The 1912 All-America teams
16 selectors named All-America teams for 1912; the NCAA counts one of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1912 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Butler, Wisconsin
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGJohn Logan, Princeton
- QBGeorge Crowther, Brown
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
Second team
- EDexter Very, Penn. State
- EJoseph Hoeffel, Wisconsin
- OTJim Trickey, Iowa
- OTRudy Probst, Syracuse
- OGCarroll T. Cooney, Yale
- OGD.H. Kulp, Brown
- CDerric Choate Parmenter, Harvard
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBDave Morey, Dartmouth
- RBNelson Norgren, Chicago
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
Third team
- EBusty Ashbaugh, Brown
- EAl Jordan, Bucknell
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OTClark Shaughnessy, Minnesota
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRay L. Bennett, Dartmouth
- CArthur Bluethenthal, Princeton
- QBEverett Bacon, Wesleyan
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
- RBLewie Hardage, Vanderbilt
- FBSpencer Armstrong Pumpelly, Yale
Other selectors
Composite Eleven
Composite Eleven selected by Louis A. Dougher in the Washington Times
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
Second team
- EDexter Very, Penn. State
- EK.P. Gilchrist, Navy
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OTJoe Guyon, Carlisle
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRay L. Bennett, Dartmouth
- CArthur Bluethenthal, Princeton
- QBEverett Bacon, Wesleyan
- QBShorty Miller, Penn State
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
- FBHuntington Hardwick, Harvard
The New York Sun
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EDexter Very, Penn. State
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- QBEverett Bacon, Wesleyan
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBHuntington Hardwick, Harvard
Second team
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- EK.P. Gilchrist, Navy
- OTJoe Guyon, Carlisle
- OTRudy Probst, Syracuse
- OGJohn James Munns, Cornell
- OGHamner Huston, Army
- CDerric Choate Parmenter, Harvard
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
- FBPete Mauthe, Penn State
The Philadelphia Inquirer
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EK.P. Gilchrist, Navy
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OTWilder Penfield, Princeton
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGTalbot Pendleton, Yale
- QBHenry Burchell Gardner, Harvard
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBWallace “Butch” De Witt, Princeton
Second team
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- EJohn O’Hearn, Cornell
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTHarvey Hitchock, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- CArthur Bluethenthal, Princeton
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBJesse Spalding, Yale
- RBE. Waller, Princeton
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
The Christian Science Monitor
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OTHarvey Hitchock, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- QBEddie Gillette, Wisconsin
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
The Baltimore Sun
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EK.P. Gilchrist, Navy
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRay L. Bennett, Dartmouth
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
Robert W. Edgren
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- QBEverett Bacon, Wesleyan
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBWallace “Butch” De Witt, Princeton
W.J. MacBeth
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OTJoe Guyon, Carlisle
- OGCarroll T. Cooney, Yale
- QBGeorge Crowther, Brown
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBDave Morey, Dartmouth
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
Tommy Clark
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EBusty Ashbaugh, Brown
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGGeorge T. Howe, Navy
- QBEddie Gillette, Wisconsin
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBHuntington Hardwick, Harvard
Parke H. Davis
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTPhillips, Princeton
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- CHoward L. Benson, Lafayette
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
Glenn S. “Pop” Warner
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EDexter Very, Penn. State
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBPete Mauthe, Penn State
Trenton Evening Times
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OTPhillips, Princeton
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- QBHenry Burchell Gardner, Harvard
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
Hamilton Fish III
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRay L. Bennett, Dartmouth
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
Second team
- EK.P. Gilchrist, Navy
- EBusty Ashbaugh, Brown
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Butler, Wisconsin
- OTHarvey Hitchock, Harvard
- CArthur Bluethenthal, Princeton
- CDerric Choate Parmenter, Harvard
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- FBLeroy Mercer, Penn
- FBHuntington Hardwick, Harvard
- FBGeorge C. Thomson, Michigan
The Philadelphia Press
First team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EDexter Very, Penn. State
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OGJohn Brown, Navy
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
Second team
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- ELon Jourdet, Penn
- OTPhillips, Princeton
- OTWagonhurst, Lafayette
- OGRay L. Bennett, Dartmouth
- OGTalbot Pendleton, Yale
- CSimpson, Penn State
- QBShorty Miller, Penn State
- RBAlex Arcasa, Carlisle
- FBWallace “Butch” De Witt, Princeton
- FBHuntington Hardwick, Harvard
Third team
- EK.P. Gilchrist, Navy
- EHarold R. Eyrick, Cornell
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OTAl Wilson, Penn State
- OGBritain Patterson, William & Jefferson
- OGJames “Red” Bebout, Penn State
- CArthur Bluethenthal, Princeton
- QBHenry Burchell Gardner, Harvard
- RBL. Fred Gieg, Swarthmore
- RBS.W. Harrington, Penn
- FBPete Mauthe, Penn State
Meriden Daily Journal
Meriden Daily Journal from New Haven County
First team
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- EFrancis Joseph O’Brien, Harvard
- OTWesley Englehorn, Dartmouth
- OTHarvey Hitchock, Harvard
- OGRay L. Bennett, Dartmouth
- OGGerard Timothy Driscoll, Harvard
- QBHarry Costello, Georgetown
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- RBHobey Baker, Princeton
Second team
- EDouglas Bomeisler, Yale
- EDexter Very, Penn. State
- OTBob Storer, Harvard
- OTLeland Devore, Army
- OTJoe Guyon, Carlisle
- OGRip Shenk, Princeton
- CArthur Bluethenthal, Princeton
- QBPat Pazetti, Lehigh
- RBDave Morey, Dartmouth
- RBTed Hudson, Trinity
- FBPercy Wendell, Harvard
Alfred S. Harvey
Alfred S. Harvey of the Milwaukee Free Press
First team
- ESam Felton, Harvard
- EMiller Pontius, Michigan
- OTBob Butler, Wisconsin
- OTJim Trickey, Iowa
- OGStan Pennock, Harvard
- OGJohn Logan, Princeton
- QBEddie Gillette, Wisconsin
- RBCharles E. Brickley, Harvard
- RBJim Thorpe, Carlisle
- FBRay Eichenlaub, Notre Dame
From Wikipedia’s 1912 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.