Amherst at Columbia

Saturday, October 15, 1904

Amherst beat Columbia 12–⁠0. It was their fifth meeting; after it, the series stood even at 2–⁠2–⁠1.

AwayAmherst9–⁠1 in 1904
12
HomeColumbia7–⁠3 in 1904
0

FinalAttendance 4,853

In the newspapers

  • The New-York tribune's story: VICTORY FOR AMHERST. COLUMBIA LOSES. 70 TO o. Massachusetts, Elsuen Outclosses the Blue and White.

    New-York tribune, New York [N.Y.], October 16, 1904, page 11

    Read the text

    VICTORY FOR AMHERST. COLUMBIA LOSES. 70 TO o. Massachusetts, Elsuen Outclosses the Blue and White. Columh.a at American LeacUe Park yesterday afternoon By a score Of l. 30 Q. Columbia s heres OF q victorious seacon In her big games with Tale Pennsylvania end Cornell received a decided shock. and ehere were few Columbia adsereats who would predict las- night anything save defeat FOR the Biue and White in these rhree matches. There was hardly a feature in -olurnbia’s play thai gare evidence Of promise FOR TIE big game. Coiurnia throushou. played very poor foot hal ard Amherst played 4 far better game There was &c point IN which Columbia col!d really claim superiority 70 he visitors The only reason Amherst cid not score oftener was not because Of any strength OF The home team but because OF the failure OF the visitors 20 take advantage OF their opportunities. Five tines Amherst fumbled the ball AT critical moments, and twice oRly. once IT each half. did Columbia succeed in recovering the hall from her opponents on downs. Columbia might almost as well have had an eleven OF seven men. so useless did the four men or the left OF the line prove. Echeverria, at left guard, was a target for the Amherst hacks. and again and again he was thrown aside as The Massachusetts men walked BY him for substantial gains. Finnegan was another weak spot, ard Brown was little better Post proved utterly unable 70 cope with Arnherst’s end plays. and often Muir. from the other end y the line was the man who finally stopped q pay thar had gone around Post ne other seven men or the Columbia eleven did all they could. but they were unable 10 check Ar-hers.’s attack directed at the left side For Amherst the star player was Hubbard He adrancec rha ball time after tine, and scored both Of Aulhe-st’s touchdowns. once he ran 100 yards for an apparent Touchdown. but hr1 Il Mne. and TIE play not allowed A few moments larer. after n. visitors mad advanced the leather twenty yards more on line plunges. Hubbard got around Post. ard. shaking or every Columbia tackler. ran eighty yards Toq touchdown. almost duplicating his previous feat which had not counted. For Columbia. Muir. al end, played an eToelent game Metzenthin did his best at quarrerback but, lacking any kind OF adequate sup Fort trcrl his team mates, he vas unable 20 DO much or quarterback runs. II was the lack OF team playing that did much TO iose Columbia the game. The men played each for himself. as they did early in the season, and often they had scarcely got into their places before Am he-st had its play under way. and had rushed the bah several yards before they were downed. This inability 70 get together los- Columbia practically q sure touchdown az the start OF The second half Then Columbia had the ball within Eve yards Of the visitors goal lire, only 10 lose il downs, when four attempts yielded only a yard gain. About i’ve thousand spectators saw The game There was q goodIy crowd OF Columbia men. who were reinforced with q brass band Am herst had also good sized delegation OF sup yorters who went Wild when their eleven was n rst 10 score Amherst won The toss and took the north END OF The gridiron- Columbia kicked OF. and, with the ball once II their possession. The 3dassachU- Esrts collegfails AZ once began al attack that carried the leather down me field in good style. EEe-- Al ms cary stage u “a IS evident that the VISITING team lzd The letter chance 10 win. Am hsrst sol 70 their cpPonsLls as-yaTo line, where re 6reL Of Inc me L1LLJles .os- them he ball Columbia then started rather an aggressive attack that carried the leather In good style 10 wIlain twenty-five Yards OF Arnherst’s goal There Amherst sti-eEec and took away ne ball or downs. Se1s1rick, cf Columbia, was hurt Father badly al this stage or the game, and had 10 retire After an exchange OF pulls. Amherst got the leather a. UidfelC. and then carried II r. % CoUrola’s 30-yard mark. There the Am hersr interference swept Post aside, and Hub bard dashed the remaining distance Tor Am hersIs lrsl score. the only one OF the period. Pierce Kicked the goal Toward The end Of the half 1-eLzrUthi- tried goal from the field for Columbia from the 3U-vard line. The ball left his FOOT we’ll but was zoo loZ. In the second half after several minutes OF LAY. = vas Au-herst’s BAH az her lO-yard line. There HUBBARD GOT around Post and ran ore hundred yards, Planting the ball behind TIE goal posts Of Columbia. The officials said there had beer holding IN the line and the ball was brought back. Columbia then made a splendid brace, and got the bail on downs With only six yards 70 80 fer score, the Blue and White faileo miserably IA IFS attempted lire pIUnges, and lost the bah on downs. Amherst rushed II several yards and rher Hubbard headed by sD-endld interference, sk1rted The end and ran nnIno!esled eighty yards for a touchdown Toward The end Of The haIf Columbia had the bal again within thirty yards % a tally. bu- Netzenlhln funhled- anG the pigskin went 70 Amherst The lineup arc score.

  • The The sun's story: ALAS. POOR COLUMBIA Overwhelmed by Amherst Speed and Strength. and Beaten. IL to o.

