Butch Davis, head coach at Miami, North Carolina and Florida International
Photo: Bobak Ha’Eri, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Butch Davis

Butch Davis went 103–⁠75 on the field as a head coach, 1995–⁠2021, at Miami, North Carolina and Florida International; 87–⁠75 officially, after the NCAA vacated 16 wins (2008 and 2009).

Record
87–⁠75 official; 103–⁠75 on the field
Seasons
15
Schools
3
Final AP top 10
1 season
Born
Nov 17, 1951
Alma mater
Arkansas 1974
Best season
2000 11–⁠1, No. 2

Season by season

Wins and losses each seasonfinal AP rank above★ national titleline: the team’s Elo at season’s end, best 1802 in 2000
SeasonSchoolRecordConference finishBowlAP final
1995Miami8–⁠3T–1st20
1996Miami9–⁠3T–1stCarquest Bowl W14
1997Miami5–⁠6T–5th
1998Miami9–⁠3T–2ndMicronPC Bowl W20
1999Miami9–⁠42ndGator Bowl W15
2000Miami11–⁠11stSugar Bowl W2
2001–⁠06: not a college head coach
2007North Carolina4–⁠84th (Coastal)
2008North Carolina8–⁠5 (0–⁠5 official)T–3rd (Coastal)Meineke Car Care Bowl L
2009North Carolina8–⁠5 (0–⁠5 official)4th (Coastal)Meineke Car Care Bowl L
2010North Carolina8–⁠5T–3rd (Coastal)Music City Bowl W
2011–⁠16: not a college head coach
2017Florida International8–⁠52nd (East)Gasparilla Bowl L
2018Florida International9–⁠4T–2nd (East)Bahamas Bowl W
2019Florida International6–⁠7T–5th (East)Camellia Bowl L
2020Florida International0–⁠56th (East)
2021Florida International1–⁠117th (East)

Each season links to the team’s season page; bowls and playoff games link to the game. Conference finishes from the Wikipedia article’s record table.

Players he coached

Every player from his seasons with a Heisman top-five finish, a national award, consensus All-America honors or a first-round pick. Photos: Wikimedia Commons, free licenses; credits on each player’s page.

How his teams did

Kind of gameGamesRecord
Against ranked teams3816–⁠22
Against top-10 teams135–⁠8
Against rivals328–⁠24
Conference games10962–⁠47
Bowls and playoffs106–⁠4
Decided by 8 points or fewer6836–⁠32
At home9160–⁠31
On the road7335–⁠38
At neutral sites148–⁠6
As our Elo’s favorite10277–⁠25
As our Elo’s underdog7626–⁠50

His own 178 games on file, 1995–⁠2021, as played (vacated wins counted, ties as half a win). Ranks are the AP poll going into the game; rivals are the ones either program’s Wikipedia article names; favorite and underdog by our own Elo rating, which reads only scores.

Against other head coaches

CoachRecordTheir schoolsGames
Frank Beamer 1995–⁠20102–⁠8Virginia Tech10
Tom O’Brien 1997–⁠20104–⁠4Boston College, NC State8
Bobby Bowden 1995–⁠20091–⁠6Florida State7
Don Nehlen 1995–⁠20005–⁠1West Virginia6
Paul Pasqualoni 1995–⁠20004–⁠2Syracuse6
Terry Shea 1996–⁠20005–⁠0Rutgers5
Rick Stockstill 2017–⁠20211–⁠4Middle Tennessee5
Walt Harris 1997–⁠20003–⁠1Pittsburgh4
Randy Shannon 2007–⁠20103–⁠1Miami4
Ron Dickerson 1995–⁠19973–⁠0Temple3

Butch Davis’s record against the head coaches he met three or more times, from the games on file, as played.

