Referee Kevin Hassell; umpire Mchl Henderson; head linesman Bill Scott; line judge David Young; side judge Steve Heinman; field judge Robert Asel; back judge Robert Lewis; center judge Corey LongGame officials: stats.ncaa.org box scores, via SportsDataverse
Scoring by quarter
Team
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Final
App State
7
13
7
7
34
Toledo
0
0
0
0
0
Standouts
No. 25RushingJalin Moore22 carries, 125 yards, 3 TDApp State
No. 51DefenseCaleb Fuller4 tackles, 1.5 sacks, 3 for lossApp State
From CollegeFootballData’s box score. Names lead to each player’s page. ★ a career high on file.
Team stats
App State
Toledo
458
Total yards
146
131
Passing yards
124
327
Rushing yards
22
7.7
Yards per pass
4.3
6.2
Yards per rush
1.0
23
First downs
8
3–13
Third downs
2–12
1–3
Fourth downs
1–1
0
Turnovers
4
4–25
Penalties
5–35
35:50
Possession
24:10
4
Sacks (by defense)
0
Efficiency
App State
Toledo
49%
Success rate
20%
0.16
EPA per play
−0.38
1.12
Explosiveness
1.59
0.34
Rushing EPA
−0.18
−0.25
Passing EPA
−0.48
47%
Passing-down success
21%
0.23
First-down EPA
−0.73
0.57
Second-down EPA
−0.26
0.01
Third-down EPA
−0.29
24%
Havoc by its defense
14%
From CollegeFootballData.com: each offense’s efficiency, and the havoc each defense caused. The better side of each line is bold.
Before kickoff
Our ratings and the line, going in
Our ratings (scores only)
Toledo 61% to win. App State won as Elo’s underdog.
The line
Toledo −6, over/under 61.5.
The last line on file before kickoff: the consensus line when the books publish one, otherwise a single major sportsbook’s.
Before kickoff, the win chances were Toledo 66%, App State 34%. CollegeFootballData.com’s estimate from the point spread.
The money
The Dollar General Bowl was put on by Mobile Alabama Bowl, Inc., a nonprofit. Its IRS Form 990 for the year to April 2018, which takes in this game, reports $3.2 million in revenue and $3.2 million in expenses.
From the organization’s IRS Form 990, via ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer and the IRS’s e-file data. Payments are the grants it lists on Schedule I of that return. See every filing at ProPublica (EIN 63-1222642).
Every drive
Solid bars scored; an outline in the other team’s color marks points the defense scored. Toledo drives left to right, App State right to left.
Q1 App StateFumble, recovered, 5 plays, −19 yards
Q1 ToledoPunt, 8 plays, 28 yards
Q1 App StatePunt, 4 plays, 4 yards
Q1 ToledoInterception, 1 play, 0 yards
Q1 App StateTouchdown, 5 plays, 36 yards
Q1 ToledoPunt, 3 plays, −48 yards
Q1 App StateTouchdown, 8 plays, 64 yards
Q2 ToledoPunt, 3 plays, 4 yards
Q2 App StateField goal, 7 plays, 4 yards
Q2 App StateField goal, 4 plays, 59 yards
Q2 ToledoPunt, 10 plays, 36 yards
Q2 App StateTurnover on downs, 7 plays, 62 yards
Q3 ToledoInterception, 6 plays, 38 yards
Q3 App StateTouchdown, 7 plays, 61 yards
Q3 ToledoPunt, 3 plays, 1 yard
Q3 App StatePunt, 3 plays, 7 yards
Q3 ToledoPunt, 3 plays, −7 yards
Q3 App StateTouchdown, 7 plays, 55 yards
Q4 ToledoPunt, 7 plays, −29 yards
Q4 App StateTurnover on downs, 8 plays, 52 yards
Q4 ToledoInterception, 3 plays, 3 yards
Q4 App StateTurnover on downs, 5 plays, 20 yards
Q4 ToledoFumble, 3 plays, −1 yard
Q4 App StateEnd of game, 3 plays, −1 yard
Play by play
1st quarter7 drives, then App State 7, Toledo 0
App State Fumble, recovered, 5 plays
15:00
1st & 10 at own 35
Jameson Vest kickoff for 61 yds , Thomas Hennigan return for 23 yds to the AppSt 27
