The 1904 All-America teams
10 selectors named All-America teams for 1904; the NCAA counts 2 of them toward its consensus team. Bold names are consensus All-Americans. The consensus team is on the 1904 season page.
Selectors the NCAA recognizes
Walter Camp
Collier’s Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
First team
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRalph Kinney, Yale
- CArthur Tipton, Army
- QBVince Stevenson, Penn
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- RBWillie Heston, Michigan
- FBWalter Eckersall, Chicago
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
Second team
- EGarfield Weede, Penn
- EAlexander Garfield Gillespie, Army
- OTJoe Curtis, Michigan
- OTTom Thorp, Columbia
- OGJoseph Gilman, Dartmouth
- OGRoswell Tripp, Yale
- CClint Roraback, Yale
- QBFoster Rockwell, Yale
- RBMarshall Reynolds, Penn
- RBJack Hubbard, Amherst
- FBPhilip O. Mills, Harvard
Third team
Caspar Whitney
Caspar Whitney for Outing magazine
First team
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- EFrederick A. Speik, Chicago
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGJoseph Gilman, Dartmouth
- CArthur Tipton, Army
- QBFoster Rockwell, Yale
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- FBWalter Eckersall, Chicago
- FBHenry Torney, Army
Second team
- ERalph Glaze, Dartmouth
- ERuss, Brown
- OTJames Bloomer, Yale
- OTTom Thorp, Columbia
- OGRalph Kinney, Yale
- OGRoswell Tripp, Yale
- CRobert Torrey, Penn
- QBDillwyn Parrish Starr, Harvard
- RBLydig Hoyt, Yale
- RBJack Hubbard, Amherst
- RBFrederick A. Prince, Army
Other selectors
New York Sun
First team
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- EGarfield Weede, Penn
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRoswell Tripp, Yale
- CArthur Tipton, Army
- QBFoster Rockwell, Yale
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- RBLydig Hoyt, Yale
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
Second team
- EChester T. Neal, Yale
- EThomas W. Hammond, Army
- OTJames Bloomer, Yale
- OTTom Thorp, Columbia
- OGRalph Kinney, Yale
- OGShort, Princeton
- CClint Roraback, Yale
- QBVince Stevenson, Penn
- RBJack Owsley, Yale
- RBMarshall Reynolds, Penn
- FBPhilip O. Mills, Harvard
New York Tribune
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- EChester T. Neal, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OTJames Bloomer, Yale
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRalph Kinney, Yale
- CClint Roraback, Yale
- QBVince Stevenson, Penn
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- RBMarshall Reynolds, Penn
- FBHenry Torney, Army
New York Herald
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- ERalph Glaze, Dartmouth
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRoswell Tripp, Yale
- CArthur Tipton, Army
- QBFoster Rockwell, Yale
- RBLydig Hoyt, Yale
- RBW.E. Metzenthin, Columbia
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
New York Press
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- EThomas W. Hammond, Army
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGShort, Princeton
- CArthur Tipton, Army
- QBVince Stevenson, Penn
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- RBLydig Hoyt, Yale
- FBPhilip O. Mills, Harvard
New York Evening Telegram
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- ERalph Glaze, Dartmouth
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRoswell Tripp, Yale
- CClint Roraback, Yale
- QBFoster Rockwell, Yale
- RBWillie Heston, Michigan
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
- FBHenry Torney, Army
Philadelphia North American
First team
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- EGarfield Weede, Penn
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Bloomer, Yale
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRalph Kinney, Yale
- CClint Roraback, Yale
- QBVince Stevenson, Penn
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- RBMarshall Reynolds, Penn
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
Philadelphia Inquirer
- ETom Shevlin, Yale
- EChester T. Neal, Yale
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJames Cooney, Princeton
- OGFrank Piekarski, Penn
- OGRoswell Tripp, Yale
- CClint Roraback, Yale
- QBVince Stevenson, Penn
- RBDaniel Hurley, Harvard
- RBW.C. Leavenworth, Yale
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
Fred Lowenthal
- EClaude Rothgeb, Illinois
- EJames Bush, Wisconsin
- OTJames Hogan, Yale
- OTJoe Curtis, Michigan
- OTJames Bloomer, Yale
- OGWalton W. Thorp, Minnesota
- OGCharles A. Fairweather, Illinois
- CJohn M. Haselwood, Illinois
- RBWillie Heston, Michigan
- RBWalter L. Foulke, Princeton
- FBWalter Eckersall, Chicago
- FBAndy Smith, Penn
- FBMark Catlin Sr., Chicago
From Wikipedia’s 1904 All-America article (CC BY-SA 4.0): each player’s selectors as the article lists them, named from its key. A selector with one team has no team number.