Most-faced opponents

OpponentGamesRecord
Virginia Techseries102–⁠8
Boston Collegeseries88–⁠0
Rutgersseries88–⁠0
Florida Stateseries82–⁠6
Templeseries76–⁠1
Pittsburghseries75–⁠2
West Virginiaseries75–⁠2
Syracuseseries64–⁠2

Career

YearsTeamJob
1973Fayetteville HS (AR) high schoolDefensive coordinator
1974–⁠75Pawhuska HS (OK) high schoolDefensive coordinator
1976–⁠77Charles Page HS (OK) high schoolDefensive coordinator
1978Will Rogers HS (OK) high schoolHead coach
1979–⁠83Oklahoma StateTight ends and wide receivers coach
1984–⁠88Miami (FL)Defensive line coach
1989–⁠92Dallas Cowboys NFLDefensive line coach
1993–⁠94Dallas Cowboys NFLDefensive coordinator
1995–⁠2000Miami (FL)Head coach
2001–⁠04Cleveland Browns NFLHead coach
2007–⁠10North CarolinaHead coach
2017–⁠21FIUHead coach

Every job as the infobox of his Wikipedia article lists it (CC BY-SA), assistant jobs included.

Coaching tree

Worked under

Butch Davis

Assistants who became head coaches

Worked under (2)
Head coachTeamYearsHis job
Jimmy JohnsonOklahoma State1979–⁠83Tight ends and wide receivers coach
Jimmy JohnsonMiami1984–⁠88Defensive line coach
Jimmy JohnsonDallas Cowboys NFL1989–⁠931989–⁠92: defensive line coach; 1993: defensive coordinator
Barry SwitzerDallas Cowboys NFL1994Defensive coordinator
Coached under him, later head coaches (22)
CoachWith himHead coach at
Chuck PaganoMiami, 1995–⁠2000: defensive backs and special teams coach; Cleveland Browns, 2001–⁠04: defensive backs coach; North Carolina, 2007: defensive coordinatorIndianapolis Colts
Larry CokerMiami, 1995–⁠2000: offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coachMiami, UTSA
Randy ShannonMiami, 1995–⁠97: linebackers coachMiami, Florida
Rob ChudzinskiMiami, 1995: graduate assistant; 1996–⁠2000: tight ends coach; Cleveland Browns, 2004: tight ends coachCleveland Browns
Curtis JohnsonMiami, 1996–⁠2000: wide receivers coachTulane, Houston Roughnecks / Gamblers
Mario CristobalMiami, 1998–⁠2000: graduate assistantFlorida International, Oregon, Miami
Greg SchianoMiami, 1999–⁠2000: defensive coordinatorRutgers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Bruce AriansCleveland Browns, 2001–⁠03: offensive coordinatorTemple, Indianapolis Colts, Arizona Cardinals, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Foge FazioCleveland Browns, 2001–⁠02: defensive coordinatorPittsburgh
Steve HagenCleveland Browns, 2001–⁠03: tight ends coach; 2004: quarterbacks coach; North Carolina, 2007–⁠08: tight ends coachWartburg
Andre PattersonCleveland Browns, 2003–⁠04: defensive line coachCal Poly
Dave CampoCleveland Browns, 2003–⁠04: defensive coordinatorDallas Cowboys
Fred GravesCleveland Browns, 2004: wide receivers coachSan Diego Chargers
John BlakeNorth Carolina, 2007–⁠10: defensive line coachOklahoma
Sam PittmanNorth Carolina, 2007–⁠10: offensive line coachArkansas, Hutchinson
Brad DavisNorth Carolina, 2008: graduate assistantLSU
Everett WithersNorth Carolina, 2008–⁠10: defensive coordinator and defensive backs coach; Florida International, 2021: assistant head coach, defensive coordinator and safeties coachNorth Carolina, Texas State, Temple, James Madison
Brent GuyFlorida International, 2017–⁠18: defensive coordinatorUtah State
Rich SkroskyFlorida International, 2017–⁠20: offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coachRamapo, Elon
Thomas SydeskiFlorida International, 2018: offensive quality control coachMercyhurst
Jerod KruseFlorida International, 2019–⁠20: co-defensive coordinatorWilliam Jewell
Andrew BreinerFlorida International, 2021: offensive coordinator and wide receivers coachFordham
Other assistants under him (14)
CoachWith him
Bill MillerMiami, 1995–⁠98: defensive coordinator
Keith ButlerCleveland Browns, 2001–⁠02: linebackers coach
Clancy PendergastCleveland Browns, 2003: linebackers coach
Kennedy PolamaluCleveland Browns, 2004: running backs coach
Taver JohnsonCleveland Browns, 2004: assistant special teams coach
John DunnNorth Carolina, 2007: graduate assistant
John LovettNorth Carolina, 2007–⁠08: special teams coordinator
John ShoopNorth Carolina, 2007–⁠10: offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach
Tommy ThigpenNorth Carolina, 2007–⁠08: linebackers coach
Art KaufmanNorth Carolina, 2009–⁠10: linebackers coach
Josh GattisNorth Carolina, 2010: graduate assistant
Tim Harris Jr.Florida International, 2017–⁠19: running backs coach; 2020: offensive coordinator and running backs coach
Brandon HarrisFlorida International, 2019: graduate assistant; 2021: cornerbacks coach
Jeff CoppFlorida International, 2019–⁠20: co-defensive coordinator