14:54
1st & 10 at own 27
Jalin Moore run for a loss of 1 yard to the AppSt 26
14:16
2nd & 11 at own 26
Taylor Lamb run for 12 yds to the AppSt 38 for a 1ST down
13:51
1st & 10 at own 38
Jalin Moore run for 2 yds to the AppSt 40
13:08
2nd & 8 at own 40
Jalin Moore run for 7 yds to the AppSt 47
12:28
3rd & 1 at own 47
Jalin Moore run for a loss of 1 yard to the AppSt 46
11:42
4th & 2 at own 46
Xavier Subotsch punt for 37 yds , Danzel McKinley-Lewis returns for no gain to the Toled 17 Danzel McKinley-Lewis fumbled, recovered by Toled Danzel McKinley-Lewis
Toledo Punt, 8 plays
11:42
1st & 10 at own 17
Terry Swanson run for 2 yds to the Toled 19
11:10
2nd & 8 at own 19
Logan Woodside pass complete to Jon’Vea Johnson for 14 yds to the Toled 33 for a 1ST down
10:38
1st & 10 at own 33
Logan Woodside pass complete to Diontae Johnson for 4 yds to the Toled 37
9:49
2nd & 6 at own 37
Terry Swanson run for 1 yd to the Toled 38
9:09
3rd & 5 at own 38
Logan Woodside pass complete to Jordan Fisher for 9 yds to the Toled 47 for a 1ST down
8:54
1st & 10 at own 47
TOLEDO Penalty, False Start (Diontae Johnson) to the Toled 42
8:39
1st & 15 at own 42
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Drew Rosi
8:24
2nd & 15 at own 42
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Terry Swanson
8:24
3rd & 15 at own 42
TOLEDO Penalty, False Start (Sami Kassem) to the Toled 37
8:16
3rd & 20 at own 37
Terry Swanson run for 8 yds to the Toled 45
7:57
4th & 12 at own 45
Bailey Flint punt for 55 yds for a touchback
App State Punt, 4 plays
7:57
1st & 10 at own 20
Ike Lewis run for 10 yds to the AppSt 30 for a 1ST down
7:19
1st & 10 at own 30
Jalin Moore run for 3 yds to the AppSt 33
6:51
2nd & 7 at own 33
APPALACHIAN ST Penalty, False Start (Beau Nunn) to the AppSt 28
6:18
2nd & 12 at own 28
Jalin Moore run for 1 yd to the AppSt 29
5:48
3rd & 11 at own 29
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete to Ike Lewis
5:41
4th & 11 at own 29
APPALACHIAN ST Penalty, False Start (Austin Exford) to the AppSt 24
5:33
4th & 16 at own 24
Xavier Subotsch punt for 43 yds , Danzel McKinley-Lewis returns for 5 yds to the Toled 38
Toledo Interception, 1 play
5:19
1st & 10 at own 38
Logan Woodside pass intercepted Anthony Flory return for 19 yds to the Toled 36
App State Touchdown, 5 plays
5:19
1st & 10 at opp 36
Jalin Moore run for 4 yds to the Toled 32
4:42
2nd & 6 at opp 32
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete to Ike Lewis
4:37
3rd & 6 at opp 32
Jalin Moore run for 15 yds to the Toled 17 for a 1ST down
4:14
1st & 10 at opp 17
Jalin Moore run for 10 yds to the Toled 7 for a 1ST down
4:06
1st & goal at opp 7
Jalin Moore run for 7 yds for a TD, (Chandler Staton KICK)App State 7, Toledo 0
Toledo Punt, 3 plays
4:06
1st & 10 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 65 yds , Diontae Johnson return for 15 yds to the Toled 15
4:06
1st & 10 at own 15
Shakif Seymour run for 1 yd to the Toled 16
3:21
2nd & 9 at own 16
Shakif Seymour run for a loss of 3 yards to the Toled 13
2:48
3rd & 12 at own 13
Logan Woodside pass complete to Shakif Seymour for 4 yds to the Toled 17
2:14
4th & 8 at own 17
Bailey Flint punt for 47 yds, fair catch by Clifton Duck at the AppSt 36
App State Touchdown, 8 plays
2:14
1st & 10 at own 36
Jalin Moore run for 9 yds to the AppSt 45
1:30
2nd & 1 at own 45
Lamb, Taylor rush for 7 yards to the TOLEDO48, PENALTY APPALCHAN holding (Duffield, Levi) 10 yards to the APPALCHAN35, NO PLAY.
