CollegeFootballDigestfrom CooperSearch

Presbyterian at Butler

Saturday, October 11, 2025

Presbyterian beat Butler 31–⁠25. It was their third meeting; Presbyterian leads the series 2–⁠1.

AwayPresbyterian10–⁠2 in 2025
31
HomeButler6–⁠6 in 2025
25

Final at Butler Bowl, IndianapolisAttendance 3,682

At kickoff
69°F, clear, wind 3 mphWeather: NOAA NCEI Global Historical Climatology Network hourly; Indianapolis Eagle Creek Airport, 11 km from the stadium, seven minutes before kickoff
Official
Grant HendersonGame officials: stats.ncaa.org box scores, via SportsDataverse

Scoring by quarter

TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
Presbyterian15301331
Butler793625

Standouts

  • PassingCollin Hurst12 of 16, 175 yards, 2 TDPresbyterian
  • RushingReagan Andrew31 carries, 115 yards, 1 TDButler
  • ReceivingNathan Levicki2 catches, 82 yards, 1 TDPresbyterian

Player stats

Presbyterian

PassingC/AttYdsTDInt
Collin Hurst12/1617520
RushingCarYdsTDLong
Justin Montgomery10134038
Zach Switzer1375214
Collin Hurst3308
ReceivingRecYdsTDLong
Nathan Levicki282175
Cincere Gill329114
B.J. Atkins325017
Dominic Kibby222016

Butler

PassingC/AttYdsTDInt
Reagan Andrew20/3319500
RushingCarYdsTDLong
Reagan Andrew31115122
Griffin Caldwell646114
Jack Weybright31006
Charlie Spegal4905
ReceivingRecYdsTDLong
Nick Munson559034
Ethan Loss436013
Michael Nix119019
Luke Jones119019

From CollegeFootballData’s box score. Names lead to each player’s page. ★ a career high on file.

Team stats

PresbyterianButler
385Total yards388
175Passing yards195
210Rushing yards193
10.9Yards per pass5.7
7.5Yards per rush4.0
16First downs26
4–⁠8Third downs7–⁠17
0–⁠0Fourth downs2–⁠2
1Turnovers0
3–⁠24Penalties3–⁠20
19:37Possession40:23

Efficiency

PresbyterianButler
55%Success rate48%
0.51EPA per play0.18
1.43Explosiveness0.94
0.37Rushing EPA0.25
0.72Passing EPA0.09
43%Passing-down success27%

From CollegeFootballData.com: each offense’s efficiency, and the havoc each defense caused. The better side of each line is bold.

Before kickoff

Our ratings and the line, going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Butler 56% to win. Presbyterian won as Elo’s underdog.

The line

Presbyterian −10.5, over/under 51.5.

The last line on file before kickoff: the consensus line when the books publish one, otherwise a single major sportsbook’s.

