Yale at Princeton

Saturday, November 14, 1908

Yale beat Princeton 11–⁠6. It was their 34th meeting; after it, Yale led the series 18–⁠9–⁠7.

AwayYale7–⁠1–⁠1 in 1908
11
HomePrinceton5–⁠2–⁠3 in 1908
6

FinalHigh 42°F, low 26°F, 2.01 in. of snow

In the newspapers

  • The The morning journal-courier's story: Goes Back to Fullback Position in Second Half and Princeton Linemen Are Unable to Stop His Advance. JOHNSON KNOCKED OUT Yale Players Say seigling Kicked Him Purposely--Dlllon Ends His Great Football Career by Down. ing Coy.

    The morning journal-courier, November 16, 1908, page 6

    Read the text

    Goes Back to Fullback Position in Second Half and Princeton Linemen Are Unable to Stop His Advance. JOHNSON KNOCKED OUT Yale Players Say seigling Kicked Him Purposely--Dlllon Ends His Great Football Career by Down. ing Coy. cated the coaches in their recent changes, and in the different style of practice since the game against Brown. Saturdays game was in many ways like that of year ago except that there was no brilliant quarterback like Tad Jones to inspire the team and to make long tusrterback runs. Coy had It.” even az he did the second half last year and he tore through the Princeton lire again and again, carry ing with him sometimes half the Princeton team cllnRinR to him. Goe- bel was always there to pull him along for extra gains, and the few times Goebsl ves missing Philbin and Hobbs were there with the pull. The other Yale men were generally good. Coy was phencrenal. He ex- ercised his rights ps field captain in the second half and dropped back to his old position. fullhact, filling 1t as he never did before and sending Field down to end. Field played end as If born to the position and Corey from then on ran the team like a whirl- wind. While Murphy was in he was n good consistent ground gainer, all his gains being short and steady. Hobbs went into the line at left tackle toward the middle of the game and proved his ability to hold the position. The center trio, Andrus, Riddle, Goebel were irreproachable. At tackle Brides played the same steady game which has marked him in every position he has ever played Johnson, who started the game at quarterback. and who seemed Yale’s only hope for the position, was kicked in the head by seigling, who now Is the Princeton captain. soon after the game started. The Yale players say that seigling did 1t Intentionally, but however that may be Johnson had no opportunity to show hls ability fin a big game. For the Tigers Tibbott played a great game. His gains were feature of the day. second only to those of Coy. seigling at tackle was Prince tons star lineman. Eddie Dillon ran the team In great shape and played a good individual game. His grit which has been byword on prep school and college athletic fields for six years and more, was never shown to a fuller extent than Saturday, He went into the game in poor physical condition. He fought for every inch Ho had his eyes everywhere and fol- lowed the ball all over the field. The culmination of his football career came when he tackled Coy. He downed Coy, but was carried off the field injured but struggling to get back into the game with his team. The progress of the game in genera is well known by now The field wa, slippery, due to the snow, sleet ant rain and both teams fumbled. Prince ton scored In the first half. Tlbbot made 45-yard run around Haines end. forward pass from Dillon tt Dowd netted 16 yards moro and Tibbot went through Haines and Lllley B yards more for touchdown Walle kicked tho goal Both the Yale touchdowns were mad in the second half, both very near tn end of the game, Both were tho resul of line plunges Coy carrying the bal most of the time with Goebel an. Brides for interference Sometimes tandem play was used with Coy Fiel and Corey The plungeH leading up [ the first touchdown were short Thos leading up to the second were longer 15, 20 and 30 yards at a time, Coy car rying the ball in practically ever plunge. When Coy retired after win ming the game his brother, Sherman ran out to meet him. The widest en thusiasm prevailed among the Yal cheering stands and no player wa ever given such an ovation as Coy. The game was one which was gen eraled by the sidelines With eac now quarterback, there was ne’ style of play. With Johnson the frs was unsuccessful, proabbly owing { the injury to Johnson. Bingham di not come Up to expectations Wit Corey came the line hammering whic sent Coy on for gain after gain, fC two touchdowns fin 12 minutes an finally to victory, Princeton. Yalt DONVu s..-s’....,......s, BulHeS, LSOBh Left End. EeiBllng .................. Lilley, Hobt Left Tackle. waller .s.....,.,..,.,,........ Anurl Left Guard MacFadyen “.,,,..,..............B Bidd Center Buckingham, Case, McGregor ....,...,..,...,.,..... Goeb Right Guard. Booth, Bamman ..................Br Brld’ Right Tackle. Welch, Bishop ..........,.. Coy tialn’ Right End. Dillon Johnson, Bingha Bergen .....,,................’ Core Quarterback Read ..........,,’.,’‘,... .......s.’ fHIppI Left Halfback Tibbott .................,. Murpt Right Halfback. Wheatc Dawson Pfelffer Fie McCrohan ...............s......’ Ct Fullback. hdowns--Tibbott, Coy CD, Goal Waller Hobbs. Referee, J Pendleto Bowdon. Umpire, J. II Minds, Un versity of Pennsylvania, Field Judg T. K. Hall, Dartmouth. LInesman, Young, Cornell Time of halves, minutes. rav ra1io b1a n11 b1ipntion of