    The sun, New York [N.Y.], October 16, 1904, page 17

    Read the text

    ALAS. POOR COLUMBIA Overwhelmed by Amherst Speed and Strength. and Beaten. IL to o. speed, and outclassed In playing ability and weight. Columbia 3 football team was crushed by Amherst yesterday at American League Park. Two touchdowns and two goals. total Of l2points. was the score OF the visitors while Columbia did not seriously threaten her opponents goal line. The AM herst team not once was stopped by Columbia and lost tho leather mainly on fumbles. To Hubbard, her left half back. Amherst owed her two touchdowns and her many long and easy gains. Three times in the game Hubbard broke through the entire Columbia team, swept aside Metzenthin. and made long runs for touchdowns. The longest OF these. when Hubbard took the leather on his own lo-yard line and dashed 100 yards for touchdown. was not allowed Shannon had been holding Post, around whose end Hub bard had sprinted. and the play was called back Nothing daunted, minute later Hub bard again took the ball and this time ran eighty yards for a touchdown. He 1t was. too. who in the first half took the leather for thirty yards and the first touchdown Of the game. after the game tears stood In the eyes Of Thorp and Stangland. the mon who had played the game for all II was worth Tor Columbia. They were not at fault, but the same could not be said of the entire left wing OF the Column bia defence. From Post TO Finnegan. the line was weak. Post was easily boxed out OF every play, and it was his end that HUB bard circled at viii Brown at tackle was good for a gain whenever Amherst 80 willed IT, Ecbeverria m light as well have been on the side lines for all the aid he rendered Column bia Finnegan, hav ing to take up double task, also was a mark for the Amherst attack The other side was strong. Stangland. Thorp and Muir played e1cellently. the last named player especially. He was in every play, downing runners that Post should never have let 60 by him. pursuing Hubbard on both his runs and ailing him, although In both cases Q bit two late. The columbia back field was ponderously slow. Only once did the Morningside collegians come what could, be called danserously near the AmheIst goal That Tss II the oR Smbs 1mSsrst.s e”yard line. Three times Met sPssia psE ss1 H. c ths linz L ia tins Of Purple. Then Amherst took the BAY a.sa and E n he AZ. 0S fsn Ba and Whit. I’D I’D :: .ss %s o xs . eating s shSa5 Hss sSa BAL. WITCH s yesterday play revealed 70 the u r. IT, e’tfsa s1s fores vere al Tor Columbia, One, girl, with the sySs and Of which, hss Set a Ing face TO the limit. turned TO her escort and aid 9 With Wien hs zee escort s ssa snhs IL toe sad ssss asE tss S%Ss Tsnsss Ess she WASH I the only one who thought So. TIP north Hcslo o Snd SdE kIah o Amherst rushed the. bali to her own to.yard lns. before tumble gays the e. Leather cath n “a To ths ,a Vsltor 81 on their soyard line Colun the leather back to the ysitoIsi Hubbard .n ,a rd thirty ysSdF eaSs t. .S 3ry ~ sfra fess sedsa ‘e gain Of enough ETs t fSnbls By 8. Crook saved Columbia for tmhsS,s sos ball downs en- s sss ‘gS Ss :as r. SSSs5SssS ‘e” oa Sk h0s e a9d hz q ihe fda shs With The Amherst rooters went Wild and struck UP their favorite tune: Three cheers for Amherst. The Columbia band did its beat 70 dr s,.I but failed, IT, ‘‘‘‘ ‘‘‘ N Muir wa. PLAYING right end a. for S., Columbia Ts bard made his 100 yard run shortly after the kck-oh. but the ball was brought back be. cause Of shannons holding. Columbia got the ball on a tumble on Amhersts e-yard LINE The ball went back to the visitors on downs. and after Hubbard had run fifteen ran eighty yards for the last touchdown Of the game Columbia took q new lease OF life later and rushed the ball from midfeld to Amherst’s 2t-yard line, only 70 lose II there getting hurt in every play. and many changes were made. The Columbia rooters stood and sang Sans Souoi” after the game ended. and then eheered for each OF the players The line-up Amherst. Posntons. Columbia. p S,ook Lef end ,.......’‘.”‘t Post Professionalism guard ., %. .Echeverris LEIGHTON. Centre. Finn eg an nshoru--...s.. Right uuard. Sedg ewick Hollns. Right tackle. ,Thorp Shhnn on Rig ht end Buell. Shsttuck.........o Quarter bsok .....-. Metrenthin hubbard II half back. .......,.. Duell Crook, ,,.,... Right half back -. o Tough Full back. Stang and .Touchdowns-Hubbard az. Goals from touch soWns-Pierce On Rerferee-Vandcrpoel. Yale Tmp,p-white Michigan. Linosman – Carver Union. Time Of haives.as and 20 minutes, Sub Hilutes-Connen for Osborn. Diehl for Connell EsnotTs for Hubbard, Noble for CorreshAl

  • The The Birmingham age-herald's story: Amherst 12. Columbia o.

    The Birmingham age-herald, October 16, 1904, page 11

    Read the text

    Amherst 12. Columbia o. New York, October 15.-Out-played at every point Columbia’s football team was defeated 12 to 0 by Amherst at American league park today. Hubbard put up the best game for Amherst, SCOT ing both touchdowns. one after a run of eighty yards through the entire Columbia eleven.

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Columbia 69% to win. Amherst pulled the upset.

Columbia leads 4–⁠3–⁠3 in 10 meetings, counting the five since this game.

Recent meetings
1949Columbia 27, Amherst 7
1923Amherst 0, Columbia 0
1922Columbia 43, Amherst 6
1921Amherst 9, Columbia 7
1905Amherst 10, Columbia 10
1904Amherst 12, Columbia 0

Around this game

Amherst

Columbia