Syracuse vs. West Virginia

Syracuse and West Virginia have 61 meetings on file, the first in 1945; Syracuse leads the series 34–⁠27 in the games on file. Over the last 10 meetings it’s West Virginia 6–⁠4, and Syracuse has won the last 4. The winner takes home the Ben Schwartzwalder Trophy. Syracuse holds it.

Syracuse wins
34
West Virginia wins
27
Ties
0
Earliest on file
1945
Longest streak
8 West Virginia
Current streak
4 Syracuse
Last 10 meetings
West Virginia 6–⁠4
Most recent
2018

The series at a glance

Every meeting by decade, colored by the winner
’0’1’2’3’4’5’6’7’8’9W–L
1940s1–⁠1
1950s4–⁠1
1960s6–⁠4
1970s5–⁠5
1980s5–⁠5
1990s7–⁠3
2000s2–⁠8
2010s4–⁠0
Both ranked
3 meetings: Syracuse 2, West Virginia 1
Average margin
15.4 points; 20 decided by one score (8 or fewer)
At Syracuse
18–⁠10 Syracuse’s record at home
At West Virginia
17–⁠13 West Virginia’s record at home
Neutral sites
3–⁠0 Syracuse first
Shutouts
9

Every meeting on file, as played. Ranks are the AP poll’s going in.

Ben Schwartzwalder Trophy

Played for since
—
Held by
Syracuse

Who holds it comes from the games on file: the winner of the latest regular-season meeting (bowl rematches aren’t played for it); a tie leaves it with the holder (the usual rule; the article doesn’t say). From Wikipedia’s list of rivalry games and the rivalry’s article (CC BY-SA). More on the Ben Schwartzwalder Trophy.

Games that tell the story

  1. Syracuse’s biggest win1960: Syracuse 45, West Virginia 0by 45 points
  2. West Virginia’s biggest win1993: West Virginia 43, Syracuse 0by 43 points
  3. Upset2010: Syracuse 19, West Virginia 14Syracuse had a 22% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  4. Upset1962: West Virginia 17, Syracuse 6West Virginia had a 29% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  5. Upset1955: Syracuse 20, West Virginia 13Syracuse had a 32% chance, by our ratings before kickoff
  6. Ranked showdown1988: West Virginia 31, Syracuse 9No. 14 Syracuse at No. 4 West Virginia
  7. Ranked showdown2018: Syracuse 34, West Virginia 18No. 15 West Virginia at No. 17 Syracuse
  8. Ranked showdown1992: Syracuse 20, West Virginia 17No. 14 Syracuse at No. 24 West Virginia

Coach against coach

YearsSyracuseSeriesWest Virginia
1955–⁠1959Ben Schwartzwalder4–⁠1Art Lewis
1960–⁠1965Ben Schwartzwalder4–⁠2Gene Corum
1966–⁠1969Ben Schwartzwalder2–⁠2Jim Carlen
1970–⁠1973Ben Schwartzwalder1–⁠3Bobby Bowden
1976–⁠1979Frank Maloney3–⁠1Frank Cignetti
1981–⁠1990Dick MacPherson5–⁠5Don Nehlen
1991–⁠2000Paul Pasqualoni7–⁠3Don Nehlen
2001–⁠2004Paul Pasqualoni1–⁠3Rich Rodriguez
2005–⁠2007Greg Robinson0–⁠3Rich Rodriguez

Head-coach pairings with three or more meetings on file, the series read from Syracuse’s side (Schwartzwalder 4–⁠1 against Lewis). A season split between coaches goes to the one credited with the game.

Both programs through the years

End-of-season Elo ratings of Syracuse and West Virginia, 1945 on13001500170019501960197019801990200020102020

Our Elo rating at the end of each season, a measure of how strong a team was, not a forecast; 1500 is an average FBS team.

Stars of the series

Biggest days

Pat White West Virginia15 carries, 247 yards, 4 TD2006 Rushing
Tyson Gulley Syracuse26 carries, 213 yards, 2 TD2012 Rushing

Named most valuable

Eric Dungey Syracuse2018
Prince-Tyson Gulley2012

Biggest days: the week’s best individual games by our big-days rule, from box scores (2004 on). Most valuable: as the games’ Wikipedia articles name them (CC BY-SA).

From the newspapers

  • The The Republican. (Oakland, Md.) 1877-current's story of the 1946 game

    1946 · The Republican. (Oakland, Md.) 1877-current, Maryland, Oct 31, 1946

  • The Evening star's story of the 1959 game: Army's Caldwell Picked on Weekly AII-Eust Squad

    1959 · Evening star, Washington, D.C., Oct 27, 1959

  • The Evening star's story of the 1962 game: Mountoineers Topic Favored Orange, 17-6

    1962 · Evening star, Washington, D.C., Nov 25, 1962

Public-domain newspapers from the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America, found through the American Stories dataset (Dell and Harvard, CC BY 4.0). The earliest meetings with a story on file; each game’s page has the full text.