  • The Los Angeles herald's story: YALE DEFEATS TIGERS, II TO 6 CHANCE IN WINNERS LINE UP EFFECTIVE SONS OF ELI PLAY LIKE PARTS OF GREAT MACHINE Princeton Scores Only Points In First Half, but Falls Down Badly In Second and Blue TrIumphs

    Los Angeles herald, November 15, 1908, page 27

    Read the text

    YALE DEFEATS TIGERS, II TO 6 CHANCE IN WINNERS LINE UP EFFECTIVE SONS OF ELI PLAY LIKE PARTS OF GREAT MACHINE Princeton Scores Only Points In First Half, but Falls Down Badly In Second and Blue TrIumphs PRINCETON, N. j., Nov. 14.-Princeton closed an inglorious football season with a defeat at the hands of Yale today, IL to 6. Outplayed in the first half, 8 to 0, Yale came back deter mined for the second, and simply car ried Princeton off its feet. Working like a piece of machinery in the OPEN ing half the Orange and Black returned for the second session to show only spasmodic flashes of the brilliancy displayed earlier. With Yale it was a different story. Entering contest for the first time since the sweeping switch of the men after the Brown game last Saturday, there was some anxiety in the Yale camp as to the outcome today, but as the contest progressed the work Of Yale improved. Princeton fought bitterly to avoid the impending disaster, but the flesh was weak. When, near the end of the second half, Captain Dillon, Princeton 5 great little leader, was carried from the field fighting and crying like a child, the heart seemed to be taken out of his followers. One by one the weak ened and battered Tigers were replaced by fresh men, until seven subs had been brought into the game. Probably not in the history of the games between the two universities have two men shone so brilliantly on their respective teams as did Coy of Yale and Tibbott of Princeton today. Tibbott, by his brilliant runs around ends and his wonderful work In open field, made possible Princeton’s only touchdown, while Coy, with bulldog tenacity and grit, tore great holes in the Princeton line, and many times 1t required the combined strength of at least four Princeton men to stop this player. If Yale has anything new in the foot ball book she religiously kept it hidden for the Harvard game next Saturday. She rarely tried the forward pass, and as infrequently resorted to the on-side play Yale relied almost wholly upon runs through tackle and Mound the ends and line plunges 1t was during one of these desperate dives by Coy when Yale was within striking distance of the Princeton goal. that Captain Dillon was struck and rendered unconscious. He remained in rather bad shape for several minutes, but the physicians say the plucky cap tain is suffering from a general relaxation and that his condition Is not Sc rious. The lineup:

  • The Omaha daily bee's story: YALE WINS FROM PRINCETON Blue Defeats the Orange and Black by Score of II to 6. COY AND TIBBoTT THE STARS Dillon of the Tigers Injured and Carried from the Field Yale Has No New Plays.

    Omaha daily bee, Nebraska, November 15, 1908, page 1

    Read the text

    YALE WINS FROM PRINCETON Blue Defeats the Orange and Black by Score of II to 6. COY AND TIBBoTT THE STARS Dillon of the Tigers Injured and Carried from the Field Yale Has No New Plays. PRINCETON, N. J., Nov. H-Princton today closed an inglorious foot ball season by a defeat at the hands of Yale by the score of II to 8. Outplayed in the first half and with the score 8 to 0 against them. the Yale eleven came back determined for the second half and simply carried the Princetonians off their feet Working like a well-oiled piece of machinery in the opening half the Orange and Black returned for the second session to show only spas modic flashes of brilliancy displayed earlier i’m the day. with Yale 1t was a different story. Entering a contest for the first time since the sweeping switch of the men after the Brown game last Saturday there was some anxiety in the Yale camp as to the outcome OF the game today, but as the contest progressed the work of Yale inn proved and eventually burst upon the tired and weakened Princeton eleven like an overwhelming flood. Princeton fought bitterly to avoid the i’m pending disaster, but the flesh was weak. When, near the end of the second half, Captain Dillon, Princeton’s great little leader, was carried from the field fighting and crying like a child, the heart seemed to be taken out of his followers. One by one the weakened and battered Orange and Black warriors were replaced by freshmen until seven substitutes had been brought into the game. Coy and TibbOtt Star. Probably in no game in the history of the contests between these two great universe ties have two men shone so brilliantly on their respective teams as did Coy Of Yale and Tibbott Of Princeton today. Tibbott by his brilliant runs around ends and his wonderful work in open field made possible Princeton’s only touchdown. while Coy with bulldog tenacity and grit tore great holes in the Princeton line and many times 1t required the combined strength Of at least four Princeton men to stop this player. At the start Goebel sent the ball almost to Princeton’s goal, where Tibbott picked

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Yale 53% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Yale leads 71–⁠45–⁠10 in 126 meetings, counting the 92 since this game.

Recent meetings
2025Yale 13, Princeton 10
2024Yale 42, Princeton 28
2023Yale 36, Princeton 28
2022Yale 24, Princeton 20
2021Princeton 35, Yale 20
2019Yale 51, Princeton 14

Around this game

Yale

Princeton