Yale at Princeton

Saturday, November 12, 1898

Princeton beat Yale 6–⁠0. It was their 24th meeting; after it, Yale led the series 11–⁠7–⁠6.

AwayYale9–⁠2 in 1898
0
HomePrinceton11–⁠0–⁠1 in 1898
6

FinalHigh 46°F, low 30°FAttendance 16,500

In the newspapers

  • The Omaha daily bee's story: ORANGE AND BLACK WIN OUT Princeton Tigers Defeat Cons Of Old Ely Six to Nothing. TOUCHDOWN ON A MISERABLE TUMBLE Right End roc Sets the Immense Crowd Frantic by His Great Dash Of N~incty-Fivc Yards to the Good.

    Omaha daily bee, Nebraska, November 13, 1898, page 1

    Read the text

    ORANGE AND BLACK WIN OUT Princeton Tigers Defeat Cons Of Old Ely Six to Nothing. TOUCHDOWN ON A MISERABLE TUMBLE Right End roc Sets the Immense Crowd Frantic by His Great Dash Of N~incty-Fivc Yards to the Good. PRINCETON. N. j.. Nov. 12.-The Prince ton Tigers defeated the Sons OF Old Ell on P-orr’v feld his afternoon by the score Of 6 to 0. While 1t was one OF the most bittoi,y contested games ever witnessed on a foot ball field, 1t was at the same line one of the most unsatisfactory. not alone to che Yale team and their supporters. but also to the wearers Of the orange and black and those who cheered them on to victory. The solitary touchdown was made on a miserable tumble by Right Halfback Benjamin when the ball was within fifteen yards Of Princeton’s goal. The ball had been car ried down the field by the Yale team by steady plunges into the Princeton line, varied by an occasional end run, until 1t lay between Princeton’s twenty and twenty-five yard line. The teams lined UP and Desaulles signaled for Benjamin to go through left tackle, a position in Princeton’s line which was awfully weak. The ball was passed and Benjamin dived into the mass OF human flesh. a second later the ball was seen to roll clear Of the bunch Of players and advance a rev feet toward Princeton’s goal line. Quick as q flash little Poe, the Tigers right end, had gathered UP the pigskin and was sprint ing down the field with Chamberlin, Still man anu IteuJduulu III “ Their he ran the greater was his lead, until, in less time than 1t takes to write it, he had planted the ball s~quarely between the posts of the much-coveted goal OF Yale. Crnuks Scream for Poe and Princeton. When Poe started or his ninety-fve-yard run up the field the scene which followed beggars description. The entire stands which surround the field were one surging, yelling --- z-- t. ~ tratayf nlh “nn and women threw dignity aside for the time being and Joined with | the younger, but none the less enthusiastic, | foot ball cranks in their cheers for Poe | and Princeton. 1t was several minutes be- | fore the game could proceed because OF the | jubilant Tiger supporters crowding onto the field. Later in the anne when the excite | ment ran high spectators who had seats IN | tie srandstand left their places and surged on the side lines, the management making | no effort to clear the field so as to enable | the working newspaper men to witness Sue ceeding plays. . Today’s game was almost a repetition OF | the game at Cambridge on last Saturday between the University of Pennsylvania and Harvard. In the latter game the wearers Of the red and blue gained almost three \ times as much distance on line bucking as did their opponents, while Harvard scored on a tumble. The same can he said Of 20 days contest. Yale would carry the ball down the field toward the Tigers goal, only to lose it on an exasperating tumble. The game was not what could be called brilliant. scientific foot ball. AT times both teams played a mastery game, 3rt at other times many Of the players seemed to have forgotten the first rudiments OF the game and some Of their plays would have Put to shame the foot ball team OF a preparatory school. Yale’s Fierce Play. Before Benjamin’s disastrous tumble, Yale’s play had been fierce. After the touch down the men grew more desperate. IN every man there was that bulldog deter mination and grit that have won many a hard fought game for the wearers OF the dark blue. Time and again they would rush ths ball down the ield toward the Tigers goal, only to lose it on a tumble. On one occasion they carried the ball, by plunges into the line, seventy-fve yards, finally losing it on a tumble within twenty yards Of the Princeton goal. Princeton was content to play on the def~ensive until within about fifteen Minutes before the game was called and 1t looked as though they had been instructed in this point by their coaches. Their entire effor at line-bucking during the frs: half and for twenty minutes of the second half net ted them all told about fifty yards, while their opponents had carried the ball foul times this distance. There was not, however, that variety Of attack and good runs behind beautiful in reference which are appreciated so much by the unadulerated foot ball crank. Yale’i play in the main was directed against Princeton’s left tackle. the one weak spo in the Tigers line. The reports that had been sent out from New Haven to the effect that the Yale team was in G badly crippled condition had blu little effect on the betting on today’s game Before the game there were several bet’ made at even money, but a majority OF thu money was placed at 4 to S in favor Of Yale Stars of h Teams. For the Princeton team the bright particu lar stars were Palmer. Poe, Edwards, Ayre’ and Hillcbrand, while Durston, Townsend Brown, Ely and Coy did the best work TO Yale. When the teams lined up the attendant, was about $4,000 with the adherents o Princeton naturally in the majority. Tn Princeton shouters were banked in q soil, mass In the east stand opposite the Yal contingent and they kept up an untirinI shout for three hours, varied only occasion ally by O college song. Visitors from Ne, York, Philadelphia, New Haven and els where were homeward bound soon afte nightfall. I. The teams lined up as follows: Princeton. Position. Yal = Palmer. ........... left end ......”..-.:Ed Crowdish-M Mills left guard Brow . Booth. center .............Cutte