Every drive

Butler end zonePresbyterian end zoneQ1 PresbyterianTouchdown, 4 playsQ1 ButlerPunt, 3 playsQ1 PresbyterianPunt, 3 playsQ1 ButlerTouchdown, 15 playsQ1 PresbyterianTouchdown, 7 playsQ2 ButlerField goal, 13 playsQ2 PresbyterianField goal, 10 playsQ2 ButlerPunt, 5 playsQ2 ButlerTouchdown, 2 playsQ2 PresbyterianEnd of half, 2 playsQ3 ButlerField goal, 18 playsQ3 PresbyterianPunt, 3 playsQ3 ButlerPunt, 3 playsQ3 PresbyterianPunt, 3 playsQ3 ButlerField goal, 10 playsQ4 PresbyterianTouchdown, 1 playQ4 ButlerPunt, 8 playsQ4 PresbyterianTouchdown, 11 playsQ4 ButlerField goal, 9 playsQ4 PresbyterianEnd of game, 1 play
Solid bars scored; an outline in the other team’s color marks points the defense scored. Butler drives left to right, Presbyterian right to left.
  1. Q1 PresbyterianTouchdown, 4 plays, 75 yards
  2. Q1 ButlerPunt, 3 plays, 0 yards
  3. Q1 PresbyterianPunt, 3 plays, −1 yard
  4. Q1 ButlerTouchdown, 15 plays, 89 yards
  5. Q1 PresbyterianTouchdown, 7 plays, 75 yards
  6. Q2 ButlerField goal, 13 plays, 60 yards
  7. Q2 PresbyterianField goal, 10 plays, 54 yards
  8. Q2 ButlerPunt, 5 plays, 15 yards
  9. Q2 ButlerTouchdown, 2 plays, 20 yards
  10. Q2 PresbyterianEnd of half, 2 plays, 18 yards
  11. Q3 ButlerField goal, 18 plays, 67 yards
  12. Q3 PresbyterianPunt, 3 plays, 2 yards
  13. Q3 ButlerPunt, 3 plays, 5 yards
  14. Q3 PresbyterianPunt, 3 plays, 9 yards
  15. Q3 ButlerField goal, 10 plays, 57 yards
  16. Q4 PresbyterianTouchdown, 1 play, 75 yards
  17. Q4 ButlerPunt, 8 plays, 24 yards
  18. Q4 PresbyterianTouchdown, 11 plays, 75 yards
  19. Q4 ButlerField goal, 9 plays, 55 yards
  20. Q4 PresbyterianEnd of game, 1 play, −2 yards