1:09
2nd & 11 at own 35
Daetrich Harrington run for 16 yds to the Toled 49 for a 1ST down
0:41
1st & 10 at opp 49
Jalin Moore run for 5 yds to the Toled 44
0:05
2nd & 5 at opp 44
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete to Jalen Virgil
0:00
3rd & 5 at opp 44
Taylor Lamb run for 8 yds to the Toled 36 for a 1ST down
Q2 15:00
1st & 10 at opp 36
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Ike Lewis for 23 yds to the Toled 13 for a 1ST down
Q2 14:31
1st & 10 at opp 13
Jalin Moore run for 6 yds to the Toled 7
Q2 13:51
2nd & 4 at opp 7
Jalin Moore run for 7 yds for a TD, (Chandler Staton KICK)App State 14, Toledo 0
2nd quarter5 drives, then App State 20, Toledo 0
Toledo Punt, 3 plays
13:51
2nd & 4 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
13:51
1st & 10 at own 25
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Jordan Fisher
13:39
2nd & 10 at own 25
Terry Swanson run for no gain to the Toled 25
12:58
3rd & 10 at own 25
Logan Woodside pass complete to Terry Swanson for 4 yds to the Toled 29
12:05
4th & 6 at own 29
Bailey Flint punt for 40 yds, downed at the AppSt 31
App State Field goal, 7 plays
12:05
1st & 10 at own 31
Taylor Lamb run for 8 yds to the AppSt 39
11:24
2nd & 2 at own 39
Daetrich Harrington run for 6 yds to the AppSt 45 for a 1ST down
10:59
1st & 10 at own 45
Daetrich Harrington run for 35 yds to the Toled 20 for a 1ST down
10:26
1st & 10 at opp 20
Daetrich Harrington run for 4 yds to the Toled 16
9:47
2nd & 6 at opp 16
Taylor Lamb run for 4 yds to the Toled 12
8:58
3rd & 2 at opp 12
Jalin Moore run for no gain to the Toled 12
8:09
4th & 2 at opp 12
Chandler Staton 29 yd FG GOODApp State 17, Toledo 0
App State Field goal, 4 plays
8:09
4th & 2 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 60 yds , Diontae Johnson return for 9 yds to the Toled 14 Diontae Johnson fumbled, forced by Austin Exford, recovered by AppSt Austin Exford
7:54
1st & 10 at opp 14
Daetrich Harrington run for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 15
7:19
2nd & 11 at opp 15
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Collin Reed for 7 yds to the Toled 8
6:42
3rd & 4 at opp 8
Timeout TOLEDO, clock 06:42
6:42
3rd & 4 at opp 8
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Ike Lewis for 2 yds to the Toled 6
5:56
4th & 2 at opp 6
Timeout APPALACHIAN ST, clock 05:56
5:52
4th & 2 at opp 6
Chandler Staton 23 yd FG GOODApp State 20, Toledo 0
Toledo Punt, 10 plays
5:52
4th & 2 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
5:52
1st & 10 at own 25
Logan Woodside pass complete to Desmond Phillips for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 24
5:14
2nd & 11 at own 24
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Terry Swanson
5:07
3rd & 11 at own 24
TOLEDO Penalty, False Start (Diontae Johnson) to the Toled 19
5:01
3rd & 16 at own 19
Logan Woodside pass complete to Jordan Fisher for 20 yds to the Toled 39 for a 1ST down
4:49
1st & 10 at own 39
Terry Swanson run for 1 yd to the Toled 40
4:24
2nd & 9 at own 40
Logan Woodside pass complete to Terry Swanson for 4 yds to the Toled 44
3:46
3rd & 5 at own 44
Logan Woodside run for 3 yds to the Toled 47
3:08
4th & 2 at own 47
Timeout TOLEDO, clock 03:08
3:08
4th & 2 at own 47
Logan Woodside pass complete to Terry Swanson for 18 yds to the AppSt 35 for a 1ST down
2:49
1st & 10 at opp 35
Logan Woodside pass incomplete
2:38
2nd & 10 at opp 35
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Darryl Richards
2:36
3rd & 10 at opp 35
Timeout TOLEDO, clock 02:36
2:36
3rd & 10 at opp 35
Logan Woodside sacked by Caleb Fuller for a loss of 4 yards to the AppSt 39
1:38
4th & 14 at opp 39
Bailey Flint punt for 21 yds, fair catch by Thomas Hennigan at the AppSt 18
App State Turnover on downs, 7 plays
1:38
1st & 10 at own 18
Daetrich Harrington run for 1 yd to the AppSt 19
1:02
2nd & 9 at own 19
Daetrich Harrington run for 19 yds to the AppSt 38 for a 1ST down
0:42
1st & 10 at own 38
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete to Ike Lewis
0:36
2nd & 10 at own 38
Taylor Lamb run for 10 yds to the AppSt 48 for a 1ST down
0:22
1st & 10 at own 48
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Thomas Hennigan for 29 yds to the Toled 23 for a 1ST down
0:13
1st & 10 at opp 23
Timeout APPALACHIAN ST, clock 00:13
0:13
1st & 10 at opp 23
Lamb, Taylor pass incomplete to Hennigan, Thomas, PENALTY TOLEDO pass interference (Mathis, Trevon) 15 yards to the TOLEDO8, NO PLAY, 1ST DOWN APPALCHAN.
