The 1928 All-America teams
9 selectors named All-America teams for 1928; the NCAA counts 6 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1928 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
UP
United Press
First team
- EIrvine Phillips, California
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- OTOtto Pommerening, Michigan
- OTForrest Douds, Washington & Jefferson
- OGDon Robesky, Stanford
- OGGeorge Gibson, Minnesota
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBChuck Carroll, Washington
- FBKen Strong, New York Univ
Second team
- EMalcolm Franklin, St. Mary’s
- EKen Haycraft, Minnesota
- OTMike Getto, Pittsburgh
- OTButch Nowack, Illinois
- OGBill McRae, Florida
- OGBull Brown, Vanderbilt
- CCharles Howe, Princeton
- QBDon Williams, USC
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
- RBWarner Mizell, Georgia Tech
- RBBill Banker, Tulane
Third team
- EDick Abernathy, Vanderbilt
- EGeorge Barna, Hobart
- OTJesse Hibbs, USC
- OTGordy Brown, Texas
- OGDanny McMullen, Nebraska
- OGChoc Sanders, SMU
- CTim Moynihan, Notre Dame
- QBHoward Maple, Oregon State
- RBClyde Crabtree, Florida
- RBLloyd Brazil, Univ. of Detroit
- RBRedman Hume, Southern Methodist
Honorable mention
- EDale Van Sickel, Florida
- ETheodore Rosenzweig, Carnegie Tech
All America Board
- EIrvine Phillips, California
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- OTMike Getto, Pittsburgh
- OTButch Nowack, Illinois
- OGSeraphim Post, Stanford
- OGGeorge Gibson, Minnesota
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBChuck Carroll, Washington
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
North American Newspaper Alliance
- EIrvine Phillips, California
- EKen Haycraft, Minnesota
- OTMike Getto, Pittsburgh
- OTButch Nowack, Illinois
- OGDon Robesky, Stanford
- OGLeroy Wietz, Illinois
- CCharles Howe, Princeton
- QBDon Williams, USC
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
- RBWarner Mizell, Georgia Tech
AP
Associated Press
First team
- EDale Van Sickel, Florida
- EMalcolm Franklin, St. Mary’s
- OTOtto Pommerening, Michigan
- OTFrank Speer, Georgia Tech
- OGSeraphim Post, Stanford
- OGEdward Burke, Navy
- CCharles Howe, Princeton
- QBDutch Clark, Colorado College
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBChuck Carroll, Washington
- FBKen Strong, New York Univ
Second team
- EIrvine Phillips, California
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- OTMike Getto, Pittsburgh
- OTGordy Brown, Texas
- OGGeorge Gibson, Minnesota
- OGDanny McMullen, Nebraska
- CNate Barragar, USC
- QBHoward Maple, Oregon State
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
- RBWarner Mizell, Georgia Tech
- FBClifford Hoffman, Stanford
Third team
- EEdwin Messinger, Army
- EMiller Brown, Missouri
- OTButch Nowack, Illinois
- OTMelvyl Dressell, Washington State
- OGBruce Dumont, Colgate
- OGChoc Sanders, SMU
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBClyde Crabtree, Florida
- RBWillis Glassgow, Iowa
- FBGerald Snyder, Maryland
INS
International News Service
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- ETheodore Rosenzweig, Carnegie Tech
- OTOtto Pommerening, Michigan
- OTFred Miller, Notre Dame
- OGSeraphim Post, Stanford
- OGDanny McMullen, Nebraska
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
- RBWarner Mizell, Georgia Tech
- FBKen Strong, New York Univ
NEA
Newspaper Enterprise Association
First team
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- EDale Van Sickel, Florida
- OTMike Getto, Pittsburgh
- OTJesse Hibbs, USC
- OGSeraphim Post, Stanford
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
- FBKen Strong, New York Univ
Second team
- ETheodore Rosenzweig, Carnegie Tech
- OTAlfred “Al” Lassman, New York Univ
- OTJimmy Steele, Florida
- OGDon Robesky, Stanford
- OGEdward Burke, Navy
- CCharles Howe, Princeton
- RBChuck Carroll, Washington
- RBWarner Mizell, Georgia Tech
- RBLloyd Thomas, Univ. South. Calif
Third team
Other selectors
Walter Camp
Walter Camp Football Foundation
First team
- EIrvine Phillips, California
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- OTMike Getto, Pittsburgh
- OTButch Nowack, Illinois
- OGSeraphim Post, Stanford
- OGGeorge Gibson, Minnesota
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBChuck Carroll, Washington
- RBPaul Scull, Penn
Pan-American Bank
- EIrvine Phillips, California
- EEdwin Messinger, Army
- OTSteve Bancroft, California
- OTFred Miller, Notre Dame
- OGDanny McMullen, Nebraska
- OGJohn Dreshar, Carnegie Tech
- CCharles Howe, Princeton
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- RBLloyd Thomas, Univ. South. Calif
- FBMayes McLain, Iowa
Central Press
Central Press Association
First team
- EDick Abernathy, Vanderbilt
- ETheodore Rosenzweig, Carnegie Tech
- OTJesse Hibbs, USC
- OTGordy Brown, Texas
- OTRussell Crane, Illinois
- OGSeraphim Post, Stanford
- CCharles Howe, Princeton
- QBHoward Harpster, Carnegie Tech
- RBChris Cagle, Army
- FBKen Strong, New York Univ
- FBBlue Howell, Nebraska
Second team
- EWes Fesler, Ohio State
- EEdwin Messinger, Army
- OTAlfred “Al” Lassman, New York Univ
- OTBud Sprague, Army
- OGEdward Burke, Navy
- OGWaldo Wittenmeyer Greene, Yale
- CPeter Pund, Georgia Tech
- QBFrederick L. Hovde, Minnesota
- RBWarner Mizell, Georgia Tech
- RBWillis Glassgow, Iowa
- FBHerschel Burgess, Texas A&M
From Wikipedia’s 1928 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.