Play by play

1st quarter5 drives, then Presbyterian 15, Butler 7
Presbyterian Touchdown, 4 plays
15:001st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
14:541st & 10 at own 25Collin Hurst pass complete to Cincere Gill for 9 yds to the PRES 34
14:292nd & 1 at own 34Justin Montgomery run for 36 yds to the BUT 30 for a 1ST down
13:571st & 10 at opp 30Collin Hurst pass complete to Dominic Kibby for 16 yds to the BUT 14 for a 1ST down
13:221st & 10 at opp 14Collin Hurst pass complete to Cincere Gill for 14 yds for a TD (J. Montgomery Run For Two-point Conversion)Presbyterian 8, Butler 0
Butler Punt, 3 plays
13:181st & 10 at own 35Jett Jackson kickoff for 65 yds , Ethan Loss return for 23 yds to the BUT 23
13:141st & 10 at own 23Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Ethan Loss
13:042nd & 10 at own 23Reagan Andrew run for no gain to the BUT 23
12:283rd & 10 at own 23Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Ethan Loss
12:174th & 10 at own 23Ryan Short punt for 39 yds , BJ Atkins returns for 9 yds to the PRES 47
Presbyterian Punt, 3 plays
12:091st & 10 at own 47Collin Hurst sacked by Jayden Norris for a loss of 9 yards to the PRES 38
11:302nd & 19 at own 38Collin Hurst pass incomplete to BJ Atkins
11:193rd & 19 at own 38Zach Switzer run for 8 yds to the PRES 46
10:394th & 11 at own 46Ethan Cartmel punt for 43 yds
Butler Touchdown, 15 plays
10:311st & 10 at own 11Griffin Caldwell run for 10 yds to the BUT 21 for a 1ST down
9:481st & 10 at own 21Reagan Andrew pass complete to Archie Cox for 12 yds to the BUT 33 for a 1ST down
9:121st & 10 at own 33Reagan Andrew pass complete to Chet Yardley for 6 yds to the BUT 39
8:372nd & 4 at own 39Griffin Caldwell run for 10 yds to the BUT 49 for a 1ST down
7:521st & 10 at own 49Gabe Passini run for 6 yds to the PRES 45
7:232nd & 4 at opp 45Reagan Andrew run for 7 yds to the PRES 38 for a 1ST down
6:431st & 10 at opp 38Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Charlie Spegal
6:382nd & 10 at opp 38Ethan Loss run for 2 yds to the PRES 36
6:023rd & 8 at opp 36Charlie Spegal run for 5 yds to the PRES 31
5:244th & 3 at opp 31Timeout Butler, clock 05:24
5:124th & 3 at opp 31Reagan Andrew pass complete to Griffin Caldwell for 4 yds to the PRES 27 for a 1ST down
4:411st & 10 at opp 27Reagan Andrew run for 6 yds to the PRES 21
4:002nd & 4 at opp 21Reagan Andrew run for 3 yds to the PRES 18
3:223rd & 1 at opp 18Reagan Andrew run for 1 yd to the PRES 17 for a 1ST down Presbyterian Penalty, Face Mask (8 yards) (Malik Lewis) to the PRES 9 for a 1ST down
2:541st & goal at opp 9Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Brady Preston
2:452nd & goal at opp 9Reagan Andrew run for 9 yds for a TD (Ryan Short KICK)Presbyterian 8, Butler 7
Presbyterian Touchdown, 7 plays
2:451st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
2:351st & 10 at own 25Justin Montgomery run for 6 yds to the PRES 31
2:082nd & 4 at own 31Collin Hurst pass incomplete to BJ Atkins
2:003rd & 4 at own 31Collin Hurst pass complete to Cincere Gill for 6 yds to the PRES 37 for a 1ST down
1:391st & 10 at own 37Collin Hurst pass complete to Justin Montgomery for 2 yds to the PRES 39
1:072nd & 8 at own 39Collin Hurst pass complete to Jaden Scott for 15 yds to the BUT 46 for a 1ST down
0:341st & 10 at opp 46Justin Montgomery run for 38 yds to the BUT 8 for a 1ST down
0:001st & goal at opp 8Zach Switzer run for 8 yds for a TD (Dixon Musgrove KICK)Presbyterian 15, Butler 7
2nd quarter5 drives, then Presbyterian 18, Butler 16
Butler Field goal, 13 plays
15:001st & 10 at own 35Jett Jackson kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
14:511st & 10 at own 25Jack Weybright run for 6 yds to the BUT 31
