Carlisle at Pennsylvania

Saturday, November 6, 1897

Pennsylvania beat Carlisle 20–⁠10. It was their third meeting; after it, Pennsylvania led the series 3–⁠0.

AwayCarlisle6–⁠4 in 1897
10
HomePennsylvania15–⁠0 in 1897
20

Final

In the newspapers

  • The The sun's story: ON TIE FOOTBALL FIELD. CARLISLE INDIANS sURPRTsE PENN 81, sILPINIA'S TEAM.

    The sun, New York [N.Y.], November 7, 1897, page 1

    Read the text

    ON TIE FOOTBALL FIELD. CARLISLE INDIANS sURPRTsE PENN 81, sILPINIA’S TEAM. IIudsOn, tue hnutnn QuNrtsr hncbs blcks Two ssosis from the Pirid-Yriurhtsn scores So Points AERinst Laray-itc-Yaic Rnaii, Dis poses OF ChicnRo = Many O.hrr Gnmrs. Tho crack team of tho University OF Ponnsyl. yania struck n snng yesterday when the Carlisle Indians lined up on Franklin Field, philndclphia. Instead Of rolling up n big scoro and whitewashing the rcd men, rs many experts believed they would. tho Qunkcrs had a diff. cult task to score 30 points, and tho Indians covered themselves with ncver-tobe.forRottcn glory by scoring 10 points. Tho remarkable feat Of kicking two goals from tho teli was accomplished by Hudson. the Indians quarter bnok. who has developed into n phenomenal player. The showing Of tho Indians was tho best they have made this year, and their game with Brown University hero next Saturday may result in their first victory over n leading college eleven. Pcnnsylvnnia’s achievement will not increase tho belief that her eleven Is the greatest In tho country this year, especially whom tho fact is considered that Princeton played wonderful football an =, ran IN n total OF 81 points against Lafayette. tho Latter ho!ng blankcd, too. Prince toms score will no used, no doubt. ms an argument that Tho Tigers are supreme, especially as tho Lafayette team was in good trim yestcr. day when they entered the conflict. Yalc’s play against tho big Chicago A. c. eleven was so effective that tho West. ern men were beaten by IL to 8. This victory strengthens the belief that Yale’s olevon Is rounding into such shape that the game with Harvard next Saturday will DO most sensational. The large number of minor games played yesterday all over the country shows that the interest in the game is at white heat. PENNSYLVANIA, 20; CARLISLE INDIANS, 10. PHILADEIrHIA Nov. 6.-Thc Carlisle Indians treated Pennsylvania and 10000 spectators to the biggest football surprise of tho season today. Tho Quakers had looked forward to a hard gnn,e against the crack eleven Of tho United States training school. but did not enpect such n game rs it proved to tic. There was some question in the minds OF Pennsylvania followers whether or not the Indians would hold PENIS team down to q total of 20, but they were prepared for this. There were a few who believed that the Carlisle boys would sue coed In sending the ball between Pennsylvania goal posts, but it is sntc 10 say that nobody in the vast crowd anticipated that the Indians would score twice. Much less did they expect Mt Mt n”y period Of the game the visitors would lead the home team. while tho iiea OF the rod mon ending the first half with the advantage in their favor was not even considered as n possibility. Yet this WINS the cnse. due to a variety OF causes. including both the good play Of the Indians and mistakes on Pcnnsylvania’s part. No discrcdit. either. is attached 10 Pennsylvania team by reason of It.. Against the o Ids OF n small gale which blow straight down he. field against hem the Qunkers did well TO twice force the ball over the Indians gonl line In tho first half. That they did not hold the Indians in check and shut them out Is not surprising. considering the weakened condition OF the team and the strong game played by the visitors. 1t was such a Q ‘ntest as one would expect to see on the occasion OF the final game 4 the season; Both elevens played good football. Both ones. neither would they to likely TO prove So in 2 big game. They were mistakes which favored affected them to that extent. At the start tho P,ennsy lvanians gained ground steadily against the visitors and forced their way slowly but once In carrying it from the centre OF the field over the line. and regained 1t almost immcdidams to advance II. In five minutes from the start Of play they had forced the leather over, The Indians kicked Of. and aided by the wind the ball carried well down toward Pennsyl. vania’s goal. The Quakcrs advanced it steadily, Here two failures to gain forced Minds to Kick. d drS nls the Te”t BAH as ahnst P the Wind. I’m Il w irom n short kick, and gave the ball to the Indians almost in the centre of the field. The red men began a series of plays with their close formation. but abandoned them when 1 pisyy i fS”n Pe 1T impossible I to s sns o T5’ I, tT Pisrt to s sssS In r TOI,S the The end for a gain of fl. the lattcrs injury, and who was playing his nrst game. was responsible for the advance, but the Indians, Again the close formation was tried and failed to gain, when Metoxen was sent yards on a pretty run, carrying the bali within zen yards OF Penn’s goal. being thrown out of There was n serious question whether or not this play could haye heen made had not Seneca seneca the right tackle Of the indians, held runner. The holding escaped the umpire’s eve q and the play was allowed to proceed. There was no question now but what the Indians u would score, for, although q close formation into the centro failed to gain and Mcloxen WINS still able to kick a goal from the Held. He cropped back on the next play and received tho instant’s hesitation and cleanly between the posts it smiled. P~anaemonium rcigned then among the follow. ers OF the Indians. Fully 200 students from the Carlisle School, had accompanied the team to see the game. headed by a brass band OF tho school boys OF scventy.hve pieces. They made themselves hoard in great shape. and were assisted. by liberal applause OF tho entire sssemolage In appreciation of the beautiful When Pennsylvania kicked of, Metoxen re-. Pennsylvnnia’s in tho centre OF the Held. Steady plays into the contre carried 1t fifteen yards for TMard and a qnarter6aGk kick gave it to the In, ana again pennsylvania began her advances. slowly CARRYING the ball forward; Three Times In the course OF its journey to the goal line IL was lost to tho Indians tor one or another cause. puntcd. N PENNSYLVANIA still continued the game and finally forced Minds over for n second Touch. down, but again the goal WAS missed. Then On. sued an exact repetition of tho play succeeding Pennsylvania first touchdown. The Ouakers carried the ball steadily, back % midiield. a thirty-yardr run by Outland playing an important part in the advance, Weeks tumbled in the centre Of the iicld and the Indians gained the ball: This, was heir opportunity. and Mctoxen again circled F%olweil’s end for a twenty.yard Savanee. carrying the ball to the 35.yard line. Twice the Indians failed to gaia: men Haason dropped back for II goal. The play was olmcult ono from an angle OF so, und The wind was blowing at u rate 10 make Judgment i’m Kicking particularly hard. Hudson received the Dali ana dropped IL as quickly Az before, and again. straight as an arrow, it flow between the posts, scoring the second goal from the field and putting tho Indians in the lead by a score of 10 TO =. The remaining time OF the halt quickly expired and so the first engagement ended. In the second h.lt, with Tho wind in favor of fennsylHanla, there WAS n different story 10 tell. The gale had died down somewhat. but IL was stu sufficient 70 give to the ouakers u decidcl advantage. They returned the kick-Oif 10 midhcld, and, after inchcCtuEl attempts 10 gain, HUDSON returned the bal, 10 Pennsylvania 80. yurd me. Minds kicked and Huhunn auni, “,

