Quarterback, Middle Tennessee (from Troy, Northern Colorado), 2021–⁠26

Peter Costelli

Number
No. 11
Height
6′3″
Weight
222 lb
Class (2026)
Senior
Hometown
San Pedro, CA

Peter Costelli plays quarterback for Middle Tennessee, after Troy (2021–⁠22) and Northern Colorado (2024–⁠25). Last time out, against Delaware: 0 of 1, 0 yards.

2026 so far

0 passing yards

Last game: 0 of 1, 0 yards vs. Delaware, W 33–⁠30

Next game: at Florida International, Oct 20

Career highs

258passing yards, career highvs. Eastern Washington, 2024

Team titles: Sun Belt champions, 2022

Passing

Passing yards, season by season, with his team’s record

* The season in progress, so far.

SeasonTeamCmpAttPctYdsY/ATDInt
2024Northern Colorado387153.55868.342
2025Northern Colorado224153.72726.614
2026*Middle Tennessee010.000.000
Career6011353.18587.656

Rushing

SeasonTeamCarYdsAvgTDLong
2024Northern Colorado18884.9032
2025Northern Colorado16744.6119
2026*Middle Tennessee1−3−3.000
Career351594.5132

Season lines from CollegeFootballData, regular season and bowls. * That team-season’s player lines are missing part of the team’s yards in our source, so these numbers may be short.

On the roster

SeasonTeamNo.PosClassHtWt
2022Troy11QBRS
2024Northern Colorado11QBSo.
2025Northern Colorado11QBJr.
2026Middle Tennessee11QBSr.6′3″222

As each season’s roster listed the player (CollegeFootballData). Classes before the latest listing are counted back from it; “Yr 1” is the year on file where that count can’t place a season he played (a redshirt, transfer or 2020 year); height and weight as last listed.

Per play

SeasonTeamPlaysEPA/playPctileMedianTotalUsage
2024Northern Colorado (FCS)720.55––39.541%
2025Northern Colorado (FCS)570.18––10.419%
2026Middle Tennessee2-0.62––-1.2–

Expected points added: how much the player’s plays moved the team’s expected score, per play and in total. Plays: total EPA divided by EPA per play, the plays the source credits to him (for a receiver roughly his catches and runs, not every target; for a passer, not every attempt), so it can differ from attempts plus carries. Percentile: against the position’s regulars that season across all divisions on file (quarterbacks with 150+ plays, backs 60+, receivers and tight ends 30+), with how many there were (n) and their median; a dash means too few plays to rank. A season in progress uses the full-season bar scaled by games played, never below 75 plays for quarterbacks, 30 for backs and 20 for receivers. The cohort grows or shrinks with the source’s coverage each season (2025 lists far more players), so compare percentiles rather than raw EPA across years. FCS seasons are marked. Usage: the share of the team’s plays the player was part of (shown from 20 plays). From CollegeFootballData, 2013 on.

Game by game

2026 Middle Tennessee 1 game, 0 passing yards
DateOpponentResultCmpAttYdsTDIntRush
Oct 13vs.DelawareW 33–⁠3001000−3
2025 Northern Colorado 4 games, 272 passing yards, 1 TD
DateOpponentResultCmpAttYdsTDIntRush
Aug 30vs.Chadron StateW 17–⁠3612921042
Nov 1vs.Montana StateL 7–⁠55576400−5
Nov 8atNorthern ArizonaL 10–⁠4935290119
Nov 15atEastern WashingtonL 7–⁠27817870318
2024 Northern Colorado 3 games, 586 passing yards, 4 TD
DateOpponentResultCmpAttYdsTDIntRush
Aug 31atIncarnate WordL 7–⁠2816261410244
Sep 7atColorado StateL 17–⁠3811221872032
Nov 9vs.Eastern WashingtonL 15–⁠4311232582012

Box scores from CollegeFootballData, 2004 on. ✦ postseason; ★ a career high on file.

Is this you, or do you know of something wrong or missing here? Suggest a correction. We check each one against a source before changing the page.