, Harvard
- ELaurence Bankart, Dartmouth
- EHarry Braddock, Penn
- OTTheodore Lilley, Yale
- OTRobert McKay, Harvard
- OGClark Tobin, Dartmouth
- OGWilliam “Bill” Goebel, Yale
- CPaul Withington, Harvard
- QBArt Howe, Yale
- RBDave Allerdice, Michigan
- RBJoe Magidsohn, Michigan
- FBJohn L. Marks, Dartmouth
Third team
- EHarlan Page, Chicago
- EFrank McCaffrey, Fordham
- OTRudolph Siegling, Princeton
- OTWilliam M. Casey, Michigan
- OGLothrop Withington, Harvard
- OGRobert Thomas Fisher, Harvard
- CH.E. Farnum, Minnesota
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBHamilton Corbett, Harvard
- RBRed Miller, Notre Dame
- FBGeorge McCaa, Lafayette
Other selectors
The New York Times
First team
- EAdrian Regnier, Brown
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- OTHamilton Fish III, Harvard
- OTHenry Hobbs, Yale
- OGHamlin Andrus, Yale
- OGClark Tobin, Dartmouth
- CCarroll Cooney, Yale
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBWayland Manning Minot, Harvard
- RBDave Allerdice, Michigan
- FBTed Coy, Yale
Second team
Tommy Clark
First team
- EAdrian Regnier, Brown
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- OTHamilton Fish III, Harvard
- OTJames Walker, Minnesota
- OGHamlin Andrus, Yale
- OGClark Tobin, Dartmouth
- CCarroll Cooney, Yale
- QBJohn McGovern, Minnesota
- RBWayland Manning Minot, Harvard
- RBDave Allerdice, Michigan
- FBTed Coy, Yale
UP
United Press consensus All-American team
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap “Bud” Smith, Harvard
- OTHamilton Fish III, Harvard
- OTHenry Hobbs, Yale
- OGHamlin Andrus, Yale
- OGClark Tobin, Dartmouth
- CCarroll Cooney, Yale
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBStephen Philbin, Yale
- RBWayland Manning Minot, Harvard
- FBTed Coy, Yale
Second team
- OGWilliam “Bill” Goebel, Yale
The Atlanta Constitution
First team
- EJohn Kilpatrick, Yale
- ELawrence Dunlap “Bud” Smith, Harvard
- OTHamilton Fish III, Harvard
- OTHenry Hobbs, Yale
- OGHamlin Andrus, Yale
- OGClark Tobin, Dartmouth
- CCarroll Cooney, Yale
- QBEarl Sprackling, Brown
- RBStephen Philbin, Yale
- RBWayland Manning Minot, Harvard
- FBTed Coy, Yale
From Wikipedia’s 1909 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.