14:102nd & 4 at own 31Reagan Andrew run for 12 yds to the BUT 43 for a 1ST down
13:311st & 10 at own 43Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Loss for 7 yds to the 50 yard line
12:572nd & 3 at the 50Reagan Andrew pass complete to Cameron Heald for 5 yds to the PRES 45 for a 1ST down
12:241st & 10 at opp 45Reagan Andrew run for 7 yds to the PRES 38
11:442nd & 3 at opp 38Reagan Andrew run for 2 yds to the PRES 36
10:533rd & 1 at opp 36Jarrin Alley run for 1 yd to the PRES 35 for a 1ST down
10:101st & 10 at opp 35Reagan Andrew run for 5 yds to the PRES 30
9:422nd & 5 at opp 30Reagan Andrew pass complete to Gabe Passini for 17 yds to the PRES 13 for a 1ST down
9:061st & 10 at opp 13Reagan Andrew run for a loss of 1 yard to the PRES 14
8:242nd & 11 at opp 14Reagan Andrew run for a loss of 1 yard to the PRES 15
7:443rd & 12 at opp 15Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Ethan Loss
7:394th & 12 at opp 15Ryan Short 33 yd FG GOODPresbyterian 15, Butler 10
Presbyterian Field goal, 10 plays
7:391st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
7:341st & 10 at own 25Collin Hurst pass incomplete to BJ Atkins
7:272nd & 10 at own 25Zach Switzer run for 11 yds to the PRES 36 for a 1ST down
6:591st & 10 at own 36Zach Switzer run for 14 yds to the 50 yard line for a 1ST down
6:361st & 10 at the 50Zach Switzer run for 3 yds to the BUT 47
5:562nd & 7 at opp 47Collin Hurst pass complete to Nathan Levicki for 7 yds to the BUT 40 for a 1ST down
5:251st & 10 at opp 40Collin Hurst pass complete to BJ Atkins for 17 yds to the BUT 23 for a 1ST down
4:521st & 10 at opp 23Justin Montgomery run for 6 yds to the BUT 17
4:242nd & 4 at opp 17Collin Hurst pass complete to BJ Atkins for no gain to the BUT 17
3:493rd & 4 at opp 17Justin Montgomery run for 1 yd to the BUT 16
3:124th & 3 at opp 16Timeout Presbyterian, clock 03:12
3:124th & 3 at opp 16PENALTY PC False Start (Levicki,Nathan) 5 yards from Butler16 to Butler21. NO PLAY.
3:084th & 8 at opp 21Jett Jackson 38 yd FG GOODPresbyterian 18, Butler 10
Butler Punt, 5 plays
3:081st & 10 at own 35Jett Jackson kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
3:011st & 10 at own 25Reagan Andrew pass complete to Nick Munson for 4 yds to the BUT 29
2:342nd & 6 at own 29Reagan Andrew run for 6 yds to the BUT 35 for a 1ST down
2:001st & 10 at own 35Ershod Jasey II run for 4 yds to the BUT 39
2:002nd & 6 at own 39Timeout Butler, clock 02:00
1:502nd & 6 at own 39Reagan Andrew run for 1 yd to the BUT 40
1:213rd & 5 at own 40PENALTY Butler False Start (Caldwell,Griffin) 5 yards from Butler40 to Butler35. NO PLAY.
1:143rd & 10 at own 35Reagan Andrew run for 5 yds to the BUT 40
1:144th & 5 at own 40Timeout Presbyterian, clock 01:14
1:054th & 5 at own 40Ryan Short punt for 40 yds , BJ Atkins returns for no gain to the PRES 20 BJ Atkins fumbled, recovered by PRES Mason Armstrong
Butler Touchdown, 2 plays
0:481st & 10 at opp 20Reagan Andrew pass complete to Griffin Caldwell for 6 yds to the PRES 14
0:392nd & 4 at opp 14Griffin Caldwell run for 14 yds for a TD (Ryan Short PAT BLOCKED)Presbyterian 18, Butler 16
Presbyterian End of half, 2 plays
0:381st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 59 yds , BJ Atkins return for no gain to the PRES 6
0:001st & 10 at own 6Zach Switzer run for 11 yds to the PRES 17 for a 1ST down
0:001st & 10 at own 17Zach Switzer run for 7 yds to the PRES 24
3rd quarter5 drives, then Butler 19, Presbyterian 18
Butler Field goal, 18 plays
15:001st & 10 at own 35Jett Jackson kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
14:481st & 10 at own 25Charlie Spegal run for 1 yd to the BUT 26
14:142nd & 9 at own 26Charlie Spegal run for no gain to the BUT 26
