Newberry vs. Virginia Lynchburg

Every game is listed as played on the field.

• Newberry vs. The Citadel34 meetings, Newberry 4–⁠26–⁠4
• Newberry vs. Furman19 meetings, Newberry 3–⁠16
• Newberry vs. Presbyterian16 meetings, Newberry 5–⁠10–⁠1
• Newberry vs. Wofford14 meetings, Newberry 9–⁠4–⁠1