Rice vs. Navy

Wednesday, January 1, 1958, Cotton Bowl

No. 8 Navy beat No. 9 Rice 20–⁠7. It was their second meeting; after it, the series stood even at 1–⁠1.

Neutral site9Rice7–⁠4 in 1957
7
Neutral site8Navy9–⁠1–⁠1 in 1957
20

FinalTV: CBSAttendance 75,504Payout $160,000 per team (Wikipedia)Referee: Albie Booth (ECAC; split crew: ECAC, SWC)

MVPs Tom Forrestal (Navy QB); Tony Stremic (Navy G)Wikipedia

In the newspapers

  • The Evening star's story

    Evening star, Washington, D.C., January 3, 1958, page 41

    Read the text

    Before the body CRice) Is cold, the Naval Academy COACH ing staff Is looking ahead to next season, with three guys named Joe the co-subjects Of some highly exciting CONVEX sation. Even as some still we’re toasting Nays 20–⁠7 victory over Rice in the Cotton Bowl Wednesday in Dallas. others we’re talking Of the greatest l-2 running punch in Academy history. That history Is yet to be made. but wearing “can’t-miss” tags are Joe Bellino and Joe Matalavage. Comdr. Jack Nc quarry. head coach Of the plebes this past season. can’t contain himself on these two. The other Is Joe Tranchini, the sophomore quarterback who led Navy to It’s first touchdown against Rice. Tranchini was the third-string varsity quarterback all season, but was moved to the No. 2 unit against Rice in order 10 get the extra experience. There is no question about IT,” McQuary said. “I’ll stake my judgment that this Beilino Is the finest halfback prospect I’ve ever seen and before next season is over somebody is going TO have to move over and make room for Matalavage at full back” He’ll Have Opposition Admittedly. that will take a heap Of moving. insomuch as Ray Wellborn and Dick Dagampat. both proven veterans at the position, will return.

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

On the newsreel

  • MIDDIES TORPEDO RICE 20-7 IN COTTON BOWLIn Dallas, Navy's future admirals make their first Cotton Bowl appearance, and paced by Tom Forrestal, with an assist by 5 Rice fumbles, they thunder their way to a 20-7 victory with a rock-solid defense and a…Universal Newsreel, January 2, 1958. Catalog record at the National Archives

Universal Newsreel, National Archives (catalog record). Story titles and words as Universal’s release sheet gives them; the films themselves may still be under copyright, so we link to the record rather than show them.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Navy 65% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Tied 7–⁠7 in 14 meetings, counting the 12 since this game.

Recent meetings
2025Navy 21, Rice 13
2024Rice 24, Navy 10
2009Navy 63, Rice 14
2005Navy 41, Rice 9
2004Navy 14, Rice 13
2003Navy 38, Rice 6

Around this game