The 1925 All-America teams
17 selectors named All-America teams for 1925; the NCAA counts 8 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1925 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
All-America Board
The All-America Board
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- ECharles F. Born, Army
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Second team
- ETed Sloane, Drake
- ETed Shipkey, Stanford
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OTBud Sprague, Army
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGDana Carey, California
- CTim Lowry, Northwestern
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
- FBAllison “Pooley” Hubert, Alabama
Third team
- EChuck Kassel, Illinois
- ERay Wagner, Columbia
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OTHarry Hawkins, Michigan
- OGWalter Mahan, West Virginia
- OGZeke Wissinger, Pittsburgh
- CJeff Cravath, USC
- QBMorley Drury, U.S.C
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- FBTony Plansky, Georgetown
- FBElmer Tesreau, Washington
AP
Associated Press
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Second team
- EGeorge Thayer, Pennsylvania
- ECharles F. Born, Army
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGBill Buckler, Alabama
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
Third team
- EVic Hanson, Syracuse
- EJ.G. Lowe, Tennessee
- OTTom Edwards, Michigan
- OTHector Cyre, Gonzaga
- OGDana Carey, California
- OGWalter Mahan, West Virginia
- CHarold Hutchinson, Nebraska
- QBKenny Hyde, Colorado Aggies
- RBJackson Keefer, Brown
- RBJohnny Mack Brown, Alabama
- FBElmer Tesreau, Washington
Collier’s
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Grantland Rice
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Thayer, Pennsylvania
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Second team
- EDick Romey, Iowa
- EChuck Kassel, Illinois
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OTTom Edwards, Michigan
- OGDana Carey, California
- OGWalt Godwin, Georgia Tech
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
- FBAllison “Pooley” Hubert, Alabama
Third team
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- ECarl Bacchus, Missouri
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OTWalden Erickson, Washington
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- OGRay J. Stipek, Wisconsin
- CTim Lowry, Northwestern
- QBLester Lautenschlaeger, Tulane
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- RBJackson Keefer, Brown
- FBTony Plansky, Georgetown
FWAA
Football Writers Association of America
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- ETed Sloane, Drake
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OTHarry Hawkins, Michigan
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGBrice Taylor, USC
- CTim Lowry, Northwestern
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
INS
International News Service
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
NEA
Newspaper Enterprise Association
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
UP
United Press
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
Liberty magazine
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- EDick Romey, Iowa
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTJohnny Joss, Yale
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGDana Carey, California
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Other selectors
Athlete and Sportsman magazine
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGEmerson Carey, Cornell
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Billy Evans
Billy Evans’s “National Honor Roll
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGEd McMillan, Princeton
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- EGeorge Thayer, Pennsylvania
- ETed Sloane, Drake
- EChuck Kassel, Illinois
- ETed Shipkey, Stanford
- EJ.G. Lowe, Tennessee
- EGus Merkle, Georgia Tech
- EHobbs Adams, USC
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OTHarry Hawkins, Michigan
- OTJohnny Joss, Yale
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OTWalden Erickson, Washington
- OTGoldy Goldstein, Florida
- OTBob Rives, Vanderbilt
- OTJohn Sargent, California
- OTStonewall McMannon, Notre Dame
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- OGBrice Taylor, USC
- OGWalter Mahan, West Virginia
- OGBill Buckler, Alabama
- OGWalt Godwin, Georgia Tech
- OGBernie Shively, Illinois
- OGFred H. Swan, Stanford
- OGEgbert Brix, Washington
- OGClipper Smith, Notre Dame
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- CTim Lowry, Northwestern
- CJeff Cravath, USC
- CAmos Kent, Sewanee
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- QBMorley Drury, U.S.C
- QBGeorge Guttormsen, Washington
- QBBill Kelly, Montana
- QBEdgar C. Jones, Florida
- QBEarl Graham, Fordham
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- RBAl Kreuz, Penn
- RBJohnny Mack Brown, Alabama
- RBChristie Flanagan, Notre Dame
- RBAustin “Five Yards” McCarty, Chicago
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
- FBAllison “Pooley” Hubert, Alabama
- FBTony Plansky, Georgetown
- FBElmer Tesreau, Washington
- FBHerb Joesting, Minnesota
- FBLoren L. Lewis, Northwestern
- FBDoug Wycoff, Georgia Tech
- FBWindy White, VMI
- FBAndy Gustafson, Pitt
Second team
- ECharles F. Born, Army
- EChuck Kassel, Illinois
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OTJohnny Joss, Yale
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGWalter Mahan, West Virginia
- CTim Lowry, Northwestern
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
Norman E. Brown
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTBub Henderson, Chicago
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Second team
- ETed Shipkey, Stanford
- EEdwards, Washington & Jefferson
- OTJohnny Joss, Yale
- OTTom Edwards, Michigan
- OGDana Carey, California
- OGKilgore, Harvard
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- RBRalph Baker, Northwestern
- FBAllison “Pooley” Hubert, Alabama
- FBBo Molenda, Michigan
Knute Rockne
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Thayer, Pennsylvania
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- OGWalt Godwin, Georgia Tech
- OGErnest Schmidt, Army
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
The Sun
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTJohnny Joss, Yale
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
Second team
- EGeorge Thayer, Pennsylvania
- ECharles F. Born, Army
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OGKilgore, Harvard
- OGAugust William Lentz Jr., Navy
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- QBGeorge Pease, Columbia
- RBAl Kreuz, Penn
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
- FBTony Plansky, Georgetown
Walter Camp
Walter Camp Football Foundation
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- ECharles F. Born, Army
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Walter Eckersall
First team
- EBennie Oosterbaan, Michigan
- ELaVern Dilweg, Marquette
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTTom Edwards, Michigan
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGHerbert Sturhahn, Yale
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- FBErnie Nevers, Stanford
Second team
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- EChuck Kassel, Illinois
- OTRalph E. Chase, Pittsburgh
- OTNathan Parker, Dartmouth
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGLen Walsh, Minnesota
- CHarold Hutchinson, Nebraska
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
- FBJacob Slagle, Princeton
- FBAllison “Pooley” Hubert, Alabama
Third team
- EGeorge Thayer, Pennsylvania
- ETed Sloane, Drake
- OTHarry Hawkins, Michigan
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OGWalter Mahan, West Virginia
- OGBill Buckler, Alabama
- CTim Lowry, Northwestern
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
- RBJackson Keefer, Brown
- RBDoyle Harmon, Wisconsin
- FBRex Enright, Notre Dame
Sam Willaman
- EGeorge Tully, Dartmouth
- ETed Shipkey, Stanford
- OTEd Lindenmeyer, Missouri
- OTBud Sprague, Army
- OGCarl Diehl, Dartmouth
- OGBrice Taylor, USC
- CRobert Brown, Michigan
- QBBenny Friedman, Michigan
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBEddie Tryon, Colgate
Herbert Reed
- ECookie Cunningham, Ohio State
- EHenry Baxter, Army
- OTEd Weir, Nebraska
- OTRip Bachor, Detroit
- OGEd Hess, Ohio State
- OGMerwin Mitterwallner, Illinois
- CEd McMillan, Princeton
- RBAndy Oberlander, Dartmouth
- RBRed Grange, Illinois
- RBWildcat Wilson, Washington
- RBPeggy Flournoy, Tulane
From Wikipedia’s 1925 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.