Every game

Dec 28, 201817Syracuse 34, 15West Virginia 18Camping World StadiumCamping World Bowl
Dec 29, 2012Syracuse 38, West Virginia 14Neutral sitePinstripe Bowl
Oct 21, 2011Syracuse 49, 11West Virginia 23at Syracuse
Oct 23, 2010Syracuse 19, 20West Virginia 14at West Virginia
Oct 10, 2009West Virginia 34, Syracuse 13at Syracuse
Oct 11, 2008West Virginia 17, Syracuse 6at West Virginia
Oct 6, 200713West Virginia 55, Syracuse 14at Syracuse
Oct 14, 20065West Virginia 41, Syracuse 17at West Virginia
Sep 4, 2005West Virginia 15, Syracuse 7at Syracuse
Oct 21, 200415West Virginia 27, Syracuse 6at West Virginia
Nov 22, 200325West Virginia 34, Syracuse 23at Syracuse
Oct 19, 2002West Virginia 34, Syracuse 7at West Virginia
Nov 10, 200118Syracuse 24, West Virginia 13at Syracuse
Nov 4, 2000Syracuse 31, West Virginia 27at West Virginia
Sep 25, 1999Syracuse 30, West Virginia 7at Syracuse
Nov 7, 1998West Virginia 35, 15Syracuse 28at West Virginia
Nov 1, 1997Syracuse 40, 17West Virginia 10at Syracuse
Nov 2, 1996Syracuse 30, 18West Virginia 7at West Virginia
Oct 21, 1995Syracuse 22, West Virginia 0at Syracuse
Nov 24, 1994West Virginia 13, 22Syracuse 0at West Virginia
Oct 30, 199313West Virginia 43, Syracuse 0at Syracuse
Oct 17, 199214Syracuse 20, 24West Virginia 17at West Virginia
Nov 23, 199116Syracuse 16, West Virginia 10at Syracuse
Nov 17, 1990Syracuse 31, West Virginia 7at West Virginia
Nov 23, 198917West Virginia 24, Syracuse 17at Syracuse
Nov 19, 19884West Virginia 31, 14Syracuse 9at West Virginia
Nov 21, 19876Syracuse 32, West Virginia 31at Syracuse
Nov 22, 1986Syracuse 34, West Virginia 23at West Virginia
Nov 30, 1985West Virginia 13, Syracuse 10at Syracuse
Oct 13, 1984West Virginia 20, Syracuse 10at West Virginia
Nov 19, 1983Syracuse 27, 14West Virginia 16at Syracuse
Nov 20, 198216West Virginia 26, Syracuse 0at West Virginia
Nov 21, 1981Syracuse 27, West Virginia 24at Syracuse
Nov 22, 1980Syracuse 20, West Virginia 7at West Virginia
Sep 15, 1979Syracuse 24, West Virginia 14Neutral site
Oct 7, 1978Syracuse 31, West Virginia 15at West Virginia
Nov 19, 1977Syracuse 28, West Virginia 9at Syracuse
Nov 20, 1976West Virginia 34, Syracuse 28at West Virginia
Nov 22, 1975Syracuse 20, West Virginia 19at Syracuse
Nov 9, 1974West Virginia 39, Syracuse 11at West Virginia
Nov 24, 1973West Virginia 24, Syracuse 14at Syracuse
Nov 18, 1972West Virginia 43, Syracuse 12at West Virginia
Nov 20, 1971Syracuse 28, West Virginia 24at Syracuse
Nov 14, 1970West Virginia 28, Syracuse 19at West Virginia
Nov 22, 196918West Virginia 13, Syracuse 10at Syracuse
Nov 23, 1968West Virginia 23, Syracuse 6at West Virginia
Sep 30, 1967Syracuse 23, West Virginia 6at Syracuse
Nov 19, 1966Syracuse 34, West Virginia 7at West Virginia
Nov 13, 1965Syracuse 41, West Virginia 19at West Virginia
Nov 21, 1964West Virginia 28, 9Syracuse 27at West Virginia
Nov 9, 1963Syracuse 15, West Virginia 13at Syracuse
Nov 24, 1962West Virginia 17, Syracuse 6at Syracuse
Sep 30, 1961Syracuse 29, West Virginia 14at Syracuse
Oct 22, 19603Syracuse 45, West Virginia 0at West Virginia
Oct 24, 19596Syracuse 44, West Virginia 0at Syracuse
Nov 22, 195810Syracuse 15, West Virginia 12at West Virginia
Nov 23, 1957West Virginia 7, Syracuse 0at West Virginia
Oct 13, 1956Syracuse 27, 20West Virginia 20at Syracuse
Nov 19, 1955Syracuse 20, West Virginia 13at West Virginia
Oct 26, 1946West Virginia 13, Syracuse 0at West Virginia
Oct 12, 1945Syracuse 12, West Virginia 0at Syracuse

Every game is listed as played on the field.