0:07
1st & goal at opp 8
Malik Williams pass incomplete to Taylor Lamb
0:00
2nd & 0 at opp 8
Chandler Staton 25 yd FG MISSED
3rd quarter6 drives, then App State 27, Toledo 0
Toledo Interception, 6 plays
15:00
1st & 10 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
15:00
1st & 10 at own 25
Terry Swanson run for 2 yds to the Toled 27
14:26
2nd & 8 at own 27
Terry Swanson run for 24 yds to the AppSt 49 for a 1ST down
13:59
1st & 10 at opp 49
Terry Swanson run for 3 yds to the AppSt 46
13:31
2nd & 7 at opp 46
Logan Woodside pass complete to Danzel McKinley-Lewis for 8 yds to the AppSt 38 for a 1ST down
12:58
1st & 10 at opp 38
Terry Swanson run for 1 yd to the AppSt 37
12:13
2nd & 9 at opp 37
Logan Woodside pass intercepted Desmond Franklin return for 35 yds to the AppSt 39
App State Touchdown, 7 plays
12:13
1st & 10 at own 39
Jalin Moore run for 9 yds to the AppSt 48
11:36
2nd & 1 at own 48
Jalin Moore run for no gain to the AppSt 48
10:52
3rd & 1 at own 48
Jalin Moore run for no gain to the AppSt 48
10:12
4th & 1 at own 48
Taylor Lamb run for 2 yds to the 50 yard line for a 1ST down
9:29
1st & 10 at the 50
Jalin Moore run for 3 yds to the Toled 47
8:56
2nd & 7 at opp 47
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Ike Lewis for 16 yds to the Toled 31 for a 1ST down
8:14
1st & 10 at opp 31
Jalin Moore run for 31 yds for a TD, (Chandler Staton KICK)App State 27, Toledo 0
Toledo Punt, 3 plays
8:14
1st & 10 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 65 yds for a touchback
8:14
1st & 10 at own 25
Shakif Seymour run for no gain to the Toled 25
7:34
2nd & 10 at own 25
Logan Woodside pass complete to Desmond Phillips for no gain to the Toled 25 TOLEDO Penalty, Offensive Holding (Sami Kassem) declined
7:11
3rd & 10 at own 25
Logan Woodside pass complete to Shakif Seymour for 1 yd to the Toled 26
6:22
4th & 9 at own 26
Bailey Flint punt for 44 yds, punt out-of-bounds at the AppSt 30
App State Punt, 3 plays
6:22
1st & 10 at own 30
Daetrich Harrington run for a loss of 5 yards to the AppSt 25
5:59
2nd & 15 at own 25
Daetrich Harrington run for a loss of 3 yards to the AppSt 22
5:12
3rd & 18 at own 22
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Daetrich Harrington for 15 yds to the AppSt 37
4:29
4th & 3 at own 37
Xavier Subotsch punt for 43 yds, fair catch by Danzel McKinley-Lewis at the Toled 20
Toledo Punt, 3 plays
4:29
1st & 10 at own 20
Terry Swanson run for 3 yds to the Toled 23
3:53
2nd & 7 at own 23
Terry Swanson run for a loss of 1 yard to the Toled 22
3:22
3rd & 8 at own 22
Logan Woodside sacked by Eric Boggs and Caleb Fuller for a loss of 9 yards to the Toled 13
2:24
4th & 17 at own 13
Bailey Flint punt for 42 yds, downed at the AppSt 45
App State Touchdown, 7 plays
2:24
1st & 10 at own 45
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Jalen Virgil for 13 yds to the Toled 42 for a 1ST down
1:54
1st & 10 at opp 42
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete to Thomas Hennigan
1:41
2nd & 10 at opp 42
Jalin Moore run for 7 yds to the Toled 35
1:14
3rd & 3 at opp 35
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete
0:52
4th & 3 at opp 35
Lamb, Taylor pass complete to Lewis, Ike for 2 yards to the TOLEDO33, PENALTY TOLEDO substitution infraction 5 yards to the TOLEDO30, NO PLAY, 1ST DOWN APPALCHAN.