  • The The Salt Lake herald's story: On Franklin Field the Indians Yield to the QuakerS. YALE AND CHICAGO CLUB A WIND WHICH FAVORED BOTH ALTERNATELY. Game Between Carlisle and Penn sylvania Was Fast and Furious Yale's Improved Play Yesterday Opens Out Interesting Possibili- ties-College Football News.

    The Salt Lake herald, Salt Lake City [Utah], November 7, 1897, page 4

    Read the text

    On Franklin Field the Indians Yield to the QuakerS. YALE AND CHICAGO CLUB A WIND WHICH FAVORED BOTH ALTERNATELY. Game Between Carlisle and Penn sylvania Was Fast and Furious Yale’s Improved Play Yesterday Opens Out Interesting Possibilities-College Football News. Philadelphia, Nov. 6.-The University of PENNSYLVANIA football eleven this afternoon defeated the Carlisle Indians on Franklin field by the score of 20 to 10. The red men kicked two goals from the field in the first half, while the red and blues scored two touchdowns. from which no goal resulted. In the second half, however, the In dians did not get within 80 yards of Pennsylvania goal. except on kicks, and then Pennsylvania would rush the ball down the field. Princeton had scored IS points against the Indians without having her goal crossed, while Yale’s score was a to 8 for the red men. There was a strong wind from the west, and after winning the toss. the Carlisle boys chose the west goal, with the wind at the backs. On every exchange OF pUnts they gained from 10 to is yards, despite the fact that Minds kicked in good form. The Indians clearly earned both of their field goals, as beautiful end runs for % yards by Mcfarland and Wheelock brought the bali TO Pennsylvania 20-yard line. and her little hulesOn showed his ability as kicker by dropping the ball square ly between the posts The Indians used the Princeton re- NolNing wedge play for occasional gains, but they could make little i’m precision OF Pennsylvania’s line and would Invariably resort to kicking. There was some bad fumbling by the Quahers, Weeks and Outland being the chief offenders. The latter. however, more than eoualled matters by his Superb tacl1ling and end skirting. Penn sylVania’s ends got down the field fast under kicks, and once forced Hudson to make safely after Metoxen had funbled the ball Neither team had out their run strength. Pennsylvania was badly handicapped by the absence of Boyle from left end, while the Indians were without the services of their brilliant half back, Jamaison. In the first half the Quakers played a dull listless game, but in the second half they braced up and had it not been for the two disastrous fumbles. two additional touchdowns would have undoubtedly resulted. The red men played good, stiff. foot ball, but We’re remarkably susceptible to Injuries. After nearly every scrinmage there would be an Indian stretch ed out on the gridiron. For the visitors, Pierce. Wheelock and McFarlaae were the stars The two latter were worked SO persistently, how ever, that they We’re forced to retire. For the red and blue, Captain Minds was the star. He never failed to gain when sent against the line or around the end, often wriggling away from two OF three Indians before being stopped. McCracken and Hare also Dloughed through the visitors line for good gains Pennsylvania did not try any OF her tricks. relying wholly on straight football Touchdowns.-Minds, .; Hare Nc Cracker. Goal-Minds. Goals From Field.-Hudson, >. Safety.-HudsOn. Total score: Pennsylvania, 20; In dams, 10. Time 30-minute halves.

