The 1958 All-America teams
9 selectors named All-America teams for 1958; the NCAA counts 6 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1958 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
AP
Associated Press
First team
- EBuddy Dial, Rice
- EJim Houston, Ohio State
- OTTed Bates, Oregon State
- OTBrock Strom, Air Force
- OGZeke Smith, Auburn
- OGGeorge Deiderich, Vanderbilt
- CBob Harrison, Oklahoma
- QBRandy Duncan, Iowa
- RBBilly Cannon, LSU
- RBPete Dawkins, Army
- FBBill Austin, Rutgers
Second team
- EMonty Stickles, Notre Dame
- ECarroll Dale, Virginia Tech
- OTRon Luciano, Syracuse
- OTDon Floyd, TCU
- OGJohn Guzik, Pittsburgh
- OGJerry Stalcup, Wisconsin
- CJackie Burkett, Auburn
- QBDon Meredith, SMU
- RBBob Anderson, Army
- RBDick Bass, Pacific
- FBBob White, Ohio State
Third team
- EJim Wood, Oklahoma State
- ERich Kreitling, Illinois
- OTVel Heckman, Florida
- OTGene Selawski, Purdue
- OGBob Novogratz, Army
- OGStan Renning, Montana
- CMax Fugler, LSU
- QBJoe Kapp, California
- RBRon Burton, Northwestern
- RBAlex Hawkins, South Carolina
- FBNick Pietrosante, Notre Dame
FWAA
Football Writers Association of America
- EBuddy Dial, Rice
- EJim Houston, Ohio State
- EAl Goldstein, North Carolina
- ECurt Merz, Iowa
- OTAndy Cvercko, Northwestern
- OTDon Floyd, TCU
- OTVel Heckman, Florida
- OTGene Selawski, Purdue
- OGJohn Guzik, Pittsburgh
- OGZeke Smith, Auburn
- OGGeorge Deiderich, Vanderbilt
- OGBob Novogratz, Army
- CBob Harrison, Oklahoma
- CMax Fugler, LSU
- QBRandy Duncan, Iowa
- QBJoe Kapp, California
- QBDon Meredith, SMU
- RBBilly Cannon, LSU
- RBPete Dawkins, Army
- RBBob Anderson, Army
- FBBob White, Ohio State
- FBNick Pietrosante, Notre Dame
NEA
Newspaper Enterprise Association
First team
- EBuddy Dial, Rice
- EAl Goldstein, North Carolina
- OTTed Bates, Oregon State
- OTRon Luciano, Syracuse
- OGJohn Guzik, Pittsburgh
- OGZeke Smith, Auburn
- CBob Harrison, Oklahoma
- QBRandy Duncan, Iowa
- RBBilly Cannon, LSU
- RBPete Dawkins, Army
- FBBob White, Ohio State
Second team
- EJim Houston, Ohio State
- ECurt Merz, Iowa
- OTDon Floyd, TCU
- OTGene Selawski, Purdue
- OGGeorge Deiderich, Vanderbilt
- OGBob Novogratz, Army
- CJackie Burkett, Auburn
- QBJoe Kapp, California
- RBBob Anderson, Army
- RBDick Bass, Pacific
- FBNick Pietrosante, Notre Dame
Third team
- EMonty Stickles, Notre Dame
- EChris Burford, Stanford
- OTBrock Strom, Air Force
- OTVel Heckman, Florida
- OGJerry Stalcup, Wisconsin
- OGGeorge Fritzinger, Navy
- CMax Fugler, LSU
- RBJake Crouthamel, Dartmouth
- RBDon Perkins, New Mexico
- FBFred Pickard, Florida State
Sporting News
UPI
United Press International
First team
- EBuddy Dial, Rice
- ESam Williams, Michigan State
- OTTed Bates, Oregon State
- OTBrock Strom, Air Force
- OGJohn Guzik, Pittsburgh
- OGAl Ecuyer, Notre Dame
- CBob Harrison, Oklahoma
- QBRandy Duncan, Iowa
- RBBilly Cannon, LSU
- RBPete Dawkins, Army
- FBBob White, Ohio State
Second team
- EMonty Stickles, Notre Dame
- ERich Kreitling, Illinois
- OTRon Luciano, Syracuse
- OTVel Heckman, Florida
- OGZeke Smith, Auburn
- OGGeorge Deiderich, Vanderbilt
- CMax Fugler, LSU
- QBJoe Kapp, California
- QBDon Meredith, SMU
- RBBob Anderson, Army
- RBDick Bass, Pacific
Third team
- EJim Houston, Ohio State
- EJerry Wilson, Auburn
- OTJim Marshall, Ohio State
- OTDon Floyd, TCU
- OGBob Novogratz, Army
- OGTom Koenig, SMU
- CJackie Burkett, Auburn
- QBTom Greene, Holy Cross
- RBDick Thornton, Northwestern
- FBNick Pietrosante, Notre Dame
- FBBill Austin, Rutgers
- FBBob Jarus, Purdue
AFCA
American Football Coaches Association
- ESam Williams, Michigan State
- EJim Wood, Oklahoma State
- OTTed Bates, Oregon State
- OTHogan Wharton, Houston
- OGGeorge Deiderich, Vanderbilt
- OGJohn Wooten, Colorado
- CJackie Burkett, Auburn
- QBRandy Duncan, Iowa
- RBBilly Cannon, LSU
- RBPete Dawkins, Army
- FBNick Pietrosante, Notre Dame
Other selectors
Time
Time magazine
- EBuddy Dial, Rice
- ESam Williams, Michigan State
- OTJim Marshall, Ohio State
- OTBill Leeka, UCLA
- OGJohn Guzik, Pittsburgh
- OGZeke Smith, Auburn
- CJackie Burkett, Auburn
- QBJoe Kapp, California
- RBBilly Cannon, LSU
- RBDick Bass, Pacific
- FBBob White, Ohio State
Walter Camp
Walter Camp Football Foundation
Central Press
Central Press Association
From Wikipedia’s 1958 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.