From coaches’ Wikipedia infoboxes (CC BY-SA) and each season’s article for its coordinators: an assistant’s seasons at a school count under its head coach in our records; jobs in the NFL and elsewhere, under the head coach whose own article lists the job that year. Names without a page here link to their Wikipedia articles.

Pay

YearSchoolJobContract pay
2017Florida Internationalhead coachbonuses up to $550,000; buyout $4,110,569$900,000 USA Today
2010North Carolinahead coachbonuses up to $105,000$1,752,000 USA Today via Leeds
2009North Carolinahead coachbonuses up to $105,000$1,702,000 USA Today via Leeds
2008North Carolinahead coach$2,100,000 USA Today via Leeds
2007North Carolinahead coachbonuses up to $95,333$1,910,000 USA Today via Leeds

USA Today’s coaches salary database (2014–⁠17, from public-records requests to the schools; Rachel Ehlers’ copy): the season’s contract pay, school pay plus outside money, before bonuses.

The same USA Today database for 2006–⁠16, from Michael Leeds’ replication data on Harvard Dataverse (CC0): the season’s contract pay.

Pay of public employees in their public job only: head coaches, and assistants in the seasons our records name them a coordinator, at public universities.

How he coached

Davis’s teams went for it on 19% of fourth downs and on 37% of those where the model said go for it, passed on 49% of plays and took 26.5 seconds a play, 2007–⁠2021.

SeasonSchoolWent for it on fourthWhen the model said goPass rateSeconds a playEPA a play
2007 11 gNorth Carolina18 of 91 20%30%53%24.6−0.17
2008 13 gNorth Carolina14 of 94 15%35%45%27.5−0.07
2009 13 gNorth Carolina15 of 104 14%33%47%31.7−0.12
2010 13 gNorth Carolina23 of 100 23%47%53%25.60.00
2018 13 gFlorida International22 of 82 27%53%46%26.7+0.17
2019 13 gFlorida International24 of 108 22%37%46%24.9+0.03
2020 5 gFlorida International12 of 48 25%56%48%25.3−0.17
2021 9 gFlorida International10 of 87 11%16%55%24.5−0.03
All 90 g138 of 714 19%37%49%26.5−0.03

His seasons as a head coach from 2004 on, from ESPN’s play by play: fourth downs where he went for it out of every fourth-down decision; how often he went when SportsDataverse’s fourth-down model said going for it was the better call; the share of his offense’s plays that were passes; seconds of game clock per offensive play (lower is faster); and expected points added per offensive play (EPA, a measure of how much each play moved the offense toward points). The season in progress counts its games so far. SportsDataverse’s coach tendencies, from ESPN’s play by play; the EPA and the fourth-down model are SportsDataverse’s.