0:36
1st & 10 at opp 30
Taylor Lamb pass complete to Ike Lewis for 26 yds to the Toled 4 for a 1ST down
0:00
1st & goal at opp 4
Jalin Moore run for 1 yd to the Toled 3
Q4 14:54
2nd & goal at opp 3
Malik Williams run for 3 yds for a TD, (Chandler Staton KICK)App State 34, Toledo 0
4th quarter6 drives, then App State 34, Toledo 0
Toledo Punt, 7 plays
14:54
2nd & 9 at own 35
Michael Rubino kickoff for 56 yds , Desmond Phillips return for no gain to the Toled 9
14:46
1st & 10 at own 9
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Art Thompkins
14:42
2nd & 10 at own 9
Logan Woodside pass complete to Diontae Johnson for 17 yds to the Toled 26 for a 1ST down
14:13
1st & 10 at own 26
Logan Woodside pass complete to Art Thompkins for 8 yds to the Toled 34
13:51
2nd & 2 at own 34
Art Thompkins run for 8 yds to the Toled 42 for a 1ST down
13:09
1st & 10 at own 42
Logan Woodside pass complete to Art Thompkins for 5 yds to the Toled 47
12:34
2nd & 5 at own 47
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Bryce Mitchell
12:15
3rd & 5 at own 47
Logan Woodside sacked by Okon Godwin for a loss of 11 yards to the Toled 36
11:44
4th & 16 at own 36
Bailey Flint punt for 47 yds, fair catch by Clifton Duck at the AppSt 17
App State Turnover on downs, 8 plays
11:44
1st & 10 at own 17
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 5 yds to the AppSt 22
11:18
2nd & 5 at own 22
Taylor Lamb run for 4 yds to the AppSt 26
10:55
3rd & 1 at own 26
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 24 yds to the 50 yard line for a 1ST down
10:12
1st & 10 at the 50
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 12 yds to the Toled 38 for a 1ST down
9:26
1st & 10 at opp 38
Marcus Williams Jr. run for no gain to the Toled 38
8:37
2nd & 10 at opp 38
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 3 yds to the Toled 35
7:54
3rd & 7 at opp 35
Timeout APPALACHIAN ST, clock 07:54
7:54
3rd & 7 at opp 35
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 4 yds to the Toled 31
7:07
4th & 3 at opp 31
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete
Toledo Interception, 3 plays
7:07
1st & 10 at own 31
Art Thompkins run for 3 yds to the Toled 34
6:29
2nd & 7 at own 34
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Darryl Richards
6:18
3rd & 7 at own 34
Logan Woodside pass intercepted Clifton Duck return for no gain to the Toled 37
App State Turnover on downs, 5 plays
6:18
1st & 10 at opp 37
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 16 yds to the Toled 21 for a 1ST down
5:36
1st & 10 at opp 21
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 2 yds to the Toled 19
4:54
2nd & 8 at opp 19
Marcus Williams Jr. run for 2 yds to the Toled 17
4:18
3rd & 6 at opp 17
Taylor Lamb pass incomplete to T.J. Watkins
4:04
4th & 6 at opp 17
Taylor Lamb run for a loss of 3 yards to the Toled 20
Toledo Fumble, 3 plays
4:04
1st & 10 at own 20
Logan Woodside sacked by Devan Stringer for a loss of 10 yards to the Toled 10
3:31
2nd & 20 at own 10
Logan Woodside pass incomplete to Desmond Phillips
3:12
3rd & 20 at own 10
Logan Woodside pass complete to Shakif Seymour for 9 yds to the Toled 19
2:28
4th & 11 at own 19
Bailey Flint punt for 44 yds , Clifton Duck returns for a loss of 1 yard to the AppSt 36 Clifton Duck fumbled, forced by Justin Clark, recovered by AppSt Tim Frizzell
App State End of game, 3 plays
2:28
1st & 10 at own 36
DeMarcus Harper run for no gain to the AppSt 36
1:33
2nd & 10 at own 36
DeMarcus Harper run for 7 yds to the AppSt 43
0:51
3rd & 3 at own 43
DeMarcus Harper run for a loss of 3 yards to the AppSt 40
0:00
4th & 6 at own 40
APPALACHIAN ST Penalty, Delay of Game (Zac Thomas) to the AppSt 35
Play-by-play from CollegeFootballData.com, as its scorers wrote it. The clock is the time left in the quarter; the spot is from the side of the team with the ball.