Indiana State vs. Valparaiso

Every game is listed as played on the field.

• Indiana State vs. Southern Illinois36 meetings, Indiana State 14–⁠22
• Indiana State vs. Illinois State33 meetings, Indiana State 11–⁠22
• Indiana State vs. Western Illinois24 meetings, Indiana State 11–⁠13
• Indiana State vs. Youngstown State23 meetings, Indiana State 7–⁠16
• Valparaiso vs. Drake23 meetings, Valparaiso 3–⁠20
• Valparaiso vs. Butler23 meetings, Valparaiso 9–⁠14
• Valparaiso vs. Morehead State22 meetings, Valparaiso 4–⁠18
• Valparaiso vs. Dayton20 meetings, Valparaiso 3–⁠17