The Citadel vs. VMI

The Citadel and VMI have 60 meetings on file, the first in 1920; The Citadel leads the series 33–⁠26–⁠1 in the games on file. Over the last 10 meetings it’s The Citadel 7–⁠3, and The Citadel has won the last 2. The winner takes home the Silver Shako, played for since 1976. The Citadel has held it since the 2024 game.

The Citadel wins
33
VMI wins
26
Ties
1
Earliest on file
1920
Longest streak
12 The Citadel
Current streak
2 The Citadel
Last 10 meetings
The Citadel 7–⁠3
Most recent
2025

The series at a glance

Every meeting by decade, colored by the winner
’0’1’2’3’4’5’6’7’8’9W–L
1920s0–⁠2
1930s2–⁠1–⁠1
1940s2–⁠2
1950s1–⁠8
1960s5–⁠5
1970s6–⁠4
1980s1–⁠1
2000s4–⁠0
2010s8–⁠1
2020s4–⁠2
Average margin
15 points; 21 decided by one score (8 or fewer)
At The Citadel
19–⁠9 The Citadel’s record at home
At VMI
16–⁠13–⁠1 VMI’s record at home
Neutral sites
1–⁠1 The Citadel first
Shutouts
7

Every meeting on file, as played. Ranks are the AP poll’s going in.

Silver Shako

Played for since
1976
Held by
The Citadel since the 2024 game
Games for it on file
24 The Citadel 19, VMI 5

Who holds it comes from the games on file: the winner of the latest regular-season meeting since 1976 (bowl rematches aren’t played for it); a tie leaves it with the holder (the usual rule; the article doesn’t say). The rivalry’s article counts the games for it: The Citadel leads, 32–⁠13–⁠1. From Wikipedia’s list of rivalry games and the rivalry’s article (CC BY-SA). More on the Silver Shako.

Games that tell the story

  1. The Citadel’s biggest win1970: The Citadel 56, VMI 9by 47 points
  2. VMI’s biggest win1954: VMI 42, The Citadel 0by 42 points
  3. Upset2019: VMI 34, The Citadel 21VMI had a 22% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  4. Upset1958: The Citadel 14, VMI 6The Citadel had a 26% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  5. Upset1955: VMI 14, The Citadel 7VMI had a 32% chance, by our ratings before kickoff

Coach against coach

YearsThe CitadelSeriesVMI
1949–⁠1952J. Quinn Decker1–⁠3Thomas Nugent
1957–⁠1965Eddie Teague3–⁠6John McKenna
1966–⁠1970Red Parker4–⁠1Vito Ragazzo
1973–⁠1977Bobby Ross1–⁠4Bob Thalman
1978–⁠1981Art Baker3–⁠1Bob Thalman

Head-coach pairings with three or more meetings on file, the series read from The Citadel’s side (Decker 1–⁠3 against Nugent). A season split between coaches goes to the one credited with the game.

Both programs through the years

End-of-season Elo ratings of The Citadel and VMI, 1920 on130015001700192019401960198020002020

Our Elo rating at the end of each season, a measure of how strong a team was, not a forecast; 1500 is an average FBS team.

From the newspapers

  • The Evening star's story of the 1930 game: ClTADEL'S DROPKICK DEFEATS v. M. l., 7-6 Point After Touchdown That Is Scored Late in Game Decides Bitter Struggle.

    1930 · Evening star, Washington, D.C., Oct 12, 1930

  • The Evening star's story of the 1952 game: vM| Tops The Citadel On Brehany's Passes

    1952 · Evening star, District of Columbia, Nov 16, 1952

  • The Evening star's story of the 1953 game: Mapp PAGES VMI To 14-O Victory

    1953 · Evening star, Oct 11, 1953

  • The Evening star's story of the 1954 game: Saturdays Stors

    1954 · Evening star, Nov 15, 1954

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The earliest meetings with a story on file; each game’s page has the full text.