  • The The Worcester spy's story: TheyCost ale the Game WITH PRINCETON. A Contest in Which Last Years Score Was Reversed.

    The Worcester spy, Worcester, Mass., November 13, 1898, page 1

    Read the text

    TheyCost ale the Game WITH PRINCETON. A Contest in Which Last Years Score Was Reversed. Princeton, N. J., Nov. 12,-The Prince ton Tigers defeated the sons Of Old Eli on Brokaw field, this afternoon, by the score of 6 to 0. While it was one of the most bitterly contested games ever witnessed on a foot BAN field, it was at the same time one OF the most unsatisfactory, not alone 20 the Yale team and their supports. but also to the wearers of the orange and black, and those who cheered them on to We tory The solitary touchdown was made on a miserable tumble by right halfback Benjamin, when the ball was within 10 yards of Princeton’s goal. The ball had been carried down the Held by the Yale team by steady plunges INTO the Princeton line. varied by an occasional end run, until it lay between Prince TONS 20 and 25-yard line The teams lined up, DeSaulles signal ing for Benjamin to go through left tackle, a position in Princeyon’s line, which was awfully weak. The ball passed and Benjamin dived into the mass of human flesh. A second later the ball was seen to roll clear of the bunch of players and advance a few feet towards Princeton’s goal line. Quick as a flash little Poe, the right end had gathered up the pigskin and was sprinting down the field with Chamberlin, Stillman and BENJAMIN in hot pursuit. The further he ran the greater was his lead. until in less than 1t takes to write it, he had planted the ball squarely between the posts of the much coveted goal of Yale. When Poe started on his 95-yard run up the field, the scene which followed beggars description. All the stands that surround the field were one surging, yelling mass of hui | manity in an instant. Old men and women threw dignity aside for the time being and shouted with younger, but none the less enthusiastic, foot ball cranks in their cheers for Poe and | Princeton. 1t was several minutes before the game could proceed because of the jubilant Tigers crowding on to | the field Later in the game, when the | excitement again ran high, spectators who had seats in the grandstand, left ! their places and surged on the side lines, the management making no Eff | fort to clear the field so as to enable | the working newspaper men To witness succeeding plays. Today’s game was almost a repetition | of the game at Cambridge on last Sat urday between the University Of Penn sylvania and Harvard. In the latter game the wearers of the red and blue gained almost three times as much distinction on | line bucking as did their opponents, while Harvard scored on a tumble The same can be said of today’s contest. Yale would carry the ball down the field toward the Tigers goal only to lose it on an exasperating tumble. The game was not what could be | called brilliant, scientific foot ball At times both teams played a masterly game, but at other times many of the players seemed to have forgotten the first rudiments of the game and some of their plays would have disgraced the foot ball team of a preparatory school Before Benjamin’s disastrous tumble the play had been fierce. After the touchdown the men grew more desperate. In every man there was that bulldog determination and grit that has won many a hard fought game for the wearers of the dark blue. Time and again they would rush the ball down the field toward the Tigers goal. only to lose it on a tumble. On one occasion they carried the ball by plunges into the line 70 yards. finally losing it on a tumble within 20 yards of the Princeton goal. Princeton was content to play on the defensive until within about Is minutes before the game was called, and it looked as though she had been in strueted on this point by their coaches. Their entire effort at line bucking dur ing the first half and four 20 minutes of the second half netted them all told about so yards, while their opponents had carried the ball four times this dis tance. There was not however, that variety Of attack and good runs behind beau tiful interference which is appreciated so much by the unadulterated foot ball crank Yales play in the main was directed against Princeton’s left tackle, the one weak spot in the Tigers line. The reports that had been sent out from New Haven to the effect that the Yale team was in a badly crippled condition had but little effect on the bet ting in today’s game. The orange and black had been UP against Yale’s ‘‘cripples, and their spending money had gone toward pay ing for the tuition of some Yale stu dent. Before the game there were sew eral bets made at even money, but the greater part of the money was placed at to in favor of Yale. For the Princeton team the bright particular stars were Palmer, Poe. Ed wards. Ayres and Hillebrand While Durston, Townshend. Brown, Ely and Gov did the best work for Yale. When the teams lined up the attend ance was about $4,000. with the adherents of Princeton naturally in the ma jority. There was no lack of Yale men and women, however, and they lifted up their voices in encouragement OF their favorites whenever opportunity offered. The Princeton shouters wers banked in a solid mass in the east stand, opposite the Yale contingent. and they KEEP up an untiring shout for three hours. varied only occasionally by a college song.