13:423rd & 9 at own 26Reagan Andrew run for 10 yds to the BUT 36 for a 1ST down
13:051st & 10 at own 36Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Loss for 6 yds to the BUT 42
12:452nd & 4 at own 42Reagan Andrew pass complete to Cameron Heald for 4 yds to the BUT 46 for a 1ST down
12:111st & 10 at own 46Griffin Caldwell run for 3 yds to the BUT 49
11:322nd & 7 at own 49Reagan Andrew run for 2 yds to the PRES 49
10:523rd & 5 at opp 49Reagan Andrew pass complete to Nick Munson for 9 yds to the PRES 40 for a 1ST down
10:281st & 10 at opp 40Griffin Caldwell run for 3 yds to the PRES 37
9:532nd & 7 at opp 37Reagan Andrew run for 3 yds to the PRES 34
9:113rd & 4 at opp 34Charlie Spegal run for 3 yds to the PRES 31
8:234th & 1 at opp 31Reagan Andrew run for 1 yd to the PRES 30 for a 1ST down
7:451st & 10 at opp 30Reagan Andrew run for 7 yds to the PRES 23
7:122nd & 3 at opp 23Presbyterian Penalty, UNS: Unsportsmanlike Conduct (Jalyn Turner) to the PRES 10 for a 1ST down
6:341st & goal at opp 10Reagan Andrew run for a loss of 1 yard to the PRES 11
5:552nd & goal at opp 11Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ershod Jasey II for 3 yds to the PRES 8
5:213rd & goal at opp 8Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Brady Preston
5:174th & goal at opp 8Ryan Short 25 yd FG GOODButler 19, Presbyterian 18
Presbyterian Punt, 3 plays
5:151st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 50 yds , Jalen Patrick return for no gain to the PRES 15
5:081st & 10 at own 15Zach Switzer run for 2 yds to the PRES 17
4:382nd & 8 at own 17Zach Switzer run for no gain to the PRES 17
4:003rd & 8 at own 17Collin Hurst pass incomplete to BJ Atkins
3:524th & 8 at own 17Ethan Cartmel punt for 40 yds, punt out-of-bounds at the BUT 43
Butler Punt, 3 plays
3:431st & 10 at own 43Reagan Andrew run for 5 yds to the BUT 48
3:092nd & 5 at own 48Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Cameron Heald
3:063rd & 5 at own 48Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Nick Munson
2:574th & 5 at own 48Ryan Short punt for 39 yds , Darriel Harper returns for 5 yds to the PRES 18
2:574th & 5 at own 48Ryan Short punt for 39 yds , Darriel Harper returns for 5 yds to the PRES 18
Presbyterian Punt, 3 plays
2:471st & 10 at own 18Collin Hurst pass complete to BJ Atkins for 8 yds to the PRES 26
2:062nd & 2 at own 26Debo Hall run for no gain to the PRES 26
1:323rd & 2 at own 26Justin Montgomery run for 1 yd to the PRES 27
0:524th & 1 at own 27Ethan Cartmel punt for 50 yds
Butler Field goal, 10 plays
0:411st & 10 at own 23Reagan Andrew run for 22 yds to the BUT 45 for a 1ST down
0:001st & 10 at own 45Reagan Andrew pass complete to Nick Munson for 1 yd to the BUT 46
Q4 14:572nd & 9 at own 46Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Ethan Loss
Q4 14:403rd & 9 at own 46Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Loss for 10 yds to the PRES 44 for a 1ST down
Q4 14:081st & 10 at opp 44Reagan Andrew run for 2 yds to the PRES 42
Q4 13:202nd & 8 at opp 42Reagan Andrew pass complete to Nick Munson for 34 yds to the PRES 8 for a 1ST down
Q4 12:451st & goal at opp 8(12:49) No Huddle-Shotgun Andrew,Reagan pass incomplete short left to Munson,Nick thrown to PC00 PENALTY Butler Holding (McPhee,Alexander) 10 yards from PC08 to PC18. NO PLAY.
Q4 12:381st & goal at opp 18Reagan Andrew run for 2 yds to the PRES 16
Q4 11:592nd & goal at opp 16Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Griffin Caldwell
Q4 11:473rd & goal at opp 16Reagan Andrew sacked for a loss of 4 yards to the PRES 20
Q4 11:114th & goal at opp 20Ryan Short 37 yd FG GOODButler 22, Presbyterian 18
4th quarter5 drives, then Presbyterian 31, Butler 25