  • The The record-union's story: ON EASTERN GRIDIRONS. Pennsylvania Varsity Defeats the Carlisle Indians.

    The record-union, November 7, 1897, page 5

    Read the text

    ON EASTERN GRIDIRONS. Pennsylvania Varsity Defeats the Carlisle Indians. PHILADELPHIA Nov. 6.-The Uni yersity of Pennsylvania football eleven this afternoon defeated the Carlisle In dians on Franklin field by the score of 20 to 10. The red men kicked two goals from the field in the first half, while the red and blues scored two touchdowns. from which no goal result ed In the second half, however, the Indians did not get within thirty five wards of Pennsylvania goal except on kicks. and then Pennsylvania would rush the ball down the field. princeton had scored Is points against the Indians without having her line crossed. while fales score was ~ to 9 ior the red men. PRINCETON IN. j.. Nov. 6.-Lafayette went down TO an overwhelming defeat this afternoon. and the inVinclbie Tigers added another victory TO their already long list by rolling up – points to nothing for the visitors CAMBRIDGE Mass, Nov. 6.-The Pennsylvania freshmen were showed under at Soldiers field to-day, where they were defeated by the Harvard freshmen--52 to o. NEW HAVEN Comm, Nov. 6.-The Yale varsity football team this after noon defeated the team representing the Chicago Athletic Club by a score of III to q. The scoring was all done in the first half. and with something OF a rush. The second half was some what uninteresting. owing TO a change of tactics from aggressiveness to care ful defense. ITHACA On. “. Nov 6.-Corneil easily defeated Pennsylvania State Col lege by the largest score the Ithacans have rolled up this years to O. WEST POINT fN. W. Nov Elm a perfect gale of wind Lehigh met the Cadsts on the field to. Say, and the game was absolutely one-slded from the beginning, West Point winning by As to q.

  • The Wood County reporter's story: GRIDIRON CONTESTS PENNSYLVANIA WINS FROM THE WIRY RED MEN CHICAGO'S GREAT VICTORY Stages Men Defeat Notre Dame by Score of "a to 5-Cleyeland Team Has an Exciting Experience Princeton Walks Right Through La Fayette-Other Games.

    Wood County reporter, Grand Rapids [i.e. Wisconsin Rapids], Wis., November 11, 1897, page 2

    Read the text

    GRIDIRON CONTESTS PENNSYLVANIA WINS FROM THE WIRY RED MEN CHICAGO’S GREAT VICTORY Stages Men Defeat Notre Dame by Score of “a to 5-Cleyeland Team Has an Exciting Experience Princeton Walks Right Through La Fayette-Other Games. Philadelphia, Nov. THE Uni versity of Pennsylvania football eleven Saturday defeated the Carlisle In dams, the score being 20 to 10. The red men kicked two goals from the field in the first half, while the red and blue scored tive touchdowns from which no goals resulted. In the sec end half, however, the Indians did not get within 35 yards Of Pennsylvania goal except on kicks, and theD Penn sylvania would rush the bali down the field. The Indians used the Princeton revolving wedge play for occasional gains, but could make little impress sion on Pennsylvania line ard would invariably resort to kicking. The red men played good, stiff football and fere remarkably susceptible to in juries. After nearly every scrimmage there would be an Indian stretched cut on the gridiron. Pennsylvania did lot try any tricks, relying wholly on straight football. This game was perhaps the most important played in the east Saturday in that it affords something of a line on the big eastern

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The text is the machine reading of the page, mistakes and all.

Before kickoff

Our ratings going in

Our ratings (scores only)

Pennsylvania 93% to win. Elo’s favorite won.

Pennsylvania leads 13–⁠6–⁠2 in 21 meetings, counting the 18 since this game.

Recent meetings
1917Pennsylvania 26, Carlisle 0
1914Pennsylvania 7, Carlisle 0
1913Carlisle 7, Pennsylvania 7
1912Pennsylvania 34, Carlisle 26
1911Carlisle 16, Pennsylvania 0
1910Pennsylvania 17, Carlisle 5

Around this game

Carlisle

Pennsylvania