  • The Daily Kennebec journal's story: uatlp Kennebec 3ournaL. FOOT BALL GAMES. Princeton Tigers Defeat the Yale Eleven, 6 to O. Bowdoin Has an Easy Time With Colby, Winning, II to 0. Harvard Makes Poor Showing With Brown. Barely Winning, II to 6.

    Daily Kennebec journal, Maine, November 14, 1898, page 3

    Read the text

    uatlp Kennebec 3ournaL. FOOT BALL GAMES. Princeton Tigers Defeat the Yale Eleven, 6 to O. Bowdoin Has an Easy Time With Colby, Winning, II to 0. Harvard Makes Poor Showing With Brown. Barely Winning, II to 6. Princeton, n. j., Nov. 13.-It was quite a revelation in the Princeton Yale game here, yesterday. considering the closeness of Princeton’s victory. to see such brilliant lights at Yale as De- Saulles, Benjamin and Mcbride repeatedly fumbling the ball on kicks and experiencing a spell of “rattles’‘ similar to that displayed by Pennsylvania s backs in the Harvard game of a week ago. Notwithstanding these drawbacks, Yale repeatedly secured firm grip on the Tigers tail, and several times the sons of Elihu We’re on the verge of tying the knot, but at every critical moment the festive tiger would free him. self by making an extra kick, and at the same time fastening his claws so securely in the blue jerseys that it took Yale long time to get a good chance to try the tail-twisting act once more. 1t was chiefly a battle of forwards. as there were very few long runs, ana the Princeton giants and the sturdy Yale Nnesmen fought it out valiantly in dzor-die finish. rRNtEroN. YALE Geer, H. -................ r.t., mberlin Crowds fMills), l.g. ........ rg., Marshall BOoth, C. .,.’‘..............-.-.- c., Cutten Edwards, rg. .......-..........; lg., Brown Hillebrand TT. .............. It,. StlIman Poe. re. .............. l.e., Eddy Duncan Hutchinson), q.b. .............. -..................... q. b., DeSaulleS (Ely) Kafer CWheeler), LIB. ................. ....:....a.. RIB, Durston (Townsend) Beardsley (Black), RIB. . Ayres, fb ................... f.b MMdLe McBride Score-Princeton. 6; Yale, 0. ~rouchdown-Poe. Goal from touchdown .Ayres. Umpire, Prof. Paul Dashiel oil Lehigh. Referee, Edgar N. Wrightington Princeton, and Mr.. Francis of Yale Time. S5-mnute halves.

  • The The sun's story: Princeton Downs Yale.

    The sun, November 13, 1898, page 6

    Read the text

    Princeton Downs Yale. Special to TIE BUN. PRINCETON, N. j., Nov. l2.-In a game full of fumbles the eleven from Old Eli was downed by the Tigers by the score of 6 to 0. Poe scored the touchdown, getting the ball on tumble OH Princeton’s ten yards and running the whole length Of the field. Princeton twice during the game had the ball on Yale’s fve-yard line, but could not get it over on account Of fun. bling.

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Princeton 63% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Yale leads 71–⁠45–⁠10 in 126 meetings, counting the 102 since this game.

Recent meetings
2025Yale 13, Princeton 10
2024Yale 42, Princeton 28
2023Yale 36, Princeton 28
2022Yale 24, Princeton 20
2021Princeton 35, Yale 20
2019Yale 51, Princeton 14

Around this game

Yale

Princeton