Presbyterian Touchdown, 1 play
11:111st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
11:001st & 10 at own 25Collin Hurst pass complete to Nathan Levicki for 75 yds for a TD (Dixon Musgrove PAT MISSED)Presbyterian 24, Butler 22
Butler Punt, 8 plays
11:001st & 10 at own 35Jett Jackson kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
10:441st & 10 at own 25Jack Weybright run for 1 yd to the BUT 26
10:142nd & 9 at own 26Reagan Andrew run for 10 yds to the BUT 36 for a 1ST down
9:211st & 10 at own 36Reagan Andrew pass complete to Chet Yardley for 5 yds to the BUT 41
9:002nd & 5 at own 41Reagan Andrew run for 4 yds to the BUT 45
8:273rd & 1 at own 45Jack Weybright run for 3 yds to the BUT 48 for a 1ST down
7:461st & 10 at own 48Reagan Andrew run for 1 yd to the BUT 49
7:012nd & 9 at own 49Reagan Andrew sacked by Carter Szydlowski for a loss of 13 yards to the BUT 36
6:103rd & 22 at own 36Reagan Andrew pass complete to Ethan Loss for 13 yds to the BUT 49
5:354th & 9 at own 49Ryan Short punt for 39 yds , Darriel Harper returns for 13 yds to the PRES 25
Presbyterian Touchdown, 11 plays
5:271st & 10 at own 25Collin Hurst run for 4 yds to the PRES 29
4:462nd & 6 at own 29Justin Montgomery run for a loss of 1 yard to the PRES 28
4:003rd & 7 at own 28Collin Hurst run for 8 yds to the PRES 36 for a 1ST down
3:251st & 10 at own 36Zach Switzer run for 4 yds to the PRES 40
2:462nd & 6 at own 40Justin Montgomery run for 2 yds to the PRES 42
2:003rd & 4 at own 42Collin Hurst pass complete to Dominic Kibby for 6 yds to the PRES 48 for a 1ST down
2:001st & 10 at own 48Timeout Butler, clock 02:00
1:521st & 10 at own 48Justin Montgomery run for 37 yds to the BUT 15 for a 1ST down
1:441st & 10 at opp 15Justin Montgomery run for 8 yds to the BUT 7
1:432nd & 2 at opp 7Timeout Butler, clock 01:43
1:382nd & 2 at opp 7Zach Switzer run for a loss of 1 yard to the BUT 8
1:383rd & 3 at opp 8Timeout Butler, clock 01:38
1:333rd & 3 at opp 8Zach Switzer run for 5 yds to the BUT 3 for a 1ST down
1:001st & goal at opp 3Zach Switzer run for 3 yds for a TD (Dixon Musgrove KICK)Presbyterian 31, Butler 22
Butler Field goal, 9 plays
0:551st & 10 at own 35Jett Jackson kickoff for 65 yds , Ethan Loss return for 21 yds to the BUT 21
0:491st & 10 at own 21Reagan Andrew pass complete to Nick Munson for 11 yds to the BUT 32 for a 1ST down
0:451st & 10 at own 32Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Nick Munson
0:392nd & 10 at own 32Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Ethan Loss
0:333rd & 10 at own 32Reagan Andrew pass complete to Michael Nix for 19 yds to the PRES 49 for a 1ST down
0:261st & 10 at opp 49Reagan Andrew pass complete to Luke Jones for 19 yds to the PRES 30 for a 1ST down
0:241st & 10 at opp 30Reagan Andrew pass incomplete
0:242nd & 10 at opp 30Timeout Presbyterian, clock 00:24
0:192nd & 10 at opp 30Reagan Andrew pass incomplete to Nick Munson
0:143rd & 10 at opp 30Griffin Caldwell run for 6 yds to the PRES 24
0:144th & 4 at opp 24Timeout Butler, clock 00:14
0:104th & 4 at opp 24Ryan Short 41 yd FG GOODPresbyterian 31, Butler 25
Presbyterian End of game, 1 play
0:101st & 10 at own 35Ryan Short kickoff for 20 yds
0:001st & 10 at the 50C. Hurst takes a knee

Play-by-play from CollegeFootballData.com, as its scorers wrote it. The clock is the time left in the quarter; the spot is from the side of the team with the ball.

The series

Every Presbyterian–Butler game

Presbyterian leads 2–⁠1 in three meetings.

Recent meetings
2025Presbyterian 31, Butler 25
2024Presbyterian 30, Butler 27
2023Butler 27, Presbyterian 17

Around this game

Presbyterian

Butler

Ranked games that day

Every game of Week 7