Carnegie Mellon vs. Muhlenberg

Every game is listed as played on the field.

• Carnegie Mellon vs. Pittsburgh30 meetings, Carnegie Mellon 5–⁠24–⁠1
• Carnegie Mellon vs. Washington & Jefferson23 meetings, Carnegie Mellon 6–⁠12–⁠5
• Carnegie Mellon vs. Notre Dame19 meetings, Carnegie Mellon 4–⁠15
• Carnegie Mellon vs. New York University13 meetings, Carnegie Mellon 3–⁠10
• Muhlenberg vs. Lafayette15 meetings, Muhlenberg 3–⁠11–⁠1
• Muhlenberg vs. Lehigh14 meetings, Muhlenberg 2–⁠12
• Muhlenberg vs. Bucknell10 meetings, Muhlenberg 3–⁠6–⁠1