Every game

Nov 14, 2026The Citadel at VMI upcomingat VMI
Nov 1, 2025The Citadel 35, VMI 24at The Citadel
Oct 19, 2024The Citadel 13, VMI 10at VMI
Oct 14, 2023VMI 17, The Citadel 13at The Citadel
Nov 19, 2022The Citadel 26, VMI 22at VMI
Oct 2, 2021The Citadel 35, VMI 24at The Citadel
Apr 17, 2021VMI 31, The Citadel 17at VMI
Oct 5, 2019VMI 34, The Citadel 21at The Citadel
Oct 20, 2018The Citadel 34, VMI 32at VMI
Oct 28, 2017The Citadel 21, VMI 3at The Citadel
Nov 12, 2016The Citadel 30, VMI 20at VMI
Nov 7, 2015The Citadel 35, VMI 14at The Citadel
Nov 22, 2014The Citadel 45, VMI 25at VMI
Nov 16, 2013The Citadel 31, VMI 10at The Citadel
Nov 10, 2012The Citadel 27, VMI 24at VMI
Oct 29, 2011The Citadel 41, VMI 14at The Citadel
Nov 17, 2007The Citadel 70, VMI 28at VMI
Nov 11, 2006The Citadel 48, VMI 21at The Citadel
Nov 19, 2005The Citadel 22, VMI 14at VMI
Nov 15, 2003The Citadel 27, VMI 23Neutral site
Oct 10, 1981VMI 14, The Citadel 0Neutral site
Oct 4, 1980The Citadel 28, VMI 0at The Citadel
Oct 20, 1979The Citadel 37, VMI 6at VMI
Sep 23, 1978The Citadel 14, VMI 3at The Citadel
Oct 15, 1977VMI 19, The Citadel 3at VMI
Nov 6, 1976VMI 30, The Citadel 14at The Citadel
Oct 25, 1975The Citadel 6, VMI 3at VMI
Oct 12, 1974VMI 20, The Citadel 9at The Citadel
Oct 6, 1973VMI 23, The Citadel 6at VMI
Oct 7, 1972The Citadel 42, VMI 3at The Citadel
Oct 9, 1971The Citadel 25, VMI 24at VMI
Oct 24, 1970The Citadel 56, VMI 9at The Citadel
Oct 18, 1969The Citadel 28, VMI 2at VMI
Oct 19, 1968The Citadel 13, VMI 8at The Citadel
Oct 14, 1967VMI 22, The Citadel 11at VMI
Nov 12, 1966The Citadel 30, VMI 14at The Citadel
Nov 13, 1965VMI 21, The Citadel 7at VMI
Nov 14, 1964The Citadel 17, VMI 0at The Citadel
Nov 16, 1963VMI 33, The Citadel 8at VMI
Nov 3, 1962VMI 16, The Citadel 7at The Citadel
Nov 4, 1961The Citadel 14, VMI 8at VMI
Nov 12, 1960VMI 20, The Citadel 6at The Citadel
Nov 14, 1959VMI 32, The Citadel 8at VMI
Nov 15, 1958The Citadel 14, VMI 6at The Citadel
Nov 16, 195713VMI 33, The Citadel 7at VMI
Nov 12, 1955VMI 14, The Citadel 7at The Citadel
Nov 13, 1954VMI 42, The Citadel 0at VMI
Oct 10, 1953VMI 14, The Citadel 0at The Citadel
Nov 15, 1952VMI 20, The Citadel 19at VMI
Nov 17, 1951VMI 27, The Citadel 21at The Citadel
Nov 18, 1950VMI 13, The Citadel 7at VMI
Nov 12, 1949The Citadel 19, VMI 14at The Citadel
Nov 13, 1948VMI 34, The Citadel 6at VMI
Nov 15, 1947The Citadel 7, VMI 6at The Citadel
Nov 16, 1946VMI 26, The Citadel 7at VMI
Nov 13, 1937VMI 27, The Citadel 0at VMI
Oct 8, 1932The Citadel 12, VMI 6at The Citadel
Oct 10, 1931VMI 13, The Citadel 13at VMI
Oct 11, 1930The Citadel 7, VMI 6at The Citadel
Oct 12, 1929VMI 13, The Citadel 7at VMI
Oct 16, 1920VMI 35, The Citadel 0at VMI

Every game is listed as played on the field.