Central Michigan vs. Colgate

Every game is listed as played on the field.

• Central Michigan vs. Western Michigan61 meetings, Central Michigan 32–⁠28–⁠1
• Central Michigan vs. Toledo52 meetings, Central Michigan 18–⁠31–⁠3
• Central Michigan vs. Eastern Michigan51 meetings, Central Michigan 34–⁠15–⁠2
• Central Michigan vs. Ball State49 meetings, Central Michigan 22–⁠26–⁠1
• Colgate vs. Cornell90 meetings, Colgate 39–⁠48–⁠3
• Colgate vs. Holy Cross67 meetings, Colgate 32–⁠30–⁠5
• Colgate vs. Syracuse61 meetings, Colgate 25–⁠32–⁠4
• Colgate vs. Bucknell55 meetings, Colgate 42–⁠13